8 ms·
This is one of those ideas that sounds genius on its face, until it's actually implemented. Kudzu? Grows fast, prevents erosion, let's pay farmers to till it in
by mikestew 11y ago
This is one of those ideas that sounds genius on its face, until it's actually implemented. Kudzu? Grows fast, prevents erosion, let's pay farmers to till it into the top soil. MTBE? Prevents engine knock, makes for cleaner air, let's mandate its use at the federal level. Whoopsie, once it's in the water we can't get it out, and its a carcinogen.
Let's kill all of the mosquitos because we find their presence unpleasant. Well, that's done and...oh, shit. Turns out there was a value to mosquitos after all. Anyone think to save some of that DNA?
- pkaye 11y agoPerhaps do a pilot test in a limited area and see the impact?
- DougWebb 11y agoIf I recall correctly, that was done in Panama by the canal builders; one of the reasons they were successful was because they wiped out mosquitoes in the region, and protected the workers from malaria. Their method was to put a bit of gasoline in all of the swamps. The thin layer of gas on the water surface killed the larvae. It probably caused lots of other environmental damage too though, so a different approach would be needed today.
- maxerickson 11y agoMalaria used to be endemic in much of the US. http://www.cdc.gov/malaria/about/history/elimination_us.html http://www.cdc.gov/malaria/about/history/elimination_us.html I guess they were pretty close to eradicating mosquitoes in transmission areas once they started the control effort.
- bradstewart 11y agoA similar tactic was used in Cuba and New Orleans to combat yellow fever. [1] They used a layer of oil rather than gasoline though. [1] http://exhibits.hsl.virginia.edu/yellowfever/new_strategies/ http://exhibits.hsl.virginia.edu/yellowfever/new_strategies/
- cdubzzz 11y agoPeople living in malaria zones find mosquitos a little more than "unpleasant".
- reustle 11y agoSame with Dengue Fever. I spent a month in Bali last summer with a group of 40 people, 4 of which got Dengue. 10%.
- waffle_ss 11y agoChairman Mao thought killing all the sparrows in China (part of his Four Pests Campaign[1]) would be a great idea because they ate laborers' grain seed. But then the population of crop-eating insects ballooned, causing the Great Chinese Famine to get a lot worse. Tens of millions starved to death. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Pests_Campaign https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Pests_Campaign
- hibikir 11y agoMosquitos aren't about unpleasantness though: It is a vector for deadly disease in the tropics. We are talking hundreds of thousands of deaths a year. Now, getting rid of all of them might not be the smartest idea: it carries plenty of risk, but to say that they are just unpleasant is a major understatement.
- astazangasta 11y agoWe should just cure these diseases. Vector control is fucking hard, we've been trying it for a century without really fixing the problem. That isn't likely to change; therapeutic interventions, however, can keep getting better and cheaper.
- ethanbond 11y agoWith the risk being that we breed immunity into the population, seeing as it's still being carried and evolving in its carriers (the mosquitos). FWIW, we could "cure" a lot of these diseases. We have, in rich parts of the world. If the option was between "we distribute cures to forgotten diseases to everyone who needs them" versus "we take a gamble and murder all the mosquitos," I might agree the former would be the better bet. That's not the choice we're given because not enough people in the first world want to step up in a serious enough way.
- astazangasta 11y agoIt doesn't really take that many people; these need not be expensive programs. It's a matter of political will, but a serious vector control program would be no different. In any event, learning how to control human diseases and prevent parasites from killing us seems like a very fundamental goal of medicine which should be accomplished in any eventuality. Eradicating mosquitoes need not be. Also, regarding resistance, it is much easier to track and defeat resistance in human patients than to track and defeat resistance in wild populations of mosquitoes, which is what we'll be doing if we try eradication campaigns.
- Turing_Machine 11y ago
- lifeformed 11y agoThere will be side effects, but could it really be worse than the alternative? That is, one million deaths per year.
- joekrill 11y agoThey very well could be. That's just it -- we don't know. And when we kill them all off, are we going to be able to reverse it when we find out that the result is causing two million deaths per year?
- bryanlarsen 11y agoWhich is why people are studying the issue, writing papers and popular articles, instead of just doing it.
- Turing_Machine 11y agoDespite the link-bait headline, no one is talking about killing off all mosquitos. And yes, gene drives can be reversed.
- cik2e 11y agoUnder what hypothetical scenario would killing off mosquitos cause two million (human?) deaths per year?
- imakesnowflakes 11y agoWhat if the diseases that depend on mosquitoes to spread mutate/evolve themselves to spread via air... You know, "life finds a way" and all that..
