13 ms·
FYI, this is the same company that sues farmers for re-planting seeds that blew onto their land: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monsanto_Canada_Inc_v_Schmeiser h
by koolba 11y ago
FYI, this is the same company that sues farmers for re-planting seeds that blew onto their land: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monsanto_Canada_Inc_v_Schmeiser https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monsanto_Canada_Inc_v_Schmeise...
I don't use the phrase "evil" often to describe corporations but Monsanto makes the cut.
- hodwik2 11y agoThat was thoroughly disproved. They sue people who have ~90%+ Monsanto crops on their fields who aren't paying royalties. You can't get 90% of a different cultivar from pollen blowing multiple miles into your field. It doesn't work that way. In fact, the company has offered to pay to remove accidentally contaminated crops for you, so that they can't be sued for having their IP on your farm.
- koolba 11y agoWhat business is it of there's how I ended up with it? If I didn't sign a license agreement then I can do what I want with those seeds. That includes planting them, spraying them with roundup, then planting the survivors. Their business model depends on farmers agreeing to licensing their seeds. Nothing says that those farmers have to agree to that. If those same seeds are available elsewhere, whether brought by the wind or just bought locally, a farmer who has NOT signed any sort of agreement can do whatever they'd like with them.
- hodwik2 11y agoExtend this logic to other intellectual properties, and explore the consequences. PC-Company-A signs no license with Microsoft. An employee of theirs finds a copy of Microsoft Windows laying on the ground. Having no agreement with MSFT, and having discovered Windows "on the wind", as it were, they start to install it on their PCs. Is it Microsoft's business? PC-Company-A has no license with them, why should it matter?
- Fargren 11y agoCan the employee install Windows without accepting a Microsoft EULA? I don't think the case is identical.
- hodwik2 11y agoThey can with a modified copy of Windows. Is that what makes or breaks it from being intellectual property theft? I ask, because it would be pretty easy to add a jump in the Windows binary to skip the EULA -- Free Windows for life!
- techthroway443 11y agoPretty sure modifying copies of Windows so that you are circumventing the EULA constitutes a crime in of itself.
- eru 11y agoAssume he finds the modified copy of Windows on the ground. (Ie someone anonymously took out the check.)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- E6300 11y agoIn that case, no, Microsoft would not be able to do anything to someone who found a Windows DVD modified to remove the EULA check: 1. Copyright would not be involved because copyright cover the reproduction and distribution of content. You did neither. It'd be the same if someone photocopied a book and you found the copy on the ground. You might argue that "well, you need to copy the software from the DVD to the system". If that's a problem, imagine that the mysterious individual also somehow installed the OS on your computer without your knowledge. 2. Patent law doesn't apply because patents (in theory) cover the application of techniques and technologies. Patents are irrelevant to end-users. 3. As stated before, the EULA also doesn't apply. IMO, applying patents to living organisms is completely bogus, conceptually. It'd make more sense if the genetic information of the organism was copyrighted. Then it would make some sense to talk about unlicensed copies being made, although it'd still be rather tenuous. Copyright wasn't thought for self-replicating and randomly-modifying data. Has a law been broken if a disc undergoes mitosis? How many words would you need to change for a book to no longer be considered the same?
- traek 11y agoBecause the case rested on patent infringement, not contract violation? People don't need to sign a license agreement to be bound by patent law. > Their business model depends on farmers agreeing to licensing their seeds. Nothing says that those farmers have to agree to that. The entire concept of patents disagrees with you. If the farmers don't agree to a license, they cannot legally use the invention.
- koolba 11y ago> The entire legal concept concept of patents disagrees with you. I'll leave it an exercise to the reader on whether I agree with idea of patents on plants (or software).
- pdabbadabba 11y agoClearly you don't, but you haven't given us any reason to agree with you!
- rhino369 11y ago>What business is it of there's how I ended up with it? If I didn't sign a license agreement then I can do what I want with those seeds. That includes planting them, spraying them with roundup, then planting the survivors. 35 U.S.C § 271 makes it their business.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deepnet 11y agoThe 90% figure is Monsanto's figure not independently tested. The Roundup corn was grown in the neighbouring field. The Schmeisers had to sue Monsanto in the small claims court for $640, because Monsanto refused to remove the corn, nor would they allow the Schmeisers to do so. They would only remove the corn if the Schmeisers signed a gag order which they were not prepared to do. The Schmeisers ( now growing mustard as their seedstock no longer belonged to them ) paid their neighbours $640 to remove the corn. The facts are the opposite of what you suggest.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- lordCarbonFiber 11y ago>Sues companies for replanting seeds then using taking advantage of the fact and treat their jobs with the corresponding pesticide. From that very article: the trial judge found that with respect to the 1998 crop, "none of the suggested sources [proposed by Schmeiser] could reasonably explain the concentration or extent of Roundup Ready canola of a commercial quality" ultimately present in Schmeiser's 1998 crop. Say what you want about the business practices, your example of a company legally enforcing their licensing agreements is probably not the best if you're trying to demonstrate "evil".
- sgift 11y agoThis assumes he bases his judgement of Monsanto on the judges decision, which he can, but doesn't have to do.
- pdabbadabba 11y agoOf course he doesn't have to. But the judge's decision does seem to be the most reliable source of information available about what actually happened, factually, in the case. One would think a reasonable person would find it at least relevant. One does not normally start spraying ones crops with RoundUp. This, as they say, kills the crop. That the farmer did so and just happened to wind up with a large population of RoundUp Ready plants clearly suggests that the farmer was breeding them selectively to get the Monsanto patented plants for free, not just that they "happened" to be there and reproduce.
