6 ms·
> Your allegations miss a crucial detail, Monsanto sued farmers who planted seeds and then sprayed them with herbicide[1]. Ie the farmer knew what he was doing
by koolba 11y ago
> Your allegations miss a crucial detail, Monsanto sued farmers who planted seeds and then sprayed them with herbicide[1]. Ie the farmer knew what he was doing and used the patented trait. Why shouldn’t Monsanto sue over that? Like many things in GMO land the myth that they sue accidental contamination is wrong.
I disagree that anything is wrong with doing that. The way I see it, he identified that a number of plants were resistant to RoundUp and efficiently figured out which they were.
It's not his fault that Monsanto's business model fails to meet up with the reality that plants have plantable seeds.
> Monsanto has the worst PR team in history, which has made my company’s work much harder, but ‘Monsanto is Evil’ is a marketing slogan developed by Greenpeace, Friends of the Earth etc. These environmental groups are actually the true evil in the industry. Their campaigning has held back progress in the industry by many years. Smarter folks than me argue that their actions on Golden Rice meet all the criteria to be considered a crime against humanity[2]
Friend of the earth (lower case without a ™ symbol) sure, but I'm no tree hugger. I'm not against GMOs and think Golden Rice is amazing. I just don't like the idea of imposing licensing restrictions on farmers. It's a dark road that we don't need to go down.
- technotony 11y ago>I just don't like the idea of imposing licensing restrictions on farmers. It's a dark road that we don't need to go down. For what it's worth I agree with you, but this is a political problem as it's congress that sets those rules. Also within the current regulatory environment, where it costs >$100MM to deregulate a GMO any other business model will be flawed. My company (www.taxa.com) makes GMO plants which are not regulated for sale in the United States (which some people thing is a bad idea). But because we have so much lower cost of getting to market we've decided to follow a open source model. Our hope is that if we can continuously improve the product people will come back for the next generation version anyway. But we can only have this model because of the way our products are regulated.
- allisthemoist 11y ago> Also within the current regulatory environment, where it costs >$100MM to deregulate a GMO any other business model will be flawed. So if I wanted to create a GMO and sell it in Argentina, I'd have to pay a premium? At what stage of development does payment occur or is it a tax on sales?
- bduerst 11y ago> fails to meet up with the reality that plants have plantable seeds. This is a terrible argument. Is Microsoft to blame for Windows piracy because CDs are easy to copy? These cases aren't accidental - the farmer was very clearly copying the technology and using it to their benefit without contributing to the IP costs.
- livingparadox 11y agoIts more akin to a company using torrent as their distribution platform, requiring a licensing fee to re-seed the content, and then suing someone for re-seeding or torrenting the file they originally seeded.
- bduerst 11y agoNo, it's akin to someone paying to license software for a year and then continuing to intentionally use it after the contract has expired. Farmers almost never grow seed crop. You're making generalizations about an industry you don't know much about.
- livingparadox 11y agoNo, its not. From the original comment in this thread >sues farmers for re-planting seeds that blew onto their land The farmers being sued never purchased or sought out the seeds in question. They blew into their land by natural processes (wind) and grew of their own course. The farmers in question then replanted the seeds that were growing in their fields. At no point did they do anything equivalent to paying or licensing the software. Nor did they intentionally plant the first generation of plants. Edit: In regards to the generalization comment, I was making my analogy based on the description given by the original comment. I fail to see how I extrapolated beyond the clear meaning of the description.
- bduerst 11y agoFrom the link: >Fact: Monsanto has never sued a farmer when trace amounts of our patented seeds or traits were present in the farmer’s field as an accident or as a result of inadvertent means. ... The misperception that Monsanto would sue a farmer if GM seed was accidentally in his field likely began with Percy Schmeiser, who was brought to court in Canada by Monsanto for illegally saving Roundup Ready® canola seed. That's analogous to continuing to use a software license after your agreed-upon contract is up, not torrenting.
