3 ms·
About the idea of "bizarre dysfunction of modern "cross-functional" teams and "full stack" developers, leading to Agile/Scrum bullshit": I have never heard peop
by Someone 11y ago
About the idea of "bizarre dysfunction of modern "cross-functional" teams and "full stack" developers, leading to Agile/Scrum bullshit": I have never heard people advocate that this should apply to sales, marketing and HR, too. User-centered designers and graphic artists also often seem to be able to carve out a niche for themselves. So, it seems the only discussion should be about how specialized the specialists can be, not about banning all specialization.
I also don't really know any organization that goes all in on "all team members are interchangeable". I do know one organization that seems to go all in on "each team member has his own unique tasks, rights, and responsibilities", and that is disastrous (X writes SQL script, but is not allowed to know the name of the database or the server it is installed on, and isn't allowed to run the script; Y is allowed to run SQL scripts, but not modify them, not even to fill in the database name. Their manager compliments them because they refuse to get anything done/follow the rules to the letter)
I think it is examples like these that led to a swing to the other end of the spectrum that Scrum advocates. I also think the pendulum will swing back.
- p4wnc6 11y ago> I also don't really know any organization that goes all in on "all team members are interchangeable". This has been a ubiquitous and openly stated goal from management in every job I've had. In one job that followed a consultant's implementation of Agile to the letter, it was actually part of new employee on-boarding to be turned into a full-stack developer no matter what your background was. Our team worked on a large predictive analytics project, and you can imagine how hard it was to recruit machine learning engineers when the proposition was, "Gee, your amazing degree from Georgia Tech and your experience building a novel recommender system from scratch for a start-up are great and all, but don't you think it would be good for you to spend 6 months fixing Javascript bugs related to poor performance of some of our app's drop-down menus? BTW if you don't exude boisterous enthusiasm for that, it means you're toxic, poor attitude, not a team player, and HR will never let you through the interview process."