4 ms·
I don't understand the logic in this. How does "we don't want a removable battery" imply "we don't want an infinitely-lived battery"?
by StavrosK 11y ago
I don't understand the logic in this. How does "we don't want a removable battery" imply "we don't want an infinitely-lived battery"?
- stephengillie 11y agoPlanned obsolescence can be seen as a revenue stream to some.
- jdietrich 11y agoIt's not planned obsolescence. Batteries that require tools to replace are commonplace in phones and tablets, because they allow the device to be made smaller and stronger. Apple will replace an iPhone battery for $79; Independent repairers charge about half that. You can do it yourself with a screwdriver and a suction cup.
- hyperbovine 11y agoI think the point is that nobody is going to want to use their current iPhone in 7.5 years, let alone 75. That is partly because people like shiny new things, but also because your current iPhone will lose iOS compatibility long before that time.
- jdietrich 11y agoThe iPhone 4s and iPad 2 are still getting updates, nearly five years on. I wouldn't be surprised if some of those devices are still plodding along in 2020, particularly iPads being used in PoS applications.
- pessimizer 11y agoBecause there's no rationale for excluding either other than to limit the product's lifespan.
- matt_kantor 11y agoLimiting the product's lifespan is one rationale, but to say that there are no others is a little unfair. Off the top of my head, these are all within the realm of possibility: - Easier/cheaper manufacturing process. - Increased structural stability. - Make the device smaller/thinner/lighter. - Apple is concerned that end users will screw something up, so they want their service staff to handle battery replacement. I'm sure the internal discussions that led non-user-replaceable batteries was more nuanced than "let's milk those suckers for all they're worth".
- pessimizer 11y agoThere will be a public rationalization for why they can't include an infinitely-lived battery, too. They'll probably say "power curve" somewhere. I can't imagine that an iPhone with a battery door would cost more than pennies more to manufacture. iPhones are fragile, and have always been; if they can charge you $79 for a new battery, they can charge you $79 to fix the battery door. Smaller/lighter/thinner? You're talking a razor-thin space savings that adds up to a major inconvenience for users. Users have been operating battery doors for a very long time without electrocuting themselves or losing fingers. They're about as dangerous as an SD slot. > I'm sure the internal discussions that led non-user-replaceable batteries was more nuanced than "let's milk those suckers for all they're worth". I'm sure Snidely Whiplash doesn't work there. That a decision both so profitable and user-hostile was made is neither an incidental part of a general striving for perfection, nor undiscussed.
- jeffbush 11y agoI worked on the iPhone at Apple and sat in many meetings where the product design and electrical engineering leads would almost come to shouting matches over fractions of millimeters. The engineering was fascinating. Everything inside the phone wants to be away from everything else. For example, the radios have power amplifier chips that are hot spots and need to be kept away from the battery to avoid exceeding its thermal limits. The antennas need to be kept away from noisy chips that would affect their reception. There are external connectors and SIMs invading the case. Once that is all crammed in, they need to drop test the whole thing and hope it doesn't bend or shatter. It's really challenging to cram that much stuff into a constrained enclosure, and all of the layers add up. As I understand, a removable battery takes up a lot of area, because you need clearance below it and space for the mechanical fasteners. It also breaks up the pristine surfaces that are a big part of Apple's design language. The individual industrial design, product design, electrical, and RF design/antenna engineers responsible for each part aren't thinking about sales in two years. They want to make their piece as good as they can and hit the schedule.
- beamatronic 11y agoImagine how long electric cars would last if the only part you really need to replace is the battery. Not to mention, you have a chance to decouple the parts that don't have or need a technical revolution ( the motors ) from the parts that do ( the battery ).
- PhantomGremlin 11y agoIn the abstract, one could believe that an electric car would be uncomplicated. But that doesn't seem to be true. For example a few days ago we discussed the BMW i3. Electric means simple? No. Someone in that discussion posted a link to a 40 min video of the i3 production line. I had no idea of how much effort was involved. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11532982 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11532982 Yes, electric cars are inherently simpler than internal combustion vehicles. But they're still quite sophisticated, with quite a lot that can break or become obsolete. There's a whole like more than the battery that needs a "technical revolution". People have been embracing recent developments such as automatic crash braking and Apple CarPlay. It would be difficult to retrofit all the sensors needed for automatic braking and lane change warnings.
- Joof 11y agoSo we need modular cars that people can update every few years. Or crush them all and get new ones I guess...
- csours 11y agoFewer moving parts is not "no moving parts". Even non-moving parts move in automobiles - the whole thing moves; add vibration and heat stress, and there will probably never be a zero-repair vehicle (excepting heroic or shiny variants) One of the biggest problems with electric vehicles right now is resale value. If the battery did not degrade, resale value would be much much higher. If resale prices were higher, people would be more willing to lease and buy new electric vehicles, and then those vehicles would be available on the used car market, and available for hacker types to do interesting things with them [1] 1. http://cafeelectric.com/stretchla/ http://cafeelectric.com/stretchla/ ; http://www.autoblog.com/2016/04/19/classic-firebird-restomod-swallowed-prius/ http://www.autoblog.com/2016/04/19/classic-firebird-restomod...
- elorant 11y agoWhat he/she probably means is that you don’t need a battery that lasts for decades in a device that would become obsolete in five years. It’s a waste of valuable resources, assuming that this battery would cost more to build.
- jrapdx3 11y agoBut in may cases the device becomes "obsolete" because its battery no holds adequate charge and is intentionally not replaceable. For example, that's certainly the case with Microsoft Surface Pro [1,2,3,etc.] computers as MS made it clear that the design life of the battery was about 3 years (and isn't user replaceable). That's absurd for a device with an initial cost of >$1500. If the battery lasted 20 times as long, I'm sure many such devices would be kept in service for much longer than 3 years, for many users there's no need to "upgrade" after so short an interval.
- coldtea 11y ago>For example, that's certainly the case with Microsoft Surface Pro [1,2,3,etc.] computers as MS made it clear that the design life of the battery was about 3 years (and isn't user replaceable). That the "design life of the battery is about 3 years" and it isn't "user replaceable" doesn't mean the device become obsolete -- just that you need to go to a shop to have the battery replaced.
- BeefySwain 11y ago5 years? More like 2.5
- prodmerc 11y agoWait, is no one considering that these batteries can be recycled? Apple or third parties can reuse them a lot of times provided that they share a form factor and there are no significant advances to capacity that would require throwing the old ones away... With all this talk about plastic bags in the other thread, I'm surprised people think no one wants an infinite battery in a device that will be obsolete in 5 years...