8 ms·
BMW Loses Core Development Team of Its I3 and I8 Electric Vehicle Line
- niels_olson 11y agoLoosing a few executives is expected for a product that's mature enough to be on the market. These guys no doubtedly got a ton of cash for defecting, but they may also learn if they try to come back that they will be considered tainted goods.
- PeterStuer 11y agoBeen driving BMW's for the past 10 years. I'm not big into cars and try to avoid driving when I can, but as far as rides go those are nice vehicles. To get me to stay with the brand, BMW needs to bring to market a 5 series plug-in hybrid with more than a token green-wash electric motor within the next 18 months, and it doesn't look like they will be able to deliver.
- angerman 11y agoSame here. Even though my current location frees me of the need of a car (public transport is ubiquitous in this city state) BMW has been the make that provided the cars I liked driving short and long distances most. While I'd certainly look at BMWs offering of cars if I ever need one again, right now I'm quite sure I'd opt for a Tesla, as I don't see BMW having a proper contender.
- sirkneeland 11y agoSingapore?
- stillworks 11y agoIsn't it difficult to even buy/keep a car in Singapore ? Or maybe I missed /s
- sirkneeland 11y agoLudicrously so. I was talking to an Uber driver there who said the high cost of car ownership (namely the COE - Certificate of Entitlement) makes owning a car simply for the sake of Uber driving to be generally uneconomical. Especially as the COE cost is due to rise substantially.
- spiderfarmer 11y agoI can wait a bit longer, but I really hope my next car will be a fully electric BMW with real knobs and not just a flashy touchscreen.
- TwoBit 11y agoimo the i3 is too feeble, and the i8 is too weird or exotic. Tesla S is good, though expensive. Tesla 3 looks like a world beater. Why can't the Germans match that?
- f_allwein 11y agoBecause they ignored electric cars for decades, or just did half-hearted trials. BMW is actually way ahead of the other German manufacturers, but I doubt they will be able to compete with Tesla. Also, I think the i3 is crazy ugly.
- mc32 11y ago"That's too long for young people who want to change the world,” a person close to the company said" Then I guess they're new to the auto industry. Even Tesla moves slow. With things like cars and power plant you can't just move fast and break things. Still a hit for BMW and a coup for Tencent.
- Gustomaximus 11y agoTo claify the line before that quote says: "But a long-awaited third model in the i-series won’t be launched before 2020" That's 5+ years for a new model. It's say that is pretty damn slow for car manufacturers that tend to release a model upgrade per year. Especially given ever developing tech position of electric. Maybe they are expecting the development to be done in Audi/Porshe companies and BMW will tag along. I find it hard to believe BMW management dont see (and plan for) where the market is clearly going.
- rhizome 11y agoIsn't it <4 years?
- espadrine 11y agoRetail deliveries for the i8 started in June 2014, so presumably they had been working on a new version for two years already; unless the team was diluted to provide insight to their other teams for BMW's iPerformance effort to include technology from their i vehicles to hybrid variants of older series.
- rhizome 11y agoDoes "launch" have a specific meaning in this context, that it's always the announcement of the final design, or the first showing at Frankfurt, or when it hits dealers?
- steffan 11y agoWhile a long time, five years doesn't sound excessively long to develop an entire new model, distinct from an upgrade to one of the existing lineups. As an example, look at the amount of time the Tesla Model 3 was in development and still remaining until the first deliveries. Not defending BMW; they seem to have missed the boat in this iteration. Perhaps they'll be able to find their way, but they'll have to play catch-up for a while.
- mdorazio 11y agoExecutives are not the development team, and there's no word on whether actual EV engineers have defected as well. This really isn't surprising given the amount of poaching going on in the market these days between Tesla, Faraday, various VC-backed startups, and the upcoming China/emerging market players. Given the choice to get a better salary and actually work on a product millions of people might want instead of slogging away on a product line that BMW clearly doesn't care much about, these moves really aren't unexpected.
