6 ms·
10 gigabit Ethernet 80 GHz point-to-point bridges
- mey 11y ago• Secure communication due inability to intercept the laser-like beam transmission at free air I would not trust that as a security layer.
- walrus01 11y agoIt's definitely not something to trust in, but intercepting (at a layer 1 level) a PTP 80 GHz link is actually harder than tapping fiber. You'd have to have Rx equipment either directly in the path or directly behind both ends of the radio link. As compared to the effort required to cut an aerial or underground singlemode cable and fusion splice in place a passive prism split tap (basically the same thing as inserting a split in a GPON FTTH network). A practiced outside plant fiber crew of 2 persons and a bucket truck could do this with less than 5 minutes of downtime on a router-to-router optical interface, short enough time to clear any NMS alerts and prevent a repair team truck roll. Assuming we're talking about only two strands. Either way actual security is accomplished through standard based crypto, not obfuscation or preventing people from messing with the layer-1.
- omgtehlion 11y agoOn a fiber you don't need downtime at all. If you manage to carefully clean the fiber from isolation and buffer and then bend it just enough to leak some light into yours. So, assume that everything might be tapped and encrypt your data.
- walrus01 11y agoYes, or if your fast, cheap new metro ethernet 10GbE circuit between two buildings has been provisioned by your ISP as some form of transport (handoff into a WDM system, EoMPLS tunnel), etc, it's not difficult for them to 'mirror' your port. It could be pre-tapped before it was ever turned up for customer service. Or the splitter could be installed in your riser cable at one end, before you ever started moving packets across it. Or a myriad of other things.
- Spooky23 11y agoI recall reading about Soviet spies buying a cabin close to the AT&T long lines microwave path to intercept calls & fax transmissions in the 60s or 70s.
- walrus01 11y agohttp://www.lamont.me.uk/capenhurst/original.html http://www.lamont.me.uk/capenhurst/original.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/how-britain-eavesdropped-on-dublin-1106606.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/how-britain-eavesdropped-o...
- TeMPOraL 11y agoI wonder if introducing a semi-translucent obstacle, like a cloud of smoke, would be enough to capture the signal while not disrupting the original connection too much?
- rasz_pl 11y agoor a drone with a reflector
- jlgaddis 11y agoI haven't read the datasheet on this particular radio, but a lot of them do optionally support AES encryption (sometimes as an extra, paid feature).
- vessenes 11y agoOoh, I really want two of these. I'm stuck on an island with poor last mile service providers. But, I have line of sight to a number of spots with good quality fiber.
- Havoc 11y agoIf you've got line of sight then current (cheap) tech should do just fine. Sure not 10x gigabit but you can def get some decent internet...
- adrianpike 11y agoDo you have any recommendations for current products for line of sight?
- walrus01 11y agofor what dollar figure, distance and speeds? anywhere from $300/link (a pair of ubiquiti powerbeam AC 5 GHz) up to $20,000 for 1 to 10GbE licensed.
- Havoc 11y agoI don't have any first hand experience, but I know you can do long range (couple kilometers), reliable (for consumer level) decent speed links for dirt cheap (<150USD for each side with weather proofing etc) based on the WUGs in my home country (ZA). Detour paragraph - background - Internet has historically been pretty sht in South Africa so a enthusiast spider network of point to point links sprung up much like the ham radio movement. Government decided to OK it as long as its not commercial & doesn't deliver internet services. Anyway...the WUG websites (JAWUG, PTAWUG, CPTWUG - being Johannesburg/Pretoria/CapeTown) have lots of beginner style info on it (will trees and leaves in block it etc)...plus info on cheap kits...plus there are loads of people there that know this stuff in wild detail (as I said - 100% community driven so even the central high-sites are community run).
- mcpherrinm 11y agoI know some people who have successfully used Ubiquiti's airFiber for point-to-point links. I think those run on the order of $5 grand for a complete installation (two radios, mounts, etc) of a faster-than-gigabit link.
- alex_h 11y agoWhat kind of licensing (FCC or otherwise) would one need to operate such a radio bridge in the US? or is it public spectrum?
- walrus01 11y ago80 GHz is "light licensed" in the US, the paperwork requirements are not onerous. It's less costly and complicated than a regular part 101 licensed microwave link.
