7 ms·
The Doom install image was 35x the size of the Apollo guidance computer. Thirty-five times! Apollo software got us to the moon. Doom wasted millions of man-hou
by snowwrestler 11y ago
The Doom install image was 35x the size of the Apollo guidance computer.
Thirty-five times! Apollo software got us to the moon. Doom wasted millions of man-hours on a video game.
My point of course is that these comparisons are not actually that illuminating.
Are web pages much heavier than they need to be? Yes. This presentation very capably talks about that problem:
http://idlewords.com/talks/website_obesity.htm http://idlewords.com/talks/website_obesity.htm
Does comparing web pages to Doom help understand or improve the situation? No, not any more than comparing Doom to Apollo memory size helps us understand the difference between a video game and a history-altering exploration.
- skoczymroczny 11y ago> Apollo software got us to the moon. Doom wasted millions of man-hours on a video game. Well, to be honest, Episode 1 and Episode 2 of Doom takes place on Phobos and Deimos, so you could say Apollo software got us to the moon but Doom got us to Mars :)
- jordigh 11y agoSince 2.1 megs is only the compressed size of the shareware distribution[1], we are not going any further than Phobos. Since this is only for v1.0, it is going to be a buggy Phobos. [1] http://www.doomarchive.com/ListFiles.asp?FolderId=216&ContentsFolderId=216 http://www.doomarchive.com/ListFiles.asp?FolderId=216&Conten...
- StavrosK 11y agoThat link inspires me to print and bind the code of a webpage into a book, and put it on a shelf next to other literature masterpieces. One Hundred Years of Solitude The Count of Monte Cristo Anna Karenina Don Quixote Amazon.com: Online Shopping for Electronics, Apparel, Computers, Books, DVDs & more
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoI want the audio version, narrated by Malcolm McDowell.
- StavrosK 11y agoLess than head question mark, doctype html, greater than less than html class equals opening quote a dash no dash js closing quote. Data dash nineteen a x five a nine j f equals opening quote dingo closing quote greater than less than head greater than.
- tdsamardzhiev 11y agoRemember: It's not a waste if you (and millions of other people) have fun!
- matt4077 11y agoThat's what NASA wants you to believe...
- Eerie 11y ago>Apollo software got us to the moon. Doom wasted millions of man-hours on a video game. How many millions of man-hours Apollo project wasted for a PR stunt?
- manaskarekar 11y agoMandatory: Benefits from Apollo [PDF] https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/80660main_ApolloFS.pdf https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/80660main_ApolloFS....
- bradleyjg 11y agoThis argument proves too much. If we wanted better sneaker materials or retractable football stadium roofs surely we could have accomplished those tasks for far less money. The opportunity cost of the Apollo missions were enormous, even if there were positive outcomes that spun out of it. Or to put it more elegantly: "Stop there! Your theory is confined to that which is seen; it takes no account of that which is not seen."
- manaskarekar 11y agoI somewhat agree with what you're saying, but eventually it's hard to prove if one way benefits us more than the other, because the benefits of the Apollo program perhaps influenced the space endeavors that improve our life today. It's definitely debatable and hard to gauge. I just thought I'd throw in the link to show the other side of the argument.
- cinquemb 11y agoMy rule of thumb is that if a goal is thought to be technically possible (although it may have not been done before) and there are people who can execute and have the resources to execute it to any degree, it will probably be done. Especially regardless of anyone else opinion if they are not intimately involved in such processes.
- chriswarbo 11y ago
- pessimizer 11y agoDoom was delivering an experience far more complex than the Apollo guidance computer was. The average webpage is not. It's delivering an experience as complex as a pamphlet with a few phone numbers on it.
- pink_dinner 11y agoThe experience may not be complex, but the software that builds and displays the experience is way more complex than the Apollo guidance computer.
- pessimizer 11y agoThe software that builds and displays the experience is the browser. Most webpages could be cut by 90% and be visually and functionally indistinguishable. For 90% of the last 10%, the functionality cut out would improve the user experience, especially on mobile.
