4 ms·
"That's too long for young people who want to change the world,” a person close to the company said" Then I guess they're new to the auto industry. Even Tesla
by mc32 11y ago
"That's too long for young people who want to change the world,” a person close to the company said"
Then I guess they're new to the auto industry. Even Tesla moves slow. With things like cars and power plant you can't just move fast and break things.
Still a hit for BMW and a coup for Tencent.
- Gustomaximus 11y agoTo claify the line before that quote says: "But a long-awaited third model in the i-series won’t be launched before 2020" That's 5+ years for a new model. It's say that is pretty damn slow for car manufacturers that tend to release a model upgrade per year. Especially given ever developing tech position of electric. Maybe they are expecting the development to be done in Audi/Porshe companies and BMW will tag along. I find it hard to believe BMW management dont see (and plan for) where the market is clearly going.
- rhizome 11y agoIsn't it <4 years?
- espadrine 11y agoRetail deliveries for the i8 started in June 2014, so presumably they had been working on a new version for two years already; unless the team was diluted to provide insight to their other teams for BMW's iPerformance effort to include technology from their i vehicles to hybrid variants of older series.
- rhizome 11y agoDoes "launch" have a specific meaning in this context, that it's always the announcement of the final design, or the first showing at Frankfurt, or when it hits dealers?
- steffan 11y agoWhile a long time, five years doesn't sound excessively long to develop an entire new model, distinct from an upgrade to one of the existing lineups. As an example, look at the amount of time the Tesla Model 3 was in development and still remaining until the first deliveries. Not defending BMW; they seem to have missed the boat in this iteration. Perhaps they'll be able to find their way, but they'll have to play catch-up for a while.
- sirkneeland 11y agohey, playing catch-up worked for Nokia, right?
- donkeyd 11y agoThe i8 (the second i-line car) was released in june 2014, which means that it'd be 6 years between the i8 and a third car. There were 4 years between the Tesla Roadster and Model S, 3 between Model S and Model X and probably 2-3 between Model X and Model 3. If the next car in the i-line is planned for 2020, I understand that these 'young people' think it's slow. And it's obvious that it isn't a priority for BMW.
- mc32 11y agoSo I'm not clear if their complaint was slow model development cycles or new models coming to market. One is, it takes us too long to go from idea to off the line, the other is we don't have enough new car ideas.
- hackuser 11y agoThe iPhone took 3 years to develop, if Wikipedia is to be believed.
- emn13 11y agoEngineering the first iPhone is a completely different kind of challenge to engineering an EV - probably a lot easier in most ways that matter. For the iPhone, it was a relatively fresh niche, so the minimum quality bar was very low (and considering how much better smartphones have gotten, you could argue that early models intentionally left a lot of room to improve). EV cars need to compete not only with "normal" cars, but also with generations of tesla's, and a wide variety of hybrids, including plug-ins that can to some extent provide the same benefits. A new entry needs to be much more competitive. Then, the ingredients to a smartphone are fairly simple, and it doesn't actually matter that much exactly what you do with them. Anything vaguely affordable with a touchscreen and internet essentially works - and without much competition that means there would have been many paths to success. By contrast, there are quite a few physical limits cars run up against that make the details a lot more relevant (perhaps not if you'd have been developing the first car, but well...) Cars have lots of regulatory issues and there is extensive safety testing. Even if this were trivial, it's likely still time consuming and may involve many iterations. Totally different beasts.
- sangnoir 11y agoThere is very little value in comparing the iPhone to an electric vehicle. Cars have more regulations (safety, emissions), more moving parts, larger teams working on them and cost 2 orders of magnitude more. A poorly designed phone is less likely to kill people.
- sangnoir 11y ago> That's 5+ years for a new model. It's say that is pretty damn slow for car manufacturers that tend to release a model upgrade per year. The automotive industry has notoriously long lead times. The second sentence does not contradict the first: they release yearly model upgrades, but each upgrade takes 5 years (more or less) to develop. In other words, 2018 models are pretty much finalized today
- sangnoir 11y ago> That's 5+ years for a new model. It's say that is pretty damn slow for car manufacturers that tend to release a model upgrade per year. The automotive industry has notoriously long lead times. The second sentence does not contradict the first: they release yearly model upgrades, but each upgrade takes 5 years to develop. In other words, 2018 models are pretty much finalized today
- frik 11y ago> damn slow for car manufacturers that tend to release a model upgrade per year That's not true. There are facelifts every few years and new models take a few more years. And even new models are often based on the older model in many ways.
- kleiba 11y agoAt the same time, some argue that not just BMW but pretty much all of the German car manufacturers sort of missed the train on electric and are now still playing catch-up.
- mc32 11y agoIIRC they bet more heavily on Hydrogen and electrics' success is taking them a bit by surprise? Only an outsider's take.
- zo1 11y agoWhich is kind of odd as I recall the predominant opinion being that electric is more viable than hydrogen. Even with the advances and improvements in hydrogen-based vehicles, electric vehicles still took-ahead.
- sveme 11y agoThere's a lot of hype and currently little real success for electric cars. But with this hype, I guess real success is just a matter of time. The problem with probably all traditional carmakers is that pivoting to electric simply does not work well at that scale and you need to simultaneously develop experience with electric cars while maintaining your gasoline cash cow. Toyota used hybrid for this, BMW tried niche cars. None went all in.
- fpoling 11y agoToyota also missed electrical cars. I guess they bet too heavy on their hybrid engines. It will be interesting how their Mirai model will sell, a fuel cell hydrogen-powered car that continue to use the hybrid technology.
- usrusr 11y agoIt's the autobahn. EV are great at acceleration, but abysmal at sustaining high speed. In Germany, a luxury sedan that has to "crawl" sub 100mph to make it to the next charger completely fails the accustomed status calculus that drives luxury sales. Price-sensitive "reason over status" EVs that don't suffer that status hit from lacking high speed endurance are a much tougher nut to crack than status vehicles like the existing Tesla models. In this market segment, german carmakers are not failing significantly harder than everybody else.