3 ms·
My biggest complaint about Flash is that it isn't truly part of the web. If you have a completely flash based site, all browser conventions go out the window:
by wvenable 17y ago
My biggest complaint about Flash is that it isn't truly part of the web. If you have a completely flash based site, all browser conventions go out the window: bookmarks, the back button, and deep linking. Sometimes even non-browser conventions are gone like cut'n'paste, printing, or saving to a file. If you're going to do that, you should have a good reason beyond "it's easy" and "you can have music"
Flash is most successful when it's used properly: for small regions of video or cool interactivity. It's least successful when it's used to replace a properly coded website.
I don't think the 'web elite' want Flash to die necessarily; they just want all the same cool toys but with something that plays nice with existing web conventions. And they also don't want to sharecrop on someone's proprietary platform. I'd argue the author has taken a very shallow look at the issues involved here.
- est 17y ago> all browser conventions go out the window: bookmarks, the back button, and deep linking. Most of the ajax in the wild is no better than that. Instead of saying Flash breaks everything, why don't we think about the good n' old browsing behavior model. Does it suit our Web 2.0 world well?
- wvenable 17y agoActually, a lot of Ajax handles the back button very well. The Extjs framework, as one example, lets you back through almost all the navigation including flipping between dynamic tabs. I'm not even sure how they've implemented that. There was a Ajax chat application that was posted here recently. And this was my comment: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1128206 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1128206 The back button is an extremely useful feature and should probably be in every application. Whenever a user gets confused or lost they just click that button -- it's a universal undo for navigation.
- mambodog 17y ago"...all browser conventions go out the window: bookmarks, the back button, and deep linking." Actually all of those things can be managed (quite well) with SWFAddress. http://www.asual.com/swfaddress/ http://www.asual.com/swfaddress/ That's not to say, however, that I agree with the article. Flash really should be used a hell of a lot less on the web. No 'main site' should be built all-Flash, however it is ideal for things like interactive product micro-sites.