2 ms·
No. The strengths of this UI is simple, good-looking organization that loads lightening-fast. Even works with NoScript easily while yours was a pile of links. I
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
No. The strengths of this UI is simple, good-looking organization that loads lightening-fast. Even works with NoScript easily while yours was a pile of links. If you want to benefit HN users, I'd suggest toying with variations of this exact design that try to solve problems people here gripe about.
Here's two with the first one probably very easy:
1. People accidentally downvote comments trying to upvote them. I can imagine no technical or UX excuse for this problem still existing. It's sooo easy to solve. Somewhere, someone is giving an order to keep it a problem probably for aesthetic reasons.
2. Comment nesting. A tricky problem in general for so many reasons. People gripe about this version of it sometimes. My only gripe is some way to restructure the presentation so deep nesting doesn't just push further and further to the right. Can be optional.
3. One of biggest complaints is how a tangent unrelated to OP takes up the whole screen and it's hard to find next reply to OP. This is actually two different problems: can't easily see how conversations are connected without parent links and them taking up the whole screen. The screen issue might be helped with little plus or minus symbols to hide a whole thread. The other one I leave to UX designers as it's trickier to balance form and function. A simple method might be an optional link on site top-level or comment that turns on some kind of highlighting putting different color, labeled boxes around grouped comments. Maybe limit groups to just first replies to OP & anything nested in them rather than everyones replies to everyone.
I think solving these three issues would be helpful. And notifications of replies, too. There's already a service for that but it's a nice feature to have in any HN client. Hope this helps you on next round. :)
- bobwaycott 11y agoIf all 3 of these were solved, I'd be at risk of never growing tired of using HN on mobile and closing it to get other things done.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoAppreciate the feedback as I put mental effort into that list. :) Anything else that should be on there that gets lots of gripes rather than one or two people's preferences?