7 ms·
Iranians Are Using Satellite TV to Beam in Banned Internet
- brownbat 11y ago> And Yahsat’s satellite hovers over the Middle East, making it harder for the Iranian government to jam the satellite’s signal as it’s broadcast directly down to Iranian dishes. Are some angles harder to block than others? Or do they just mean that satellites are hard to block in general?
- detaro 11y agoIf you aim at a satellite very low over the horizon it would be easier to do disturb your reception with a terrestrial transmitter on the horizon line(?)
- Hyperborian 11y ago> Are some angles harder to block than others? As a matter of fact, yes. Satellite dishes have, by their very nature, a narrow "beam width" of reception. That's so that they can pick up the weak signals coming from satellites (which, having limited sources of power out in space, can't produce as strong a signal as terrestrial broadcasts), and it's why they have to be carefully pointed in order to receive that signal. In order to jam a signal and prevent someone from receiving it, you have to overpower it by aiming a signal of your own on the same frequency at their antenna. Since satellite dishes have such narrow reception beams, though, that means in order to jam them you need to get your signal out in front of the dish, so you can aim it directly in. If the dishes are pointed to the side, at a satellite near the horizon, that's not so hard to do. You just need to get your jamming transmitter up on a tower in the way and Bob's your uncle. If those dishes are pointed straight up, on the other hand... well, there's not much you can do without a capable space program. Iran is not exactly known for their extensive space program. :)
- syedkarim 11y agoIt's always possible to saturate a satellite transponder by illegally uplinking to it. The Iranian government paid the Cuban government to do this a few years ago. I think they were jamming BBC content.
- amazon_not 11y agoYou'd think they could come up with a more efficient way of broadcasting content than just rebroadcasting the same content over and over again hourly. A more interesting approach would be to use a data carousel with erasure codes. That way you could tune in anytime and be done once you've collected enough blocks to reassemble the wanted files. You could even vary the allocated bitrate for each file, starting with a higher bitrate to get early birds fast access and then lowering the bitrate as more and more people already completed their download, but still allowing stragglers to catch up. Since this is just a curated collection of content, it has very little to do with the Internet, unlike the title suggests. At the very least they should add some level of interactivity, so that users could vote on content to be sent and/or submit content for broadcasting like other similar satellite data casting systems already in use.
- djaychela 11y agoAnd what would be the channel for that feedback? Surely any such system would risk detection of the user, particularly for a non-technical user who may make a mistake in the (needed) security/privacy software/access needed for such a back channel? As for a more complex data transmission scheme, do all satellite receivers support it?
- bwilliams18 11y agoDon't let great be the enemy of good. Create a tor website, and provide a text file with the link in all downlinks. If people don't know how to use tor or can't access the site, that's fine, but if they can access it, they get additional features. Provide a simple feedback form or voting system. It doesn't have to be perfect, these downloads are already hand assembled by someone each day. You aren't obligated to use all suggestions, or even the most popular, but use it as a feedback mechanism to inform your choices.
- amazon_not 11y ago> And what would be the channel for that feedback? Surely any such system would risk detection of the user, particularly for a non-technical user who may make a mistake in the (needed) security/privacy software/access needed for such a back channel? How about using that nifty Tor browser they keep rebroadcasting to access a hidden service website to vote and issue requests? Hidden services cannot by definition be accessed without Tor and are thus more secure from prying eyes, even when used by non-technical users. > As for a more complex data transmission scheme, do all satellite receivers support it? The satellite receivers just store the transport stream. The data is extracted by parsing the transport stream with a Windows program. You can implement whatever scheme you like with software.
- chris_wot 11y agoI can see the Iranian government super gluing all the USB ports on all the receivers. Sigh.
- malekpour 11y agoGovernment has no control over receivers since those are already banned and people buy them from underground market. Selling, buying or installing receivers are all illegal and punishable. Having said that, majority of Iranians are watching satellite TVs.
- nissehulth 11y agoYou can't really hide a satellite dish, seems to me it would be easy to find houses with illegal equipment?
- malekpour 11y agoWe are talking about millions of dishes. This is where law ridicules itself and impossible to enforce. There are some police raids once a while, but not effective. http://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-news-from-elsewhere-27920659 http://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-news-from-elsewhere-27920659
- chris_wot 11y agoThat's good news then :-)
- danharaj 11y agoSelectively enforced laws are more useful to the government than laws that are consistently enforced.
- azernik 11y agoBut not useful for their original purpose (in this case, suppressing satellite TV usage). Just useful as general leverage against targeted people, which the Iranian government is not short of anyway.
- kw71 11y agoF You Wired. "Here's the thing with ad blockers." I'm not using any ad blocker! I'm not letting you run scripts in my browser. Why do you need to run scripts to show a static magazine article, with ads or not? You aren't getting my dollar, but you would have gotten some impressions ($$$) and I would have read the article if you didn't act like a retard with your website.
- capote 11y agoThere's always been a delay in Wired blocking me, so I always just print the page to a PDF and read away.
- capote 11y agoMakes me feel like I'm sticking it to the man.
