6 ms·
Having done so myself and observed lots of people do it: 1. It's a way to (pointlessly) delay adulthood. 2. Fear of the job market. 3. Don't know what else t
by jseliger 11y ago
Having done so myself and observed lots of people do it:
1. It's a way to (pointlessly) delay adulthood.
2. Fear of the job market.
3. Don't know what else to do.
4. Magical thinking (despite the numerous articles out there, like mine (http://jakeseliger.com/2012/05/22/what-you-should-know-before-you-start-grad-school-in-english-literature-the-economic-financial-and-opportunity-costs/ http://jakeseliger.com/2012/05/22/what-you-should-know-befor...) that attempt to dissuade it). I think this is the biggest issue. In addition, there seems to be a Lake Woebegone effect: Everyone thinks they're going to be above average.
EDIT: I forgot to add another important one: Grad school is pretty easy and fun! You get to hang out on campus, think about ideas, take a minimal number of classes, do a bit of teaching, and have copious free time. The problem is that, as time advances and your priorities start changing (want a real life / job, date people who don't date people whose lives aren't together, etc.), reality starts to intrude. Many grad students have an unacknowledged Peter Pan complex.
- eli_gottlieb 11y ago>Grad school is pretty easy and fun! You get to hang out on campus, think about ideas, take a minimal number of classes, do a bit of teaching, and have copious free time. What on Earth? Did I go to grad-school in an alternate dimension or something?
- iends 11y agoIt's fun (mostly).
- RIMR 11y agoI did really well when I finished my undergraduate program, and my professors kept trying to get me to pursue a Doctorate or PhD. in my field. They were really enthusiastic about it telling me that with my talents I deserve more than a B.A. None of them could give me a convincing answer as to how I would benefit long-term for continuing my education. None of them could give me an example of a job that I would be unable to get with my current level of education. All of them admitted that it would require 4-6 more years of my life, and that even with the best financial aid / scholarships, I would still be paying $60-100k out-of-pocket for the experience. So basically, it would have required me to put off getting a full time job to instead drive myself deep into debt all while sacrificing all of my free-time until I was 30. Instead, I moved to Seattle, found a job in I.T. and I have been climbing the corporate ladder ever since, making more than enough money to live comfortably and save money. I was lucky enough to earn my B.A. without any student debt. My degree isn't even in an I.T. field. I have a B.A. in Journalism! The thing that has done more to further my resume has been my full-time employment and my technical certifications. I get to expense my certifications to my company... Furthering my education would have ruined my future. Ending my education has accelerated it. Sadly, I worry that this is going to become true of Undergrad programs in the next decade, and that's not a good thing...
- beambot 11y agoIn STEM, if you don't get a financial offer along with your PhD program acceptance letter, then you've probably just been politely rejected. The financial offer will usually cover your living costs (a few $k per month), so it won't cover any lost opportunity costs... but you shouldn't need to take on debt to do your PhD in STEM. I'm guessing journalism is a different story! For STEM, it's also true that certain job opportunities (eg. elite R&D facilities) more-or-less require a PhD or equivalent levels of mastery. It's possible to obtain those jobs after a long period of field work (without PhD), but it's a lot more difficult. Plus, you will always be butting up against credentialing norms during those jobs' recruiting processes. (Whether that's equitable or not is another story.) Just my $0.02.
- archgoon 11y ago> In STEM, if you don't get a financial offer along with your acceptance letter, then you've actually been politely rejected. This is important. I thought at the time that I accepted that it was due to the massive budget cuts happening in California, and the UC's were undergoing furloughs. Oops.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- selimthegrim 11y agoWhich UC was this, if I may ask? I heard isolated rumors of this happening at Santa Barbara, for one...
- Joof 11y agoThey don't make this clear. The culture is very insular.
- daodedickinson 11y agoA prof I know at Berkeley won't let anyone in the Ph.D. program unless he can secure funding for them. He's in a humanities major, though. Maybe in STEM profs think they can land a job to pay it off.
- threatofrain 11y agoSome practicing, non-research positions are gated and require a doctorate, such as psychology.
