3 ms·
As soon as drones are required to have geofencing, you will find they become useless for monitoring the police, factory farms, pollution, "black" sites, etc. Hu
by Zigurd 11y ago
As soon as drones are required to have geofencing, you will find they become useless for monitoring the police, factory farms, pollution, "black" sites, etc. Humans die because of those things, while no practical benefit to aviation safety has been proven. And yeah, controlled airspace has been used to prevent monitoring of police, in Ferguson, for example.
- sosborn 11y agoIf we argue that regulations don't stop criminals (DRM etc) then doesn't it also hold true that regulations wouldn't stop do-gooders? (sorry, not the best word).
- iamnothere 11y agoIt wouldn't stop activists from filming "restricted" areas, no, but it could give authorities a way to tack on additional charges ("terroristic disabling of an aviation safety device" or the like) when they inevitably find the person who leaked the video.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- cpncrunch 11y agoAnother slippery slope argument. We're talking purely about controlled airspace here. Those things you mention have never been controlled airspace.
- setra 11y agoIn general the slippery slope is not actually a fallacy.
- jdietrich 11y agoBritish law is very restrictive on the use of camera-equipped UAVs. Without specific permission from the CAA, it is unlawful to use a small unmanned surveillance aircraft within 150 metres of "any congested area" or within 50 metres of "any vessel, vehicle or structure which is not under the control of the person in charge of the aircraft".
- jle17 11y agoIt's a common tactic used by governments to push a restriction under a (often emotional) motive that looks legitimate at first and then extend it further. "We need to do this or that because terrorism and won't somebody please think of the children." "Well, now that it's in place, it would be a shame not to use it against illegal <insert something harmless or subversive here>." And usually they manage to design laws so that diverting their use doesn't require passing through parliament again.