3 ms·
Unruh radiation itself is well established theoretically, though it has not been observed experimentally. However, the theory behind Unruh radiation says one t
by pdonis 11y ago
Unruh radiation itself is well established theoretically, though it has not been observed experimentally.
However, the theory behind Unruh radiation says one thing that creates an obvious problem for anyone trying to use it to explain something like the EmDrive or the flyby anomaly: Unruh radiation is felt by objects that are undergoing proper acceleration. That is, they have to already be experiencing thrust. And according to the theory, the thrust they are experiencing has to be very, very small, so that the wavelength of the Unruh radiation is of the same order as the size of the observable universe.
In the case of the flyby anomaly, the spacecraft passing by the Earth were in free-fall orbits--i.e., zero thrust. That means zero Unruh radiation.
In the case of the EmDrive, technically the apparatus was feeling "thrust", in the sense that it was sitting on the surface of the Earth and therefore feeling weight. (Weight counts as "thrust" in this connection.) But the weight of the EmDrive apparatus is many orders of magnitude larger than the small accelerations that would be required for the Unruh radiation explanation to work--the wavelength of Unruh radiation associated with a 1 g acceleration is about one light-year, much, much smaller than the radius of the observable universe.
So, bottom line, whether or not the EmDrive results themselves are valid (I am skeptical, but the whole thing is still being hashed out so it's too early to know for sure), it doesn't look to me like Unruh radiation can account for results of this sort.
(Btw, as gaur pointed out, Unruh radiation actually is a result of quantum field theory in flat spacetime, i.e., not GR, as the article claimed.)