I also disagree. HN has a system in place to decide if these comments are worthy/useful/fair. If this kind of summary is getting upvotes it is both proof of co

I also disagree. HN has a system in place to decide if these comments are worthy/useful/fair. If this kind of summary is getting upvotes it is both proof of concept and promotion of the Apply HN. I see no problem with that. What is the problem in trying to influence people to upvote his application? It seems to me that this kind of influence is a feature, not a bug of this kind of application that YC chose to test.