3 ms·
I think the author latched on to a PR piece from 16.04 release. Yeah that has the word security in it a few times. But X11 was there before and installing rand
by rdtsc 11y ago
I think the author latched on to a PR piece from 16.04 release. Yeah that has the word security in it a few times.
But X11 was there before and installing random packages on your Desktop (or piping stuff from curl to a root bash, etc) is not secure. That is not controversial, I'd think.
> Matthew Garrett, a [...] security developer at CoreOS.
There might be a slight conflict of interest here. Although I am all for exposing security threats and issues regardless, Ubuntu has been advertising LXD, Juju and such technologies which somewhat compete with CoreOS, so I can understand why they'd want to move quickly to discredit it.
The whole adorable teddy bear thing is a bit childish perhaps. "Oh look how evil the new Ubuntu is, it lets evil teddy bears eat your data".
- rbanffy 11y agoTo be fair, X has that issue since the mid 80's. I am quite sure my vintage SPARC boxes running Solaris 2 are equally exposed.
- danieldk 11y agoBut X11 was there before and installing random packages on your Desktop (or piping stuff from curl to a root bash, etc) is not secure. That is not controversial, I'd think. The point that canonical is trying to push that installing random packages is more secure with snap/snappy because they are sandboxed (to some extend). However, as Matthew Garrett points out, this sandboxing is practically useless as long as you are running on X11, since a sandboxed program can send keystrokes to other applications, grab keystrokes, do window grabs, etc. So it still has as much control as unsandboxed applications as long as they are running in a normal X11 session. He is right to call them out on this. There might be a slight conflict of interest here. Since he is actually stating (known) facts about X11's security model, I don't see the problem.
- rdtsc 11y ago> is more secure with snap/snappy because they are sandboxed (to some extend). In a press release. Yes it is more secure but when running on a desktop with X11 will have same issues as before with X11. Imagine a press release for 16.04 that all of the sudden starts going into details about X11 vulnerabilities. Who does that? I am can see refuting a white-paper where Ubuntu makes detailed claims about security guarantees under certain threat models but this seems like a cheap shot to me. Moreover under this model you can shoot down any product. "Tor provides privacy" -- "Ah no it doesn't, here are more details". "The new JDK is faster than the old" -- "Wrong! Here is a benchmark where it shows it is slower". And so on.
- digi_owl 11y agoHe has also had an axe to grind vs Canonical for some time now (i think it started before he moved to work for CoreOS) over their requirements for working on projects under their control.