6 ms·
If global warming is a danger Mr. Jones has made it a little more dangerous with his illegal actions that have discredited climate research. But anyway, I get
by fauigerzigerk 17y ago
If global warming is a danger Mr. Jones has made it a little more dangerous with his illegal actions that have discredited climate research.
But anyway, I get the feeling that we're suffering a collective bout of climate hypochondria this century. Haven't icebergs been colliding and breaking apart forever?
- icey 17y agoI don't really know if we're reacting appropriately, overreacting, or underreacting to climate change; but I think your last sentence is kind of like saying "Volcanoes have been erupting since Earth began, who cares if a supervolcano is about to erupt?".
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoIs it a supervolcano or is it just supercharged perception of everything that might or might not have to do with climate change? I can't bring myself to react to very long term potential dangers in the same way I would react to clear and immediate dangers like a volcano that's going to blow up in my face. That's why your analogy doesn't work for me.
- jbooth 17y agoSummer ice melts have generally been setting records year after year, both in the northern and southern hemisphere. So, uncertain, but probably more on the "supervolcano" end of your spectrum there. Experiment: Fill a glass with ice water. Take the temp. 32 degrees or so. Drop a thimble full of boiling water in, some of the ice will melt. Take the temp. Still 32 degrees. Repeat. What happens when we're out of ice? (Situation is slightly different for a planet as opposed to a glass but the fundamentals still apply)
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoSo are you saying that the temperature up until now should not have been going up since we're not out of ice? [edit] And my second question would be this. If all of this is so simple that it can be demonstrated with a glass of water and a few ice cubes, why is it that a minority of serious scientists has doubts? The same scientists would probably confirm that your experiment is correct.
- jbooth 17y agoOf course I'm not saying that, I even included a parenthetical to make it explicit -- you have higher temperature gradations on a planet than in a glass of water -- it's always hot in the tropics, always cold at the poles. But you still have an average. The answer to your second question is that no legitimate scientists have doubts about whether the temperature's rising. It's an established fact. What's uncertain is how much CO2 is related to the rising temperature. They correlate, CO2 is a greenhouse gas and it makes intuitive sense, but it's not "proven" and to certain levels of "proof", is impossible to prove because there's billions of confounding factors like sunspots, water vapor etc. You're probably confusing this with uncertainty over whether the temperature is rising (which is proven), because paid shills and ideologues (who get paid in emotional satisfaction) deliberately conflate the issue. Confusion is on their side -- educating people will probably hurt their argument, even if they're right.
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoYou're trying to refute an argument that I haven't made. The debate about the supervolcano was about our collective perception of the potential consequences of global warming, not whether or not warming takes place. I don't know nearly enough about climate science to make any claims about it. What I do know about is scientific methods and I do know that there is no scientific method that can credibly make long term predictions about complex systems. We had the Stern review tell us what the costs of climate change are going to be many decades down the road. It's not possible to make such predictions because it's not possible to know the social and scientific reaction to any change. It's that kind of government sponsored charlatanery that I don't like about this debate. I am still in favor of reducing CO2 and changing our energy infrastructure in a moderate fashion, because by and large I do believe that we are causing changes in the athmosphere that we should try to minimise (There are other good reasons for doing this as well). I just think we need not have a collective bout of panic and I don't need politicised scientists present things in a way that suggests way more certainty than we could ever possibly have about goings on in complex systems.
- protomyth 17y agoWell, if a super volcano erupted, then we wouldn't really need to worry about global warming.
- troystribling 17y agoThere could be some truth in your hypochondria comparison. Climate concerns developed as good global climate data became available in the 70's and 80's and the range of the data variability became known. It is possible that the fear around observed climate variability comes from the the unclear picture of what is a 'habitable' range of variability. Exactly what the 'habitable' range is seems to be determined mostly be political associations not data. Also, the article mentions that not all "experts" are concerned, "Some experts are concerned about the effect of the massive displacement of ice on the ice-free water next to the glacier, which is important for ocean currents, while others are less concerned. Experts say this type of iceberg calving happens from time to time and these are not record large icebergs." Finally, the atmosphere-ocean-biosphere system has never been in 'equilibria'. It is a highly nonlinear, nonstationary system whose dynamic are just beginning to be understood.
- jsz0 17y agoAs we learn more about the ramifications of climate change I think it would be irrational not to worry. I live in a civilized country with modern building standards and easy access to food and clean water so I'm not too concerned about myself. I'm very concerned about the many millions of people who don't have that luxury. If you're already on the razor's edge increased flooding or increased drought could be the difference between life and death. We also have to consider the political ramifications of mass migrations due to people fleeing floods, mudslides, drought, changing animal/insect populations and their impact on agriculture, etc. I think you're right that it's not really anything new, weather patterns have always been subject to change, but we have more humans on the planet contending for ever more scarce resources today.