- barry-cotter 11y agoLegally required qualifications may make a nod towards being for the good of the general population but there's a great deal of rent seeking involved. In Germany until a few years ago you could practice as a psychotherapist after doing your Master's (which included a large practical component.) Now they tacked on more post graduation training time. In the USA and other unfortunate countries that follow its example medicine, dentistry and law are all postgraduate degrees, elsewhwere they're undergraduate. In the USA until recently physiotherapy was a Master's degree. Now they require a "professional doctorate" like an Ed.D. or Psy.D. You can still practice in the US with a Bachelor's in physiotherapy acquired in Europe. In Germany physiotherapy is an apprenticeship. In my home country of Ireland they recently increased the necessary qualifications for teaching from a one year post bachelor's diploma to a Master's. This despite the fact that the evidence for positive effects of teaching qualification on effectiveness are minimal, at best. Credentialism.
- a_bonobo 11y ago>In Germany until a few years ago you could practice as a psychotherapist after doing your Master's (which included a large practical component.) Now they tacked on more post graduation training time. I think in the special German case this was made to allow for more career switching - I have a relative who has a diploma in Pedagogy, he took one of the new short psychotherapy courses ("post graduation training time") and is now a certified child psychologist, a career that was before this new course impossible for him without the prior psychology degrees.
- threatofrain 11y agoMany disciplines don't have a reliable way of predicting professional performance from a simple test, like the actuarial discipline, and I think psychology and pedagogy would be among those fields. So, an employer looking at many undifferentiated candidates would likely choose someone with a masters or doctorate, if not at least to cover their hiring decision if ever questioned. The development of a fast and cost-efficient test would lower the need for credentials as a gateway.
- brownbat 11y ago> Magical thinking (despite the numerous articles out there... I think humanity applies the lessons from these articles in the aggregate, but at an individual level, this is a much messier story. It features people (like myself) who didn't really understand or place any importance on marketability when asked to choose a major at 17. Four years later you get another fun choice: accept your current job prospects, grab an advanced degree, or start from scratch on a different undergrad degree, which is psychologically quite hard.[0] I know a lot of people push for universally free college tuition. A part of me though would much rather encourage school loans that signal to students the viability of their major by adjusting interest rates or availability of credit based on the field of study. Though that has it's problems too. We'd want to pay teachers considerably more, for instance. Ok, I mostly just wish someone had handed me a copy of "So Good They Can't Ignore You" when I was young and stupid. [0] And some people successfully convince a great manager to take a chance on them. That involves a lot of search costs and a lot of luck, though. It also filters for risk-tolerant employers, which becomes a high-risk strategy itself.
- mathattack 11y agoAll of your reasons are valid. I would add one more: 5. Academic success has been rewarded every step of the way. I look at my high school classmates who I know went on to get Phds. (Sample size of 8) All of them were among the smartest few percent in the class. Every success that they got through the end of undergrad was due to academic performance. But afterwards things slowed down. Only 2 of 8 stayed through to tenure. The two smartest got Phds in math and wound up in non-faculty positions. One other got a science industry job. One wound up at a hedge fund. And two teach high school. All things considered it's not a bad lot in life, but these were amongst the best and brightest of my peer group. Five of Seven would have been better served taking other paths to their end destinations. There is a systemic incentives problem going on. Every individual school has an incentive to push as many people as possible into academia. This is for both cheap labor, and because their brand goes up when absolute #s of their grads go on to big things. The schools in aggregate also benefit when there are more Phd grads than job applicants. (Again keeps costs down) The systemic over-supply punishes the graduates as a whole. It's a case where the individuals who have gotten the most mileage listening to their teachers, are also the ones who most need to stop listening to them. :-)
- civilian 11y agoYeah! I did my senior thesis in an 8-person biochemistry lab, graduated in 2009. I was probably solidly in the bottom 2 students of the group. I was just as smart as my labmates, and I had a lack of attention to detail and a weak work ethic. A handful of them went on to more education, and most of them stayed in the field. I think I might be doing the best, career-wise, unless any of them pivoted to be a medical doctor. I got fired from a biotech job (that pesky work-ethic...) and learned python while working data-entry. Being a C student in college kinda paid off, if it helped me dodge a career in the life sciences. Linkedin/FB stalked, of the 8 of us we have: Research Associate (has a Masters now), Phd/MD Student, Scientist II, Research Lab Tech (might be unemployed & traveling the world?), Research Lab Tech, PhD Student, Physician's Assistant, Senior Software Eng. All but one of these people are harder-working than I am, and all are just as smart. I just lucked out by having an economist for my dad, who planted the idea that I should look at switching to a field in demand.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y ago> Grad school is pretty easy and fun This is not a universally shared experience.
