4 ms·
EFF and ACLU Expose Government’s Secret Stingray Use in Wisconsin Case
- nfncnchf 11y agoLet's not kid ourselves: between secret courts, tampering with investigative records, and institutionalized torture (now even of US citizens), we really are not much better than the USSR at this point.
- db48x 11y agoNo, we're still a lot better off than anyone in the USSR was. A number of defectors have written books you might want to familiarize yourself with. I recently read _The "Liberators"_, by Victor Suvorov; I recommend it.
- nickysielicki 11y agoHe said better, not better off.
- db48x 11y agoIndeed, I misread. Still, I disagree, and suggest that he read up on the subject. Even with the problems it has developed, our legal system is far superior to that of the USSR.
- chongli 11y agowe really are not much better than the USSR at this point Oh really? I guess I must've missed the part where over 10 million Americans starved to death under a program of forced collectivisation and a million more were killed by the secret police in a program of repression. Yeah, I didn't think so. The US government has done enough to criticize already without resorting to hyperbolic statements like that. It totally cheapens your argument.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- fkdkjdje 11y agoYeah instead the US is only responsible for millions of dead Iraq's, Syrians, Libyans, Afghans. The bombing of hospitals, torture, indefinite imprisonment of the innocent without trial. Get your head out of your ass.
- geomark 11y agoThat's different. The US gov isn't doing all that to their own citizens. So it's ok. At least that's how the US gov and a lot of US citizens feel. And the rest of US citizens don't care enough to do anything about it.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jrapdx3 11y agoThe article convincingly describes some rather underhanded behavior by federal law enforcement appearing to violate 4th Amendment rights. Of course it's hard to empathize with criminals, well, because of their crimes. At the same time it's not hard to want to protect the rights of the people from overzealous police. It would be ideal for attorneys and other experts to comment on this case. As portrayed in the article, an appellate court decision that the use of "Stringrays" requires a warrant before they are deployed would be a step in the right direction. I think there should be more restrictions on technologies that can grab thousands of communications at a time.
- throwaway_xx9 11y ago> Of course it's hard to empathize with criminals, well, because of their crimes. The accused in the American justice system is allowed a defense. Empathy has nothing to do with that right. Most people who are "criminals" were not convicted - they were plea-bargained. And many of those found guilty at trial were in fact innocent of any crime.
- beedogs 11y agoIt also kind of depends on the crime. I would have less of an issue with these sorts of devices being used in, say, a kidnapping investigation, than I would if they were used to catch street-level drug dealers.
- xbmcuser 11y agoDoes it really make a difference with or without warrant when police can ask secret courts etc to give judgements that can't be contested.
- uxp 11y agoThe defendant was out on parole, and had an arrest warrant issued for some other violation of his parole, and while sitting in a vehicle in the passenger seat, a weapon was at his feet. That's the entire context of this. A cop happened upon this vehicle and had "prior knowledge" that the defendant was in the car according to the police report [0]. I don't think he's even arguing that he had violated his parole, but that the cops are just flat out lying on how they found him. Sure, parole violations are bad, but this is just petty, run-of-the-mill arrests they are using stingrays on. [0] https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/2698299-12-1.html https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/2698299-12-1.html
- rasz_pl 11y agoAt first its criminals riding around with a gun on their lap, but soon you will get a cop visit at work because cell site simulator detected you blowing 10mph past speed limit on some back road few days ago.