- pink_dinner 11y ago..and the server, protocols, and language used to build that web page. It's not like a powerpoint presentation.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoWhich only highlights the point of how overengineered it is. You shouldn't need (and in fact you don't need) several-layer tall stacks of programming languages and support equipment to render something that's less functional than a PowerPoint presentation.
- harryf 11y ago> Are web pages much heavier than they need to be? Yes What about the question "do web pages work any better than they did in 2007?" when we were using full page reloads and server side logic instead of Javascipt tricks. I see so much basic brokenness on the web today from the back button not working to horribly overloaded news websites with mystery-meat mobile navigation I find myself wondering what have we really achieved in the last 9 years? This stuff used to work
- untog 11y agoI think you are looking at the past through incredibly rose-tinted glasses. The web has been a mess for a long time, and we used to have to make sure our computer was set to 800x600 and we were using Internet Explorer 6 in order to even use it.
- TillE 11y agoThat was 1997, not 2007.
- bradyd 11y agoIE 6 was released with Windows XP in 2001 and IE 7 didn't come out until the end of 2006.
- PavlovsCat 11y agoOpera was awesome even in 2000.
- djsumdog 11y ago2007 I was working for a shop that only officially supported IE6. It was a health insurance company too. Your premiums at work!
- coolsunglasses 11y ago>make sure our computer was set to 800x600 Thaaaaaaaat's nonsense. I had relatively high-res CRTs (1600x1200) in the late 90s and early 2000s. My father and I were able to get by with Netscape Navigator and Firefox for quite awhile as well.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- falcolas 11y agoDoom was created for entertainment. Web pages are (typically) created for entertainment. The guidance computer was created for calculating trajectories. IMO, Doom and Web pages are remarkably close in terms of purpose and required assets, and the comparison is apt. Especially when you can play Doom on a web page...
- PaulHoule 11y agoApollo era space navigation is not that complex, mainly a matter of (i) pointing the ship in the right direction, (ii) firing the engines until a certain velocity change had happened, and (iii) assessing the result. (ii) in particular is a one-dimensional problem, and (iii) can be done by the guys on the ground via radar. What the shuttle did was much more complex because it was an unstable aircraft that required many "frames per second" applied to the control surfaces to keep it stable during reentry and landing. Back around 2006 or so I wrote a simple software 3-d rendering engine in Javascript that was 8k in size without much effort towards minimizing size other being (a) maybe the only AJAX application that actually used XML (to represent 3d models) and (b) using XML element and attribute names that were just one character long. Not long after that, libraries such as Prototype and JQuery were becoming popular and these were all many times bigger than my 3d engine before you even started coding the app.
- treebeard901 11y agoTo be fair, Doom wasn't a waste by any metric. Doom has had an history altering impact on 3D engines. The huge advancements that came from the Doom and Quake engines have found their way into software that benefits society as a whole.
- blazespin 11y agoPretty sure he was just being funny about the doom bit.
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoThe Web is heavy because there's no negative feedback for the weight factor. And in people's minds, it nearly seems that the difference between a video game and history-altering exploration diminishes day by day.
- wldcordeiro 11y agoHonestly if a native Android or iOS app can be several Gb in size then a webapp can be a few Mb. That said there are lots of optimizations that we're missing out on. I hope http2 and other advances in server side render + tree shaking help reduce the size of payloads further.
- tompsonson 11y ago> The Doom install image was 35x the size of the Apollo guidance computer. Keep in mind that the AGC was a necessary but not sufficient piece of hardware for navigating to the moon, and was extremely special-purpose. NASA had several big (for the time) mainframes that 1) calculated the approximation tables that were stored in AGC ROM (each mission required a new table because the relative positions of the earth, sun and moon was different) 2) reduced soundings from earth-based radars to periodically update the AGC's concept of its position. 3) other things that I've forgotten In other words, the AGC required the assistance of a ground-based computer with dozens of megabytes of RAM and hundreds of megabytes of storage. That will fit on your phone quite easily, but let's not minimize the requirements for celestial navigation.
- jccalhoun 11y agothat's because the moon landing was staged! wake up sheeple!!!!!!
- TeMPOraL 11y agoYes, it was recorded in a sound stage on Mars.