- ArnoldP 11y agoI have line of sight to the building where I work, I would love something like this so I could get gigabit internet at home w/o paying through the nose :)
- mikeyouse 11y agoCheck out Mimosa's offerings.. For a few hundred dollars you can get ~750mbps via unlicensed spectrum up to ~5km distance. https://www.mimosa.co/Products/Backhaul/backhaul-specs/B5-Lite-Specifications.html https://www.mimosa.co/Products/Backhaul/backhaul-specs/B5-Li... I know Ubiquti has similar products as well but I'm more familiar with Mimosa's.
- Havoc 11y agoMost employers would never let you hook that up - too much risk for zero gain (for them). Hell mine won't even let me bring my own screen to work. (It lacks some enterprise cert apparently).
- nixisfun 11y agoThis would get really bad rain fade at 80GHz or even on a humid day the speed would back off a lot. You need to run a lower frequency backup link in parallel.
- walrus01 11y agoThat's the nature of 80 GHz, design the links for your climate and don't try to go more than 2-3km. You can achieve five nines. And yes, run a 5.x GHz backup path in parallel.
- jessaustin 11y agoThe word "Ethernet" in the title is misleading. That word does not appear in TFA, which appears to discuss a radio transceiver. [EDIT:] I stand corrected; thanks!
- walrus01 11y agoIt has a 10GbE SFP+ optical interface and functions as a layer 2 ethernet bridge. From an ethernet port perspective same as 99% of the other PTP microwave and millimeter wave radios on the market. What's new is the 10Gb (vs existing radios with 1Gb SFP). Read the datasheet linked at the bottom of the page.
- jlgaddis 11y agoThey're transparent Ethernet bridges. They have Ethernet interfaces, you push an Ethernet frame in one side and the same Ethernet frame comes out the interface on the other side.
- wrigby 11y agoIt's interesting to see the huge channel bandwidths they're using to attain this. Advances like this are largely driven by higher sample rate ADCs and DACs becoming more viable in recent years. Edit for clarity: channel bandwidths in the datasheet are up to 2 GHz. Need to close the link at 32 QAM to hit 10 gb before error correction overhead at that bandwidth, which is certainly doable. Also, it's interesting to note that they quote 7 gbps throughput @ 1 GHz bandwidth, and 10 gbps at 2 GHz. It implies that they can run at 256 QAM at 1 GHz, but only 32 QAM at 2 GHz, which also makes sense. Having worked in the satellite communications industry, where channel sizes used to be limited to 72 MHz (because of hardware limitations of the spacecraft), getting modems designed to operate on larger channels is no small task. I would love to learn more about the internal architecture of these radios to understand exactly what's going on - are they using interleaved ADCs? Is the modulation/demodulation being done in an FPGA, or an ASIC? If there are terrestrial microwave engineers on here, I'd love to hear your thoughts on this!
- walrus01 11y agoterrestrial microwave engineer here: "80 GHz" is actually 71-86 GHz FDD. The original FCC band plan allowed for 5000 MHz wide channels each direction and basically OOK or BPSK level modulation. Newer radios use 250, 500 or 1000 MHZ wide FDD channels and QPSK or better. Incredibly wide channels can be used because it falls off in the atmosphere so rapidly after a few km, and the antennas are all very narrow parabolic reflectors with less than 1 degre beamwidth. Basically no colocation interference issues are possible unless two companies try to shoot from the same rooftop, to also the same rooftop, using the same channel AND the same linear polarity.
- walrus01 11y agoit's worth noting that this is just the first one publicly announced and not under NDA.. It's from a russian radar/microwave/millimeter wave manufacturer. All of the other much larger players such as Bridgewave also have 10 Gbps radios coming.
- martinald 11y agoInteresting. There has been a huge effort in the UK for mobile carriers to add fiber to as many cell towers as possible. Do people think this would undo this trend? I'm sure that 10gbit would be more than enough to carry the backhaul of 3G+4G with plenty of room to spare?
- walrus01 11y agonot really, fiber is still greatly preferred (For example: it's impossible to do 40Gb by microwave/millimeter wave, but a CWDM 4-channel 4x10GbE passive mux/demux on two strands of singlemode is trivial and very very cheap), or just a pair of 40Gb QSFP 10km reach optics using a single 1550nm wavelength between two routers or metro-E switches. But wireless can reach small cells, rooftops and towers that might be a very costly underground fiber build at $400-900/meter total construction cost to dig up streets in urban cores. It very much depends on the location.
