3 ms·
Maybe you make UBI an income guarantee rather than a right to live in a given place guarantee. In such a structure the state could incentivize moving to areas
by mc32 11y ago
Maybe you make UBI an income guarantee rather than a right to live in a given place guarantee. In such a structure the state could incentivize moving to areas which are losing population, such as Midwestern rustbelt cities and towns in the US, or any place not the MDF in MX or the Ruhr valley in DE, etc.
- ghaff 11y agoAny remotely rational policy would not try to adjust subsidies to enable living in luxury locations. No, you're not going to be able to live in San Francisco. You'll be able to (barely) afford a crappy apartment in Detroit.
- kylebgorman 11y agoI don't think we should incentivize moving to such places unless we plan to also (somehow) massively increase the opportunities available in such places.
- mc32 11y agoIsn't the whole idea of UBI that it's subsidizing the lack of good jobs for people who for one reason or another can't land decent jobs? I don't see why someone who isn't being overly productive also needs to live in a location where one could use more productive people. In other words if a mill worker's site shutdown and this person now depends solely on UBI I don't see why they should feel like they should afford some place in the closest big city if they don't get a job since their active addition to productivity is nil. If they get a job then they may or may not afford a place in that city. Still, it's not "owed" anyone.
- dllthomas 11y ago> plan to also (somehow) massively increase the opportunities available in such places. The incentive itself does this. First, there's the "opportunity" of living on the UBI - not a great option but more than there was before. Second, there's the opportunity of meeting the needs of the other people moving to such places, as well as those who lived there before (with their increased ability to pay). And this leaves aside the fact that an increasing number of opportunities are not inherently tied to location.
- dragonwriter 11y agoUBI, by definition, is an fixed, unconditional, income. If it's need-tested (such as scaling by a formula taking into account local cost of living) it's not a UBI, it's a conditional, needs-treated welfare program. UBI is specifically intended to dodge bureaucratic overhead by avoiding means-, needs-, and behavior-testing common in existing welfare programs. So the "alternative" you propose is actually what a UBI is by definition.
- mc32 11y agoStart its implementation in economically depressed regions first.
- dragonwriter 11y agoUnnecessary complication. If you do it generally, it'll matter more and go further in depressed regions on it's own. Line drawing exercises are unnecessary and counterproductive.