4 ms·
As mentioned by others in the other threads, I would not recommend continuing these summaries in an attempt to promote your Apply HN. At minimum, it is an atte
by minimaxir 11y ago
As mentioned by others in the other threads, I would not recommend continuing these summaries in an attempt to promote your Apply HN.
At minimum, it is an attempt to influence votes.
- JesseAldridge 11y agoI like it. I'm busy and that summary was really nice. Let him have his one line advertisement.
- Diamons 11y agoWhy not? I like it.
- Kinnard 11y agoI disagree. More power to you. Please keep it up. Best of luck.
- soneca 11y agoI also disagree. HN has a system in place to decide if these comments are worthy/useful/fair. If this kind of summary is getting upvotes it is both proof of concept and promotion of the Apply HN. I see no problem with that. What is the problem in trying to influence people to upvote his application? It seems to me that this kind of influence is a feature, not a bug of this kind of application that YC chose to test.
- educar 11y agoI have nothing against the summaries but HN puts new comments on top for short duration and it's really annoying to sift through the summary because I have already read the article. Because of that, these summaries are just comment spam.
- 0xEFF 11y agoI upvoted because I found the comment useful. I honestly didn't even see the one line at the end until you called it out. No problem here, please keep the summaries coming. I find them valuable.
- rm999 11y ago>I would not recommend ... it is an attempt to influence votes. Are you accusing him of breaking a rule or a spirit of a rule? Because your comment reads like that. To me, this is an unequivocally useful service, and those imaginary internet points are well-earned. Very often a quick summary in the user's own words bubbles up to the top because people find it genuinely useful.
- minimaxir 11y agoPer the FAQ: > Can I ask people to upvote my submission? > No. Users should vote for a story because it's intellectually interesting, not because someone is promoting it. I added the "at minimum" since it is a bad tactical decision for the OP anyways as it would potentially trigger the voting ring detector. And no, "genuinely useful" does not morally counteract the impact of the promotion.