- sbardle 11y agoOn point number 1, since we are living longer (Happy Birthday, Your Majesty), there is a logic to delaying adulthood by around 5 years until your mid to late 20s. Grad school can also be a great place to date, and the time can be used to reflect on what you really want to do in the future. All your points resonate with me and the people I knew in grad school. I had two criteria when it came to doing a PhD: it had to be funded and it had to be relatively short (so UK rather than the US).
- tiplus 11y agoMy experience was different. 1. It's a way to (pointlessly) delay adulthood. adulthood != working for a company Developing the next CRISPR, detecting gravitational waves, or building a stellator is a pretty grown up thing. In the end there is a non zero chance of achieving or contributing to something exceptional during your 20s (depending on your field). 2. Fear of the job market. Well said. No other entity is recruiting young undergrads like academia does. Only topped by consulting firms, maybe. 3. Don't know what else to do. The fellow students I encountered (~30) were mostly driven/obsessed by curiosity (2-3 exceptions maybe). 4. Magical thinking Academia problem or society in general? This pattern prevails everywhere. disclaimer: physics PhD
- jerf 11y ago"Developing the next CRISPR, detecting gravitational waves, or building a stellator is a pretty grown up thing. In the end there is a non zero chance of achieving or contributing to something exceptional during your 20s (depending on your field)." It is a mistake to look at a field full of so many thousands of people and focus on the outliers. The common case of the PhD experience is proving cheap labor to a tenured professor on their projects while moving your own PhD process forward, in a field that lacks the hard science component that allows you to paint such a glowing image of the process. You dipped into physics twice, in fact; even accidentally, I'd suggest this means something. Further, both fields you named are fields where getting a PhD still leaves you quite eminently hireable even if you "fail out" of academia... this, too, is not the common experience. Someone getting their PhD needs to make sure they ask questions about what is most likely, not what the most awesome possibilities are, who are, by that very token, getting drowned in applications for those positions. Do you have a good story as to why you will get those positions?
- msdos 11y agoNo other entity is recruiting young undergrads like academia does. The military does.
- rinzao 11y agoI really fall under #3. My wife got a job offer which implied relocating on a short notice. I wasn't finding any work at all and a PhD seemed like a way to keep busy for 3 years doing something (potentially) interesting.
- dagw 11y ago1. It's a way to (pointlessly) delay adulthood. That one I don't get. Having watched my wife get her PhD, I'd say that it requires at least much "adulthood" (place in that word what you will) as any job I've ever had, and probably a lot more.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Gibbon1 11y agoI'm reminded of sitting first day in class, English 101. The teacher said 'I won't accept late work in this class' And I'm like fair enough. Then she added 'because when you get out into the real world your boss won't accept late work' And the other students are nodding their heads while I'm trying hard not to snort coke out my nose. The difference between me, the other students and the teacher was I'd had been working at technical job through school. In the real world crap's late all the time. Meeting the deadline involves jettisoning requirements like the sailors in a stricken ship tossing valuable cargo over side. You know your wife is an adult. And school actually is the real world. Grad school is often harder, you don't have a boss. You don't have tasks that are neatly sectioned. Work places tend to be organized to psychologically pressure you into getting stuff done. Self motivation is a big factor in being successful in school. Lot of students don't get that though. And the potential transition out of school seems scary. So they punt.