- spikej 11y agoSeriously, just stick this in front of most sites/articles: http://www.readability.com/m?url= http://www.readability.com/m?url= And here it is in bookmarklet form javascript:void(window.location.href='http://www.readability.com/m?url='+window.location.href http://www.readability.com/m?url='+window.location.href)
- pmarreck 11y agoExcellent tip
- enraged_camel 11y agoI get a "Readability was unable to parse this page" error when I plug in the submitted Wired article.
- x5n1 11y agoYeah felt the same thing. Turned off the adblocker, still won't load because it wants to load a ton of privacy invading scripts to track everything about you. Yeah it's fine, your article might be interesting, but it's not that interesting. Get a Google cached version if I really want to read it.
- anon4 11y agoIf they wanted to write an article against ad blockers, why not just do that? Why the bait and switch? Mods - title of the article is "Here's the deal with ad blockers", the submitted title is just clickbait, the article gets replaced with another one as soon as you scroll a few lines down.
- tudorw 11y agoThis is a great idea, could we move the top 100 viewed internet videos of they day into a daily satellite packet and take the pressure of the pipes, nice :)
- akx 11y agoSo how exactly is Toosheh getting this satellite to beam their content?
- malekpour 11y agoYears ago I was using http://www.skygrabber.com http://www.skygrabber.com and similar apps to get free internet. I remember I got OpenOffice, JDK, .NET SDK and terabytes of random data while I had no internet access whatsoever.
- mehdiyahya 11y agoSkygrabber works with DVB cards and are used to receive from satellite data streams. Toosheh works with the existing TV satellite receivers. The data is not sent through the TV channel stream instead of the conventional data streams.
- Lanari 11y agoI didn't bother to check but if it's like SkyGrabber it works that way: Internet via satellite is just like a big local network, when you request data it get sent in space unencrypted, you only have to read it... So you basically download what other people are downloading without any way to control what to download except with filters that filter text, css, jpg, small files... since this is most of what people get (browsing the net...).
- dogma1138 11y agoThe data is encrypted that's actually how satellite internet works unless you have the resources of a nation state your packets will be mingled with everyone else's the receiver on your end reads all the packets but can only decrypt the ones intended for you. The uplink varies in the past the uplink usually used to go over dial-up/ISDN or even slow speed DSL but today terrestrial transmitters are quite common in most modern Satnet installations.
- Lanari 11y ago
- nandhp 11y agoThis is similar to Outernet/Lantern (https://outernet.is/ https://outernet.is/), though Toosheh has the neat feature of being able to reuse existing satellite receivers, which is obviously very useful here. They also seem to have a much larger bandwidth budget (1GB per hour with Toosheh vs 1GB per day with Outernet).
- godzillabrennus 11y agoOuternet was download only free bandwidth last I checked. Met the founder at TechWeek in Chicago and liked the idea. Backed it by buying a shirt.
- adamfisk 11y agoUnlike Outernet, this is also actually deployed in the field and works at scale.
- amazon_not 11y ago> Outernet was download only free bandwidth last I checked. This is download only too.
- hendersoon 11y agoNice to see an example of the CIA slush fund financing something other than sending arms to "freedom fighters". This sort of thing is how they _should_ be spending that money.
- Aelinsaar 11y agoThe problem is that American defense contractors don't get a slice of this pie, while exporting arms for whatever reasons = $$$. There is also the political pressure from some such leading luminaries as John "I can't feel my feet!" McCain to throw weapons at every problem. I agree though, this is pretty clever. It's not quite the RoK building a giant bank of speakers on the DPRK border, but it's probably more effective.
- hendersoon 11y agoCost is only $100k per year and it's technically run by private citizens so completely deniable from a diplomatic standpoint. It really is brilliant.
- Aelinsaar 11y agoI want to believe that this is the kind of thinking that's rewarded, but...
- tmptmp 11y ago>>There is also the political pressure from some such leading luminaries as John "I can't feel my feet!" McCain to throw weapons at every problem. omg, it took me a while to decode that bunch of words, super power-packed words indeed. Hilarious and witty. Thanks for making that comment. It captures the sentiment of some section of US which is very much eager to use weapons no matter whether it makes much sense or not. Edit: quoted properly.
