5 ms·
This reminds me a lot of the development of aircraft carriers during WW1 and the interwar period. At first, all aircraft carriers were converted tankers/freigh
by nostrademons 11y ago
This reminds me a lot of the development of aircraft carriers during WW1 and the interwar period.
At first, all aircraft carriers were converted tankers/freighters/cruisers/etc, and aircraft were only used for scouting (much like drones here will be used as tankers). Then came the converted battlecruisers - the capital ships of the day, much like the USS Carl Vinson is now. Even then, people didn't trust carrier-based air power: Lexington and Saratoga had a full suite of 8-inch guns, in case they ended up in a surface engagement. It was only in the run up to war in the late-30s that major parties started commissioning purpose-built aircraft carriers, and then only in small numbers.
I predict that in the next major conflict, aircraft carriers will be utterly useless, most of our big flat-tops will be sunk in the first couple months, and the bulk of combat will fall to a large fleet of inexpensive drones. And then the AI controlling them will gain sentience and we'll be forced to send one of these drones back in time to save John Connor so that he can become the leader of the Resistance as they take over humanity...
- djrogers 11y ago> most of our big flat-tops will be sunk in the first couple months Carriers as they exist today may well become as obsolete as the Battleships of WW2, but there isn't a navy in the world that can currently get enough firepower inside the envelope of a single U.S. carrier battlegroup to sink a carrier, let alone all of them.
- dforrestwilson 11y agoLob enough hypersonic missiles at something as big as a carrier, and things will get through. Momentum alone will carry a "defeated" missile to the target if it's going fast enough. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DF-21 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DF-21 The carrier is becoming a relic.
- nickff 11y agoCurrent hypersonic missiles require extensive guidance to intercept their targets (i.e. hit them); momentum will carry a defeated hypersonic missile right into the water. The Dongfeng 21 is a ballistic missile, and not usually referred to as hypersonic; the latter usually refers to cruise missiles capable of travel at > Mach 3. In addition, the DF-21 is very unlikely to be used in a conventional war, as it may look like a tactical nuclear weapon. The DF-21 is also relatively easy to intercept, and could only be successful if used in a saturation attack; the Wikipedia article is written more like an advertisement than a fact-based informational piece.
- dforrestwilson 11y agoYes your point is valid now. How much does it cost to develop and build an aircraft carrier? How much does it cost to develop and build better anti-ship missiles? How hard would combatants object to use of tactical nukes over the ocean? Why are we still chucking rockets with men attached to them into the air when a rocket without men is cheaper and able to pull more Gs?
- rhino369 11y agoTargeting is really hard. Carriers move around and these are susceptible to electronic counter measures.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ChuckMcM 11y agoI'm not sure I want to be there if they carriers have been sunk :-). That said, Carrier survivability is a pretty big deal in naval doctrine, between the ring of cruisers and destroyers in a typical battle group providing ship missile defense to ABM defense from the Aegis class cruisers, and subs and aircraft providing ASW defense. It is going to be pretty hard to get close enough to a carrier to sink it in a 'hot war' situation. And while I could see one or two getting taken out while the country was still at Defcon 3 or 4, once one got hit that would all change. I got to tour the Carl Vinson when it was in Oakland, its a pretty amazing ship. The MQ-XX program is one where ships like the Carl Vinson can add additional air patrol and farther over the horizon engagements. That would seem to extend the depth of the defense.
- SEJeff 11y agoThat isn't as unlikely as you think. This incident made more than a few Admirals red in the face that they weren't aware of this sub: http://www.popularmechanics.com/military/navy-ships/news/a18094/a-chinese-submarine-stalked-an-american-aircraft-carrier/ http://www.popularmechanics.com/military/navy-ships/news/a18...
- bcoates 11y agoSurely the exact submarine detection capabilities of a carrier group are a major military secret? It would be crazy to acknowledge a submarine that didn't announce itself even if you did or could have detected it.
- 67726e 11y agoExactly right. Why would we want to let the "enemy" know our capabilities? If they're not a threat, ignore it. There is a reason the Allies were careful in choosing to act on decrypted messages after they cracked the Enigma.
- greedo 11y agoTwo bad we just had a major security breach with someone conversant with our latest technology.
- kposehn 11y agoOutside the last sentence (I was thinking Ghost in the Shell for the future, not Terminator) you echo something I've been thinking as well almost exactly. The US strategic imperative is control of the oceans. Drones of all kinds will create a totally new way of the US to control them, or for other nations to deny them to us.
- Raphmedia 11y agoControl over the oceans is all well and good until someone militarize space. You can't keep war chained forever.
- SEJeff 11y agoThis makes it a good bit harder for most of the "super powers" to do just that, at least overtly: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Outer_Space_Treaty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Outer_Space_Treaty
- stcredzero 11y agoThe Naval treaties of the 20th century were so ironclad and effective! (Not!)
- angersock 11y agoAnd that someone is likely to be the US, if we haven't already.
- pjmorris 11y ago> most of our big flat-tops will be sunk in the first couple months I'd expect that anyone starting a shooting war with the US wouldn't do it until they were sure they could take out the carriers in 1-2 days. Say, via hypersonic drones or de-orbiting kinetic payloads. At least, that's been my expectation for what they'd eventually call WW3.
- gogopuppygogo 11y agoThen the Mutually Assured Destruction Doctrine kicks in and we all die in an apocalyptic nuclear fire. Though John Conner will lead the resistance so at least we have that.
- mturmon 11y agoJust for reference on this kind of system: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DF-21#DF-21D https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DF-21#DF-21D "This is the first ASBM and weapon system capable of targeting a moving aircraft carrier strike group from long-range, land-based mobile launchers." The asymmetry of a single missile strike sinking a huge vessel brings to mind the Exocet that sank the Sheffield in 1982 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HMS_Sheffield_(D80)#Sinking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HMS_Sheffield_(D80)#Sinking).
