4 ms·
What if the pace of gameplay were slowed down 5x? Would execution still be an issue?
by stcredzero 11y ago
What if the pace of gameplay were slowed down 5x? Would execution still be an issue?
- daveguy 11y agoThat is a really good question. I would love to see tournament players playing against each other and non-pros in a 5x slower or 10x slower game. Among the pros would be most interesting. Does everyone now play about equally well? Does some random barely pro destroy the field because that player has a better grasp on the strategy that was convoluted by the rapid aspect. If you compare to chess, good blitz players aren't always good at long games and vice versa. Computers are much better at fast blitz games (beating pros well before Kasparov in 1996). I expect that even if DeepCraft performs well in a full speed game a slower more strategic game would have the humans at an advantage (at least for a while).
- ctvo 11y agoThis is like asking what basketball would be like if you weren't required to dribble. It might be interesting to think about, but would probably result in a different game.
- stcredzero 11y agoThis is like asking what basketball would be like if you weren't required to dribble. Not really. The "physical" aspect of Starcraft is an information input/output feat. It's still arguably the same abstract game. Arguably, it's no longer a sport however. (And maybe it wouldn't be a "game" in the sense that basketball and football are "games" for people.)
- ctvo 11y agoSolving THAT game (where we get as close as possible to a brain -> machine interface and it becomes completely strategic) is interesting, but it's not StarCraft. Arguably it's the same abstract game, but when you bypass constraints (applicable only to humans), you probably should have targeted something else without those constraints in the first place. In our case, a turn-based strategy game that is equally complex and with limited information (Civilization?!).