- ommunist 11y agoEasy. Untold side effect of MTBe caused infertility in 50% of cases in second generation of black women in treated regions. Entire country was depopulated in 25 years. Like that research article from 2056?
- 11y ago
- saulrh 11y agoMBTE is unconfirmed as a carcinogen except at very high doses and can be efficiently and economically removed from water with simple bioreactors. It is better than either lead additive or the health effects of increased pollution from inferior combustion from increased knocking. It is in fact used medically to dissolve gallstones by way of injecting it into the gallbladder. It is not required to be added to gasoline; while there are laws requiring oxygenates to be added, MTBE is not required and there are alternatives. Do your research better.
- mikestew 11y agoMTBE...can be efficiently and economically removed from water with simple bioreactors. That wasn't the case fifteen years ago. Mandating something, then hoping we come up with an inexpensive way to clean up the mess later probably isn't a good long-term plan. It is in fact used medically to dissolve gallstones by way of injecting it into the gallbladder. Arsenic has medicinal uses, too. I'll swing by the house later to drop some in the water inlet of your house. MTBE is not required and there are alternatives When the alternatives are more expensive, MTBE has been effectively "required". Perhaps it is not the current case, but it most certainly was in years past. Do your research better. You mean do my research such that my conclusions match yours? Or did you just have a nice, cold glass of Uncalled-for-Snark(tm) with your breakfast this morning?
- saulrh 11y agoI did some more looking around. Oral MTBE is a carcinogen at levels above 200mg/kg/day in rats. When inhaled it has acute toxic effects before it has carcinogenic effects. MTBE tastes bad enough to render drinking water unpalatable at levels around 10ug/l. So you basically can't drink enough to give yourself cancer. Calling it a persistent pollutant is perfectly fine. It's bad enough to make entire aquifers taste bad until you put in the hardware to clean it out. What it isn't is a problematic carcinogen. "Because of the intense odor (and taste) of MTBE, humans will not tolerate either air or water concentrations sufficient to produce the cytotoxic precursors required to promote cellular proliferation." http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1539-6924.1997.tb01274.x/full http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1539-6924.1997.... > Arsenic has medicinal uses, too. Not for its macroscopic physical properties it doesn't. > I'll swing by the house later to drop some in the water inlet of your house. Just be sure to stick to things like the EPA exposure limits and so on. > That wasn't the case fifteen years ago. Mandating something, then hoping we come up with an inexpensive way to clean up the mess later probably isn't a good long-term plan. That's fair. > You mean do my research such that my conclusions match yours? Or did you just have a nice, cold glass of Uncalled-for-Snark(tm) with your breakfast this morning? I'll admit that a little bit of it is snark. I find that the kind of person that's most vulnerable to misleading science is also pretty vulnerable to snark. But, no, I really did mean that you needed to do more research.
- nnain 11y agoI am all for environment and sustainability, but in case of mosquitoes, even I would draw an exception! You have to be in a tropical country to know how many nights they spoil and how much effort it is, everyday, to keep yourself insulated -- all those Aerosols, sprays, nets... So much effort and resources. They are under the desks, in corners, in gardens, everywhere.. they seriously affect the lifestyle in a bad way.
- vermontdevil 11y agoI used to think Kudzu was really bad until I read this: http://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/true-story-kudzu-vine-ate-south-180956325/?no-ist http://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/true-story-kudz... Not saying it was a good idea to plant Kudzu but there are far worse invasive plants to deal with.
- ch4s3 11y agoYeah I'm surprised that most sources still cite those junk stats from the 1970's and 90's.
- rdtsc 11y ago> we find their presence unpleasant It's a bit more then "unpleasant" I would say
- ch4s3 11y agoKudzu is great for erosion and its invasiveness in the Southeastern US is GREATLY exaggerated. Apparently the 1996 survey that is most cited greatly overestimated the number of hectares covered.
- JBReefer 11y agoStuff in the south in general grows really, really fast.
- oaktowner 11y agoI'm not a scientist, but I know from movies that the amber is filled with mosquitos. Now: to ensure we're only extracting the mosquito DNA and not the dino DNA...
- technofiend 11y agoOr it could be like air bags and seat belts: certainly responsible for its share of issues, but far fewer than what it prevents.
- tempestn 11y agoWhat if they keep a bunch of unaltered mosquitoes in captivity while eradicating them in the wild? Then if it does have some unanticipated effect the change may be reversible. (Of course it's possible the re-released mosquitoes will be out-competed by whatever's moved in in their absence, but you've got a better chance than if you didn't keep a backup.)