6 ms·
I'm not sure I want to be there if they carriers have been sunk :-). That said, Carrier survivability is a pretty big deal in naval doctrine, between the ring
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
I'm not sure I want to be there if they carriers have been sunk :-).
That said, Carrier survivability is a pretty big deal in naval doctrine, between the ring of cruisers and destroyers in a typical battle group providing ship missile defense to ABM defense from the Aegis class cruisers, and subs and aircraft providing ASW defense. It is going to be pretty hard to get close enough to a carrier to sink it in a 'hot war' situation. And while I could see one or two getting taken out while the country was still at Defcon 3 or 4, once one got hit that would all change.
I got to tour the Carl Vinson when it was in Oakland, its a pretty amazing ship. The MQ-XX program is one where ships like the Carl Vinson can add additional air patrol and farther over the horizon engagements. That would seem to extend the depth of the defense.
- SEJeff 11y agoThat isn't as unlikely as you think. This incident made more than a few Admirals red in the face that they weren't aware of this sub: http://www.popularmechanics.com/military/navy-ships/news/a18094/a-chinese-submarine-stalked-an-american-aircraft-carrier/ http://www.popularmechanics.com/military/navy-ships/news/a18...
- bcoates 11y agoSurely the exact submarine detection capabilities of a carrier group are a major military secret? It would be crazy to acknowledge a submarine that didn't announce itself even if you did or could have detected it.
- 67726e 11y agoExactly right. Why would we want to let the "enemy" know our capabilities? If they're not a threat, ignore it. There is a reason the Allies were careful in choosing to act on decrypted messages after they cracked the Enigma.
- greedo 11y agoTwo bad we just had a major security breach with someone conversant with our latest technology.
- sickbeard 11y agois this like playing hide and seek with your kid and pretending you didn't see him?
- gozur88 11y agoThe only people who know for sure aren't talking. You don't react to a sub the minute you discover it in peacetime. It gives away too much information about the quality of your sensors. They may have discovered it far from the fleet, or may have missed it, or anywhere in between. Also, during wartime fleets will be using active sonar. It's going to be a lot harder for subs to hide.
- nostrademons 11y agoThe way to kill a carrier strike group today is to make them run out of bullets. An Arleigh-burke class destroyer carries 96 missiles, a Ticonderoga carries 122. Assuming you've got 2 squadrons of F-18s overhead, that's 2 * 12 * 6 = 144 additional missiles. Additionally, you've got Phalanxes etc. for close in warfare, capable of engaging another couple dozen targets. The CSG as a whole can engage (rough order of magnitude) 1000 simultaneous targets. What happens if you send in 10,000 flying bombs simultaneously? Each of these would be exceptionally simple: a couple thousand pounds of TNT or other explosive, a basic aluminum airframe, control servos, a lot of fuel (enough for a couple thousand mile range), a small jet or even turboprop engine, a microchip, and a communications uplink. You could probably build this for about $10K with COTS hardware. $10K * 10K missiles = $100M, to sink a carrier group that cost tens of billions and carries 7500 lives. In a one-to-one contest with modern U.S. weaponry, every single one of these devices would lose. The point is to force that 1:1 tradeoff, because you have more than an order of magnitude more weaponry. All of U.S. military doctrine is based on the assumption that manpower is the limiting resource. You can't currently launch a 10,000-plane aerial attack on a CSG, because most nations aren't willing to sacrifice 10,000 pilots in a suicide mission, and even if they were, you can't coordinate 10,000 people in any meaningful way, nor do you have the airfield or aircraft capacity for it. You can coordinate 10,000 microchips in a meaningful way, and these drones can be a lot smaller and launch off of carriers that are themselves drones (or freighters, or fishing boats, or airliners, or other craft that look a lot like civilian vessels) and hence expendable.
- greedo 11y agoFirst your opponent would have to find the carrier. Easier said than done. Next they would have to be able to target it with these drones. The drones would have to be fast, (otherwise the carrier has moved out of reach), long ranged (otherwise the airwing will neutralize the launchers) and completely autonomous (otherwise the carrier and its escorts will jam any comlinks. If you think you could build such a weapon for $10K, good luck.
- logfromblammo 11y agoIf my mission were to take out a carrier group, and I had a budget of $100M, I would go a slightly different direction. I'd shop Alibaba for 300 hp diesel outboard motors, and rigid-hull hydroplaning inflatable boats with at least 2000 kg maximum cargo weight. Then I'd build some one-ton armor-penetrating bombs and 19 times that number of cheap decoys. My engineers would rig up the steering and throttle controls to some servos, connected to a system-on-a-chip, connected to some cheap sensors that could determine distance and direction to nearby objects and discriminate between big ship and little boat. The software on the SOC would have a flocking/schooling AI that would maintain separation between vessels while seeking to maneuver the bows of many small boats into contact with any large ship. Any boat carrying a non-decoy bomb detonates it on contact. It would be about as complex as an insect brain. For bonus points, the boats would be spitting flares, smoke, mylar helium balloons, and chaff everywhere as they approach. Perhaps a few would conceal a conventional torpedo. As you say, the hard part is getting the weapons to the targets. With a setup like this, you really need to have the carrier group come to you. The inflatables can certainly outrun a carrier, but they have much shorter range. Perhaps the boats could be deployed by submarines? I think each decoy boat could probably be deployed for less than $2000. The bomb boats would be that, plus the cost of the bomb. There would be no radios to jam. There's no particular reason the drones need to be airborne, other than for speed and maneuverability, and you're trading that in for sheer numbers (40000+) anyway. Besides that, it's a lot easier to float a one-ton bomb than it is to fly it, and it would do more damage at or below the waterline than on a deck. If US carrier groups are not wargaming this type of scenario, they probably should, both as underway-at-sea and in-the-harbor attacks.
- kqr2 11y agoThere is concern that US aircraft carriers are vulnerable to a barrage of long-range anti-ship ballistic missiles such as the DF-21D: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DF-21 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DF-21 If the carriers are vulnerable then they need to stay very far away which limits the combat effectiveness of its aircraft since they must now deploy from very far away.
- Shivetya 11y agoNah, the US Navy has already obsoleted their own carriers by developing rail gun technology. You don't need an explosive payload when you can just shoot over the horizon at speeds that exceed most missiles. 10kg slugs traveling at mach 7 are a bit much to shoot down and they will be able to put a lot of the in flight. Then in all out war you don't have to get that close with a heavy nuke to take down a carrier flotilla. The biggest deterrent to war between US, Russia, China, and similarly sized nations, is free trade. The amount of investment in countries that would participate in such a war is so high that its a deterrent all its own
- Jtsummers 11y agoIt's only obsoleted when it's replaced. We have lots of things that are "obsolete", but still exist. And, see the F-35, there's no reason to go all-in on a singular technology, rather than using a new, more advanced, technology as a supplement to your older tech. Phase out the old as you find it's unneeded. Also, rail guns don't replace the role of the aircraft that a carrier transports. It replaces some long range missile roles, and maybe some defensive cannon roles. But helicopters, jets, and now drones will need a platform to launch for other missions besides "blow shit up".