- rndmize 11y agoI've been wondering if perhaps we should be looking into new submarines that can launch drones from missile tubes and surface to collect them at a later point. Seems like it would allow faster, more flexible and more stealthy power projection in a lot of cases.
- nickff 11y agoThis has been looked at.[1][2] [1] http://www.northropgrumman.com/Capabilities/UAVCapsuleLaunch/Documents/payload.pdf http://www.northropgrumman.com/Capabilities/UAVCapsuleLaunch... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_Martin_Cormorant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_Martin_Cormorant
- jallmann 11y agoThe Navy's moves seem sensible here. The next generation of naval drones are being used for in-air refueling and reconnaissance. You may say it's because we don't "trust" drones -- but the fact is, we are a LONG way from fully autonomous anything. (Saying otherwise is simply fantasizing over an indeterminate time-frame.) Humans will be in the loop for the foreseeable future, especially when it comes to pulling the trigger. Even more so with fast movers like the F-18. Consider: why do we need attack aircraft if cruise missiles are good enough for all bombing roles? They aren't. > I predict that in the next major conflict, aircraft carriers will be utterly useless, most of our big flat-tops will be sunk in the first couple months Aircraft carriers (and submarines) will be critical to victory in any major conflict, especially in the Pacific. We do have to keep them afloat though [1]. Otherwise we're likely to see an effective stalemate if nobody can maintain control of the seas, the US is simply too far out of reach for most of the world. At that point, we may well be in nuclear territory... > bulk of combat will fall to a large fleet of inexpensive drones Air combat? Eh. (See my earlier comment about fantasizing...) But you can't win with air power alone. I know you were being tongue-in-cheek with the Terminator references, but lest the Internets take you seriously: we are even farther away from robotic "boots on the ground" than we are from fully autonomous flying drones, and we're not even close to the latter. If we really wanted to speculate on a somewhat-realistic, near-future, large-scale conflict, I'd consider what happens when all our satellites are blown out of the sky, perhaps with the resulting Kessler syndrome. No more drones for you. [1] http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-492804/The-uninvited-guest-Chinese-sub-pops-middle-U-S-Navy-exercise-leaving-military-chiefs-red-faced.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-492804/The-uninvited...
- stcredzero 11y agoThen came the converted battlecruisers - the capital ships of the day Only sorta. Battlecruisers had compromised armor in exchange for greater speed. Battleships were the capital ships prior to WWII. Battlecruiser's large size combined with greater speed made them a great platform for conversion into carriers, though. I predict that in the next major conflict, aircraft carriers will be utterly useless, most of our big flat-tops will be sunk in the first couple months, and the bulk of combat will fall to a large fleet of inexpensive drones. Really, this depends on how the next "major conflict" is defined and who it is against. A "mobile base for bomb trucks" is what they are now, and that's not technically useless. If the biggest powers are smart, then the rest of the conflicts on this planet will be economic or through proxies or take the form of a "cold war." The strategic win will be to enlarge the context of human activity while claiming as much of that as possible. (Failing to of course, but perhaps one's cultural descendants will look kindly on the "old country.")
- jbattle 11y agoAlso - wasn't the battlecruiser concept largely discredited after WW1? I wouldn't be surprised if they were seen as more obsolete/expendable than battleships. Better to convert them to an aircraft carrier than have those expensive ships going to waste.
- stcredzero 11y agoThe battlecruiser HMS Hood was the pride and joy of the British Navy, until it was exploded by a lucky shell from the Bismark in WWII.
- gozur88 11y agoOn the other hand, German battlecruisers were the focus of British fire in the Battle of Jutland and only one was sunk. HMS Hood may have simply been a flawed design.
- vlehto 11y agoIowa can be classified as very fast battleship or very large battle-cruiser. So in a way the concept was not discredited, but expanded. The battleships really didn't need more speed for line of battle. But Iowas needed speed to keep up with the carriers.
- sickbeard 11y agoCarriers typically don't engage directly in battle, they are not entirely useless, infact they are very useful for projecting your force across a large range. This will needed until war machines move so fast force projection is no longer needed.
- CapitalistCartr 11y agoA big part of the USA's fondness for carriers is the ability to project political strength around the World. Its often described as four and a half acres of US sovereignty, ninety thousand tons of diplomacy. In other words, to project intent and avoid conflict. They also make fantastic (if expensive) disaster relief platforms.
- make3 11y agoWho can sink all the flat tops without launching a nuclear war? That seems pretty unlikely. More likely, at most one or two will be sunk by suicide/guerilla attacks by small states, and super power conflicts will be constrained to cold & economical wars
- gozur88 11y ago>I predict that in the next major conflict, aircraft carriers will be utterly useless, most of our big flat-tops will be sunk in the first couple months, and the bulk of combat will fall to a large fleet of inexpensive drones. Having worked on naval air defense, I can tell you carrier battle groups in open water are a lot tougher than people think. If a major conflict started today, unless it went nuclear the carriers would probably survive. Of course the scenario matters a lot. A carrier group in the Med is a lot more vulnerable than a carrier group near Hawaii. A carrier group during peacetime is a lot more vulnerable than a carrier group during a war. Etc. That's today. It's hard to say how things will develop - I think we'll see a lot more DF-21D style anti-ship ballistic missiles, but we're getting better and better at knocking those things down, too. The difference between the interwar period and now is there isn't a clear successor technology. If you want to project force, the carrier is still the best way to do it and will be for the foreseeable future.