2 ms·
Lots of folks disagree with you. How can the absence of anything in this case be at all useful? Not obvious to me I'm afraid. I don't feel I was out of line at
by chris_wot 11y ago
Lots of folks disagree with you. How can the absence of anything in this case be at all useful? Not obvious to me I'm afraid.
I don't feel I was out of line at all.
- dang 11y agoViolations of HN's rules aren't affected by what "lots of people" agree with (lots of people agree with every such violation) nor by how you feel. You broke the rules by replacing what you saw as political spin in the original headline with an opposing political spin that you happened to prefer. That's so obviously against the rules that if you do it again, we'll take away your right to submit stories here. Instead, either use the original title or (if it is misleading or linkbait) replace it with one that is accurate and neutral. That means as spin-free as you can make it, preferably using representative language from the article itself. It's pretty easy in most cases if you try. Doing this is a valuable service to the community: it presents the story in a way that allows people to receive it as information, not agitation.
- chris_wot 11y agoNo need to threaten me. Fair comment on neutrality, but your comments on accuracy is what lots of people disagree with. No less than Mike Godwin has commented on that anomaly, off HN. I'll be more careful on neutrality in future. What would you have used as the title? Edit: love to know the reasoning of the person following this thread. If you could step out of the shadows and comment, I'd appreciate it.
- chris_wot 11y agoHmmm... I've reflected on my reaction as I was clearly feeling upset about dang's comment. I have to come to the awkward conclusion that I reacted badly here because I was fairly called on something that broke the rules. I reasoned my way out of my responsibility to be more neutral and in the back of my mind I must have realised what I was doing wasn't the right thing to do. The fact that I felt the need to justify the title choice tends to confirm this :-( Therefore, I owe dang and I guess ycombinator an apology: first for that last comment where I mischaracterised dang as being threatening, and secondly for the title of this post which was needlessly partisan. I guess I react badly sometimes to being rebuked. However, that's my issue as in this case the rebuke was fair. I think in this matter my emotions got the better of me and I was in denial - I guess the only good thing about it is that I can recognise the emotion, try to take a step back from myself and then after I realise it's caused by my own behaviour I need to make amends (i.e. I feel sheepish). So once again, apologies to dang and the wider HN community. I'll try much harder to listen to criticism and I'll ensure this sort of submission doesn't happen again.
- dang 11y agoBeing rebuked is never fun, and the correction is all we care about, so thanks.