3 ms·
"The only reason Veronica was able to carry out her experiment was that I had the flexibility to spend hours struggling through paperwork, and because I had a s
by jerf 11y ago
"The only reason Veronica was able to carry out her experiment was that I had the flexibility to spend hours struggling through paperwork, and because I had a social network of scientists I’ve developed as a science writer. This was an exercise in privilege."
No, it was an exercise in barriers. Everybody [1] has enough "privilege" to do this experiment, by which I mean the experiment itself without the "fair" elements, with little more than a slightly-interested science teacher. They just aren't allowed to do it by the science fair. Being able to speak with "actual" scientists about counting bacteria is at most a slight bonus; it is not necessary to the process, learning about it by reading would be a fine education on its own, and even failing at the process would be educational in its own way, as the author describes in his own experiences. (Science fairs have a major role to play in the pernicious idea that science is only "successful" when it obtains the positive result the experimenter was looking for... but that's a separate rant.)
This isn't someone being born with silver spoons in their mouth. This is regulation thoughtlessly applied with no thought about the costs. If "privilege" issues were as easy as just removing some regulation, we probably wouldn't be talking about it so much.
[1]: Everyone plausibly within the scope of this article, anyhow, which is places that have science fairs at all. That would be a separate issue.
- nmrm2 11y ago>...by which I mean the experiment itself without the "fair" elements I don't think the author or anyone else disagrees... the article was specifically about science fairs, not science projects generally. It's right in the title. And reiterated in the portion of the text where the author juxtaposes their childhood experience with their child's experience. > This isn't someone being born with silver spoons in their mouth. This is regulation thoughtlessly applied with no thought about the costs. It's both (which gets to the heart of what I consider the most compelling arguments for decreased regulation). Whenever there are bureaucratic barriers, knowing the right sorts of people works wonders. You might even say it's a privilege...
- panglott 11y agoBeing coached by professional microbiologists in a working lab is not really an advantage?
- uremog 11y agoWhile I think the parent underestimates the impact stated, I also think the point was that the experiment can be done at home by nearly anyone with the will, science fair or not, privilege or not.
- jerf 11y agoJust to confirm, uremog is getting my point. No, it really isn't an advantage. It would be an advantage if one were doing an experiment that required access to a particular strain of cells or really specialized equipment or specialized knowledge, but this particular experiment is none of the above. And even to the extent that it may help, the science fair is a time to not use it! A great deal of the point of such activities is to show how anybody can use the scientific methods to learn things. If you take your student to a high-tech lab to do their high-tech experiment on high-tech equipment, you're just further reinforcing the idea that Science is a Thing done by Scientists and I Can't Do It Myself. If I were running a science fair, a rock-solid requirement for me to judge something as the winner would be a plausible argument that pretty much any student could replicate the experiment with school-level resources, if they took the time.
- hooloovoo_zoo 11y agoIt's not trivial for a middle-schooler to make an incubator and I'm sure this girl got advice from microbiologists that would have taken her much longer to gather on her own. They had all the equipment she would need right there (sterile loop, agar plates, bunsen burner, lab grade ethanol). Plus, she probably had a bunch of equipment to make it easier (test tubes, tube shaker, that light she's using to examine the plates). So really she had a huge advantage over someone doing it on their own.
- tzs 11y ago> It's not trivial for a middle-schooler to make an incubator You don't actually need an incubator. Bacteria won't grow as fast at room temperature, but for the kind of experiment she was doing that should not be a problem. Nevertheless, it is actually pretty easy to make an incubator. Google for "homemade bacterial incubator" and you'll find many sites offering instructions. A typical design uses an aquarium tank, an incandescent lamp, a dimmer, and a thermometer. This should be well within the capability of any middle schooler. If the kid is up for doing a little programming, they could even toss in an Arduino and use a dimmer that can be controlled by it and automate keeping the temperature constant. The rest of the things needed, like Petri dishes, agar, and such are available from Amazon. There are even kits specifically aimed at people who want to grow bacteria for science fair projects.
- noonespecial 11y agoReally? All I saw was an "ordinary" world positively ruled by irrational, anti-intellectual fear coupled with an automatic, even pathological denial of permission by the uninformed that can only be surmounted by awesome levels of societal privilege. This is the path to the dark side. And by the dark side, I mean living amidst the ruins trying to find someone to blame for where it all went wrong. Somewhere between "We choose to go to the moon" and "if you see something, say something" we traded all of our hope for fear. That sucks.
- IIAOPSW 11y ago>Somewhere between "We choose to go to the moon" and "if you see something, say something" we traded all of our hope for fear. That sucks. That is the most succulent summary of the state of things I have ever read.