- technotony 11y agoYour allegations miss a crucial detail, Monsanto sued farmers who planted seeds and then sprayed them with herbicide[1]. Ie the farmer knew what he was doing and used the patented trait. Why shouldn’t Monsanto sue over that? Like many things in GMO land the myth that they sue accidental contamination is wrong. Monsanto has the worst PR team in history, which has made my company’s work much harder, but ‘Monsanto is Evil’ is a marketing slogan developed by Greenpeace, Friends of the Earth etc. These environmental groups are actually the true evil in the industry. Their campaigning has held back progress in the industry by many years. Smarter folks than me argue that their actions on Golden Rice meet all the criteria to be considered a crime against humanity[2] [1] http://www.monsanto.com/newsviews/pages/gm-seed-accidentally-in-farmers-fields.aspx http://www.monsanto.com/newsviews/pages/gm-seed-accidentally... [2] http://www.allowgoldenricenow.org/the-crime-against-humanity http://www.allowgoldenricenow.org/the-crime-against-humanity
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- koolba 11y ago> Your allegations miss a crucial detail, Monsanto sued farmers who planted seeds and then sprayed them with herbicide[1]. Ie the farmer knew what he was doing and used the patented trait. Why shouldn’t Monsanto sue over that? Like many things in GMO land the myth that they sue accidental contamination is wrong. I disagree that anything is wrong with doing that. The way I see it, he identified that a number of plants were resistant to RoundUp and efficiently figured out which they were. It's not his fault that Monsanto's business model fails to meet up with the reality that plants have plantable seeds. > Monsanto has the worst PR team in history, which has made my company’s work much harder, but ‘Monsanto is Evil’ is a marketing slogan developed by Greenpeace, Friends of the Earth etc. These environmental groups are actually the true evil in the industry. Their campaigning has held back progress in the industry by many years. Smarter folks than me argue that their actions on Golden Rice meet all the criteria to be considered a crime against humanity[2] Friend of the earth (lower case without a ™ symbol) sure, but I'm no tree hugger. I'm not against GMOs and think Golden Rice is amazing. I just don't like the idea of imposing licensing restrictions on farmers. It's a dark road that we don't need to go down.
- yodsanklai 11y ago> I don't use the phrase "evil" often to describe corporations but Monsanto makes the cut. They also manufactured the infamous "agent orange" during the vietnam war. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agent_Orange https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agent_Orange
- DominoTree 11y agoMonsanto was one of a number of manufacturers that the DOD ordered 2,4,5-T from, and they warned the US Government about the dioxin issue literally decades before they stopped using it, and they tried to raise at least some awareness of the issue before many other manufacturers even knew about it. From the article that you linked: Additionally "Boehringer, which used the relatively safer low-temperature-process since 1957, in the same year warned the other producers of 2,4,5-TCP, which were using the high-temperature-process, pointing out the risk[vague] and providing suggestions how to avoid them."[28] Internal memoranda revealed that Monsanto (a major manufacturer of 2,4,5-T) had informed the U.S. government in 1952 that its 2,4,5-T was contaminated.[29] In the manufacture of 2,4,5-T, accidental overheating of the reaction mixture easily causes the product to condense into the toxic self-condensation product TCDD. At the time, precautions were not taken against this unintended side reaction, which also caused the Seveso disaster in Italy in 1976. The employment of 2,4,5-T by the military rapidly ended, according to the American Cancer Society, following the convincing results of a study in 1970 that found 2,4,5-T could cause birth defects in lab animals.[30] So yeah, Monsanto warned the US government of the problem 10 years before the start of Operation Ranch Hand, and they were ignored. And I can't really fault a chemical company for manufacturing chemicals when the DOD orders them.
- unclebucknasty 11y ago>I can't really fault a chemical company for manufacturing chemicals when the DOD orders them. Why not?
- enoch_r 11y agoWow. This is incredibly dishonest. Monsanto sues farmers for re-planting seeds that blow onto their land, spraying all of their crops with roundup (killing the non-Monsanto plants), and re-planting the survivors. If you don't believe in patenting plants, fine. But please don't try to convince people by telling them that Monsanto sues poor, hapless farmers for things they can't control, which is what your summary implies.
- mejari 11y agoThis is an incredibly irrational comment and it's sad that it is the top comment for any article on HN.
- tn13 11y agoThat is simply incorrect and probably nothing more than propaganda. Monsanto is not some alien company, it is just another company like Tesla, Google, Facebook or Ford. They are full of people working hard to increase agricultural productivity. It is because of them the third world can afford more food then ever. Yeah, they are probably as ruthless as anyone else in seeking profit but they are not. No one has forced the farmers to use their seeds. Farmers are opting for it willingly. I find Tesla motors far more evil that uses Tax payer's money to subsidize rich people's car that does not even run 300 miles.
- forrestthewoods 11y agoThat's not even remotely true. I don't blame you. Most people fall for the lie.
- seattle_spring 11y agoHoly cow, you (and many of other posters) are seriously misinformed. I recommend getting your information from somewhere other than blogs, documentaries, and NaturalNews.
- ptaipale 11y agoYou misrepresent the case Monsanto vs. Schmeiser. It very specifically was not about accidentally re-planting seeds that "blew" onto their land; the farmer was intentionally using Monsanto's breed of seeds commercially. Monsanto or not, every seed breed developer has right to protect their IPR.
- bootload 11y ago"same company that sues farmers for re-planting seeds" watch the 10min Documentary, "Seeding Fear", Michael White Vs Monsanto [0] by Neil Young [1] [0] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YZGueeao0tE http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YZGueeao0tE [1] http://www.rollingstone.com/music/news/see-neil-youngs-monsanto-themed-mini-documentary-seeding-fear-20150723 http://www.rollingstone.com/music/news/see-neil-youngs-monsa...