- rdl 11y agoMore likely run by people in the Gulf who hate Iran (i.e. Saudi), or even a single somewhat-rich Iranian who is angry at what has happened to his country. (Not because CIA shouldn't fund something like this, but because they're too dumb/slow/bureaucratic to, and if they were doing it, it would cost way more than $100k)
- josefdlange 11y agoNot to reduce this story to a meme, but actually to reduce this story to a meme: http://i.imgur.com/wQc9RPi.gif http://i.imgur.com/wQc9RPi.gif
- rmason 11y agoThe Mullah's like the Soviets before them will find that once they lose the ability to block the truth their expiration date is only a matter of time. The Soviets were brought down by the humble FAX machine. When the United Auto Workers reached out to Lech Walesa of the Solidarity union and said what is your biggest problem he reportedly answered secure communication. So the union sent him hundreds of FAX machines and that is how Solidarity was able to coordinate their protests and share information. What these guys in California are doing with their satellite channel and accompanying software is important. Now they need to enable the former leaders of the green revolution with a mesh network in each city in Iran. The answer once again could come out of Detroit where they're the world's leaders. All they would need is the funding, doubt it will come from the Feds but maybe from the UAW once again? https://www.alliedmedia.org/dctp/digitalstewards https://www.alliedmedia.org/dctp/digitalstewards
- mehrdada 11y agoThat's wishful thinking. I can't say much about the Soviets, but the regime in Iran, or at least a chunk of the people in power, understands how to balance their power and freedom (critically the "freedom to get rich", despite, and often because of massive corruption) and the perception and hope of freedom in the wider society and they adapt well to new circumstances. They are much more sophisticated than you portray them to be in your comment. If they weren't as good in adapting, they would have been gone many times by now. Source: personal [unfortunate] experience of having been born and lived there for a the first couple decades of my life. P.S. Also note that a lot of (and I'd say the majority of young) even non-technical people know how to circumvent internet censorship and are regularly on Facebook and social media, so it's not exactly a social revolution happening just today. In fact, I see this type of system without direct user choice of the content, just another form of centralized, controlled, media, which is a step down from normal internet over some sort of proxy/VPN (albeit slow). (I don't want to detract from the technical contribution; just putting it in perspective of the existing available techniques in wide use over there.)
- thaumasiotes 11y ago> The Soviets were brought down by the humble FAX machine. Assuming your description is accurate, this is still only sort of true. The Soviets were such a disaster that their downfall was greatly overdetermined. Without fax machines, they would have been brought down by something else. "Old age" used to be an official cause of death. There was a period when we started doing autopsies on people who had died of old age, and discovered (keep in mind this was new information at the time!) that in every single case, those people had died of some malfunction that would have killed anyone else, old or not. But, after a spree of autopsying people with the goal of preventing death, we figured out that there were basically no implications to this. What happens when you're old is that everything is failing all the time. Remove a 20-year-old's ruptured appendix and they'll probably go on for several more decades; if you fix a similarly severe problem in an 80-year-old, they're unlikely to get one more decade, because a completely different problem will kill them shortly afterwards. The Soviets were like that.
- pmarreck 11y agoIs there any way that I as a Westerner can help this process along?
- _wmd 11y agoMove to the US and pay taxes
- wtbob 11y ago> a video game that includes lessons on Iranian constitutional rights It's been noted regarding the Soviet satellites that only a tyrannical government needs to shoot to keep people in; one might likewise argue that only a tyranny tries to stop its people from learning their rights under that government's constitution. Before we get too full of ourselves, we might consider what a public school makes of teaching the First, Second, Ninth and Tenth Amendments …
- roywiggins 11y agoSounds like Teletext 2.0- The BBC Micro could even get software over Teletext for a while, and that was the 80s!
- amazon_not 11y agoPretty much. Only difference is that data isn't sent between scan lines but embedded in the transport stream.
- furyg3 11y ago> low and expensive—a gigabyte of data costs around $1 in a country where many people make only hundreds of dollars a month. "Hundreds" is ambiguous, let's conservatively say it's $200. So half a percent of your income went to a plan with 1GB of data. Here in Holland the average (gross) wages was €3073 in 2012 (most recent numbers I can find), and in 2012 €50/month for a plan with 1GB internet was pretty normal. So the Dutch are playing 3-4 times as much of their relative income for data, excluding the fact that they probably pay higher taxes and that 'hundreds' probably means more than $200.
- clishem 11y agoRespectfully, but there were no bandwidth caps in the Netherlands in 2012 [1]. Furthermore, € 50 is an exessive amount of money to be paying for only internet, even in 2012. Perhaps you have mobile internet in mind? [1]: http://www.oecd.org/internet/broadband/BB-Portal_5i_13July_Final.xls http://www.oecd.org/internet/broadband/BB-Portal_5i_13July_F....
- furyg3 11y agoSorry, I was assuming they were talking about mobile internet (in many developing countries this is the primary internet source).
- why-el 11y agoDidn't look at your numbers closely but I agree that prices for cellular internet are very, very high in Europe. I moved to Germany 2 years ago and I currently pay 37 euros or so for 2GB (horrendously slow, on Edge most of the time). Contrast this with when I go back home (Morocco). I pay 10 euros for 12 Gbs of extremely available access (and many hours of calls for few euros more). I rarely finish it even when on Apple Music for hours a day.
- amazon_not 11y ago> Didn't look at your numbers closely but I agree that prices for cellular internet are very, very high in Europe. Or not. You simply need to pick a carrier with good coverage and cheap prices. Either you picked the wrong plan/carrier or your monthly fee includes a phone subsidy.
- infocollector 11y agoWhy aren't the Chinese doing this?
- agumonkey 11y agoHow many alternative networks are made (be it satellite, mesh network, ham) ?
- alfiedotwtf 11y agoThe elephant in the room is that the State Department is behind Toosheh funding
- zymhan 11y agoAh, I was wondering how they could afford their own Satellite TV channel...
- ape4 11y agoWould complete if individual users could request videos somehow.
- xufi 11y agoNow only if you could do this in China without getting around the Great wall. I take it Iranians have it a tad easier