4 ms·
Under an anarcho-syndicalist system you don't need to worry what your neighbor does with their share. You have your share. If you want to work towards a common
by erikpukinskis 11y ago
Under an anarcho-syndicalist system you don't need to worry what your neighbor does with their share. You have your share. If you want to work towards a common goal you need to convince them to work with you voluntarily.
I addressed the second point in my original post but maybe that was unclear: if there are so many applicants that individual grants become too small to serve their purpose, you stop accepting applicants. But then you require the applicant pool to spend some portion of their time growing the grant pool until the waiting list is empty. Flipping burgers if need be. Although we're talking about PhDs so I am sure there are better ways to use that labor pool.
- danieltillett 11y agoStopping the acceptance of potential grantees is just putting an inefficient barrier to entry of new people. The end result of limiting people rather than a base quality is that it would favour the old over the young which I don’t think is a good outcome.
- erikpukinskis 11y agoYou will have to argue it's less efficient than the current system. You can't just state that it is so. As for favoring the old, all you have to do is require people to regularly re-apply. There's no reason you need to hop the line after the end of your term. And you seem to be assuming that the waitlist will be prohibitively long, but the longer the waitlist the more labor you have for growing the grant pool, so it naturally self-regulates.