4 ms·
There's a key difference in this case though, namely that it's not a case of a government trying to look forward and anticipate whether an ideology will cause d
by smacktoward 11y ago
There's a key difference in this case though, namely that it's not a case of a government trying to look forward and anticipate whether an ideology will cause damage, but instead a government looking back on an ideology that actually did cause damage.
Nazism cost millions of Germans their lives, led to one of the biggest campaigns of genocide in history and wrecked the economy, social structures and world perception of Germany for decades. So the question about it isn't so much "is this thing dangerous?" as "how can we best keep this dangerous thing from getting loose again?"
(Which isn't to say that banning it is necessarily the right way to do that; many have argued that banning it just gives it an air of uniqueness that makes it more attractive, rather than less. But nobody making that argument would go from there to say that Nazism is somehow morally neutral.)
- paulddraper 11y agoSo what we are going to do about the Crusades? Ban Christianity? Or what about the 34 to 49 million deaths at Stalin's hands? Ban Communism? Or what about terrorism? Ban Islam? This is a ridiculous position to argue.
- smacktoward 11y ago> Or about the 34 to 49 million deaths at Stalin's hands? Ban Communism? No, but the Russians did go through their own cultural reaction to Stalin's tyranny; see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De-Stalinization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De-Stalinization. Beyond that, by naming the entity doing the banning as "we" you're eliding a key point, which is that in this case it's the people who were responsible for the terrible thing doing the banning, not some outside entity. Germans decided, through a democratically elected government, to pursue this course. It wasn't forced on them by anybody. It has remained in law over many decades, across numerous changes of government and the reunification of East and West Germany, so it's hard to argue that it's somehow unrepresentative of the general desire of the German people. That's a very different thing than it would be if "we" (which on HN will mean primarily Westerners, mostly Americans) were to, say, tell the Islamic world which parts of Islam they should keep and which they should discard.
- paulddraper 11y agoDe-Stalinization was a good thing, because the man and his ideology were fundamentally and absolutely wrong. From the wikipedia headers: Improved prison conditions, Re-naming of places and buildings, Destruction of monuments, Re-location of Stalin's body. Notice that no part of that included banning ideas. It was the cession of government endorsement and a de facto fall from popularity. No one will fine or jail you for making a complimentary movie about Stalin. They just won't go see it.
- detaro 11y agoNote that many works (e.g. Mein Kampf and many of the "banned" Nazi movies) are not actually banned by law, but via copyright rules. You can sue against the ban of a brutal movie if you think the ban decision was wrong. You can't sue against the de-facto ban of the movies, and our parliament couldn't lift the ban by changing a law. A more-or-less private entity controls them, and many argue that some of not-banned movies are actually worse. There are laws against Nazi propaganda etc, but for quite a few things they aren't even applied and tested.
- bad_user 11y agoChristianity is about the New Testament and anybody that has ever read it knows that its teachings invite to tolerance and can never justify the crusades. That the crusades happened in the name of Christianity, that's what usually happens when you have an uneducated population that would believe anything. There is however a huge difference between the New Testament and Main Kampf. Should we ban Islam? I don't know, I know nothing of Islam. But on communism / Stalinism I think it's a disgrace that we conduct business with communist countries that are guilty of repeatedly violating human rights and yes I'm talking about China. It's a spit in the face of all those that have suffered under communism.
- Excavator 11y agoI'm unsure how one would find the numbers but aren't Islamism an ideology that affects the world in a very much the same way. And as for countries, doesn't Turkey have something of a track record when it comes to getting rid of unwanted groups, nowadays focusing on Kurds as I recall it? Or is this just some form of propaganda?