- enoch_r 11y ago> I disagree that anything is wrong with doing that. The way I see it, he identified that a number of plants were resistant to RoundUp and efficiently figured out which they were. Okay, great, this doesn't matter to you, but surely it's a relevant detail for other people who are deciding whether Monsanto is "evil"? Specifically, for anyone who doesn't already share your set of beliefs about what should be patentable, this is a crucial piece of information. Seriously, even for those who do believe that plants should not be patentable, "farmer willfully breaks (unjust) patent laws" is a different story than "Monsanto blew seeds onto a farmer's property and then sued him for it."
- marincounty 11y ago1. Watch a documentary called Eating Alabama. 2. Keep an eye out for the little farm that used/bought their own seeds. The neighbor's hugh Monsanto crop blew in pollen. Now this little farm had some Monsanto genetic material on their land. The young couple wanted to fight it, but their wiser neighbor told the young couple, "do you have an extra $400,000?". The young couple said no. 3. Just watch the documentary. Do your research from there. I think you just might question Monsanto. Maybe not?
- kusmi 11y agoHow exactly is Monsanto supposed to recoupe the initial investment of generating a transgenic crop and getting it through the FDA to ensure its safe for human consumption if they can only charge for the first generation of seeds. The second generation still contains their unnatural transgene insert (the part which is actually under patent).
- roywiggins 11y agoIn corn at least, hybrid vigor usually means the 2nd generation crop isn't very good and farmers almost always buy new seed every year. This isn't true for all crops, but for corn, buying new seed was common long before GMOs. http://passel.unl.edu/pages/informationmodule.php?idinformationmodule=1075412493&topicorder=9&maxto=12 http://passel.unl.edu/pages/informationmodule.php?idinformat... > The crop produced from open-pollinated seed harvested from a single-cross hybrid will not be as productive as the original single cross.
- a_bonobo 11y agoThis is the correct reason - this has been going on since at least Norman Borlaug's work (the Green Revolution), you can't just keep on seeding your seeds you bought, the seed company has to keep on recreating hybrids. There's a lot of misinformation in this thread, as usual on this topic.
- mirimir 11y agoThey could have made seeds sterile.
- harryh 11y agoDo you think that books should be copyrightable? Software? Movies? Any sort of digital good?
- hibikir 11y agoLicensing restrictions are 100% optional: Nobody is forcing anyone else to plant, say, roundup ready soybeans. It just happens that the seeds that require licensing are that much better than the alternative, an overwhelming majority of farmers plant GMO soybeans. If, say, going organic is more profitable, farmers plant organic crops instead. Farming is a low margin business, nobody is putting a gun to their head one way or the other. If licenses were draconian and not worth it, the farmers would not buy that seed. It's not as if there are compatibility problems if they don't plant what everyone else does! I would have a big problem with licensing myself if the patents lasted 80 years, but, in practice, by the time a patent goes offline, people were buying better anyway. And if at some point agricultural process slows down enough, then we all get the benefit anyway.
- ejolto 11y agoWe went down the dark road of licensing restrictions on farmers almost 90 years ago.. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plant_Patent_Act_of_1930 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plant_Patent_Act_of_1930. Actually the first patent on a living organism dates back to 1873 when Monsieur Louis Pasteur was awarded U.S. Patent [#141,072](http://patimg2.uspto.gov/.piw?docid=US000141072&SectionNum=4&IDKey=5D7B823FAEBB&HomeUrl=http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-Parser?Sect1=PTO1%2526Sect2=HITOFF%2526d=PALL%2526p=1%2526u=%25252Fnetahtml%25252FPTO%25252Fsrchnum.htm%2526r=1%2526f=G%2526l=50%2526 http://patimg2.uspto.gov/.piw?docid=US000141072&SectionNum=4...) with a claim to yeast .
- makomk 11y agoPlant patents didn't cover crops that had to be replanted annually, so the only licensing restriction they imposed on farmers was that they had to get certain varieties of fruit trees and other similar plants from approved breeders (and honestly, I don't think most of them were even that expensive). In 2006 a company did begin using its plant patents on a variety of apple called SweeTango to force farmers to agree to a restrictive contract that forces them to only sell their produce through the apples through them and pay ongoing royalties, but that practice was previously unheard of.