9 ms·
Possibly by doing representative sampling of the user population and finding what works for them. Architects are encouraged to be outrageous, individualistic,
by TheOtherHobbes 11y ago
Possibly by doing representative sampling of the user population and finding what works for them.
Architects are encouraged to be outrageous, individualistic, capricious, even dictatorial. A generic Edwardian terrace is the opposite of everything creative architecture is supposed to stand for. So a divergence of opinion is not a surprise.
But I think it's interesting that you can estimate the health of an environment by measuring the effects it has on people. That's not quite a new idea in architecture, but it's certainly not central to architectural teaching.
"Objective architecture", assessed by measurable effects instead of subjective whimsy, would revolutionise the profession.
- cm2187 11y agoI think it is rather that since the early XX, architects, like painters, stopped caring about doing "beautiful" and only cared about doing "original". But the difference between painters and architects is that painters can only offend the visitors of the Tate Modern, who are presumably consenting. Architects will offend anyone who happen to live in a city where they exercise their creativity.
- true_religion 11y agoIt's actually a reversal of previous eras where people didn't want "beautiful" but wanted to ape the classics. Today originality is seen as a boon, but for a long time you were only seen as a true master if first you could replicate old works.
- vlehto 11y ago""Objective architecture", assessed by measurable effects instead of subjective whimsy, would revolutionise the profession." Agreed. It could also put money back to architecture. Let's say your company revenue of 70k$ per year per employee, there is 300 of them in a factory. You move your company to new factory, but you meet architect who can promise you 5% increase in employee productivity. That's 70X300X0,05= 1050k$/year more in revenue. You can probably spend some money to hire that archi-rainmaker.