- amazon_not 11y agoPlus there's the reliability factor. With fiber you only have to worry about backhoe fade. Wireless has all kinds of fun failure modes.
- walrus01 11y agoThough with small monopole and cellular rooftop sites, MW can frequently be built in a ring or redundant traffic path configuration. Fiber to many endpoint sites like a cell tower is frequently a star topology network with one cable in a linear path along a ROW either aerial or underground.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoCrap, now I need to go buy a couple of these and lobby the nearest data center for some rooftop space. That is the short way of saying I had no idea you could get antenna this effective for wireless data transmission. I'd seen the 5mbps ones but nothing close to a gigabit much less 10 gigabits. Time to draw a 10km radius circle around my home address :-)
- tlrobinson 11y agoI've seen up to about 400 Mbps on my Webpass [1] connection for a couple years, and I think that's pretty run-of-mill tech at this point [2] 1. https://webpass.net/ https://webpass.net/ 2. https://www.ubnt.com/broadband/ https://www.ubnt.com/broadband/
- walrus01 11y agoWebpass uses a fairly large number of Siklu 80 GHz 1 Gbps radios on rooftops for backbone links in SF.
- tyingq 11y agoThere are solutions that are lower end than this one, but still gigabit, at relatively affordable prices. This Ubiquiti setup is $999 per side: https://www.ubnt.com/airfiber/airfiber5/ https://www.ubnt.com/airfiber/airfiber5/
- walrus01 11y agoAn AF5 or AF5X PTP link isn't a transparent 1Gb full duplex bridge, realistically you'll achieve 250-400 Mbps max. They're great radios but physics is still physics, 40 or 80 MHz wide dual polarity channel at 256QAM 5/6 code rate is not 1GbE.
- tyingq 11y agoGiven the context that the parent was saying "I'd seen the 5mbps ones but nothing close to a gigabit", and was talking about a non-commercial setup, it still seems relevant. Also curious...they show 5470-5950 MHz...from my layperson standpoint, that seems to allow for more than 80MHz wide. What's the actual story? The UBNT forums seems to indicate 2 separate 50Mhz channels, one for TX...one for RX.
- mlakkadshaw 11y agoDo these products require a clear line of sight to work?
- amazon_not 11y agoYes.
- punnerud 11y agoWhat is the price for this?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- imauld 11y agoAnd here I am with 12MbS down/800KbS up
- zurn 11y agoAccording to Nielsen's law of bandwidth, consumer gigabit last mile should be common by now and 10G would be a logical next step development, becoming ubiquitous in 2020 or so. There's a huge number of houses with idle fiber installed 10+ years ago. Gigabit ethernet was introduced 17 years ago and carries 5 km over fiber. Cable is just waiting for providers to switch on 10 Gbps since years ago. Phone line copper has similar story.. Maybe something like this could jump-start the stalled development of last-mile consumer internet.
- revelation 11y agoYou can put the savings into better bandwidth for consumers or lower cost for ISPs. With no competitive pressure for the former in the majority of the country, providers have happily pocketed the 3+ order of magnitude improvements while providing the same old 1990 speed.
- amazon_not 11y agoSome of those savings are needed in order to be able to provide 100M/1G to the consumer: - 10G in the distribution - 100G in the core So, even with competitive pressure, consumers can't expect to receive the latest and greatest for peanuts.
- amazon_not 11y ago> There's a huge number of houses with idle fiber installed 10+ years ago. Do you have a source for that? Verizon may have passed 18 million homes, but only the homes which have placed an order for Fios were ever connected. So, no or very little idle fiber. > Gigabit ethernet was introduced 17 years ago and carries 5 km over fiber. Wrong. You can buy off the shelf SFPs with 200 km reach. Use amps if you want longer reach. > Cable is just waiting for providers to switch on 10 Gbps since years ago. You don't just switch on 10 Gbps on cable. First your vendor needs to release DOCSIS 3.1 equipment and you need to test it. Then you need to upgrade your CMTS to DOCSIS 3.1 and swap out any cable modems that don't support 3.1 and dedicate spectrum to DOCSIS 3.1 downstream channels. And it's not since years ago. DOCSIS 3.1 was released a bit over two years ago. Comcast will start rolling out commercial DOCSIS 3.1 service this year. > Phone line copper has similar story... What?! G.fast can theoretically give you 1 Gbps, but only if you already have fiber to your driveway. There aren't even any commercial deployments yet and all vendors don't even have products yet.