- openplatypus 11y ago"struggling with weak sales" Translation: "our executive bonuses were in danger so we jumped the ship before anyone noticed" No word on actual engineers (you know, the thing that makes R&D) moving as well.
- dagw 11y agoAt most (real, not software) engineering companies I've been involved with most of the executives where "actual engineers".
- tankenmate 11y agoEspecially in Europe, where companies are more likely to promote and train management from within rather than import freshly minted MBAs, compare to the US.
- imeron 11y agoBMW i models Q1 sales lower than last year by 23%. Maybe bonuses were really the cause for all this --- http://insideevs.com/bmw-sold-5128-bmw-i3i8-in-the-first-quarter-of-2016/ http://insideevs.com/bmw-sold-5128-bmw-i3i8-in-the-first-qua...
- dagw 11y agoExecutives are not the development team However in many cases they are the senior engineers of the development team. In this case the defection included executives who developed the i8 plug-in hybrid sports car and the electric powertrains for the i-series.
- Hermel 11y agoBMW sells more electric cars than Tesla in some markets and about half as many globally. Unlike the WSJ, I would say these are respectable figures.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- codeulike 11y agoI'm finding it hard to find any i series sales figures for anywhere but the US. But in the US last year they sold 11,000 - less than half of what Tesla sold. For pure EVs they took 3rd place behind Tesla and Nissan Leaf. Rumoured about 25,000 worldwide sales which is about half of Tesla's (rapidly growing) worldwide. The Leaf consistently takes second place after Tesla.
- varjag 11y agoHere in Norway, world's 3rd largest EV market, they are behind Nissan, Tesla, VW and KIA.
- mootothemax 11y agoI'd love to know whether car-fanatic kids today have posters of the BMW i8 up on their walls. (well, or as their desktop wallpapers, for that matter) Ever since I saw one in Real Life - but how I covet my neighbour's i8!
- greglindahl 11y agoI suspect that EV-fanatic kids don't think much of the i8 -- it's a plug-in hybrid with weak all-electric performance. It would have made a great all-electric car.
- TwoBit 11y ago"core development team." lol
- justsaysmthng 11y agoSensationalist clickbait title. There's mention of 4 i-series executives leaving (BMW has over 100,000 employees), which is somewhat expected, given that the article mentions that i sales haven't been stellar. True, I haven't seen too many i models on the streets, but I haven't seen too many of competitor's electric models either. So the market is still not quite ready for them and the manufacturers, I guess, are wary of betting it all on the electric card. Of course there'll be people moving from company to company, just like people from Apple move to Google and vice-versa and it's normal, but the tone of this article is like "BMW is collapsing and everyone is running for their lives... to China". Why is this even in the news ? Press is so unreliable and sensationalist these days .. Or has it always been like this ? Edit: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pa5_tudyAF8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pa5_tudyAF8
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- smt88 11y ago> True, I haven't seen too many i models on the streets, but I haven't seen too many of competitor's electric models either. Anecdotes. I see Teslas all the time. Neither of us is seeing a representative sample. > So the market is still not quite ready for them Tesla has 325,000 preorders. > wary of betting it all on the electric card They don't have much choice about how much to bet. The US government has mandated a certain percentage of their sales be low-emission vehicles by 2017. > Why is this even in the news It tells us that the I Series is a failed/failing product line and that Future is giving better incentives to electric-vehicle executives. > Or has it always been like this It has always been like this. In fact, it used to be much worse (see: yellow journalism and William Randolph Hearst).
- jonah 11y agoMore anecdotes. I saw one of the full-electric i3s today. (Though, I probably also saw three Model Ss.)
- 11y ago
- mosselman 11y agoCould someone explain to me how this works legally? Don't contracts have clauses in them to prevent people moving to a new job in the same industry or clauses that prevent people from taking old employees with them when they move to another company?
- ddorian43 11y agoIsn't that fucked up ? Doesn't mean it has to be fucked up everywhere.
- SmellyGeekBoy 11y agoApparently such clauses aren't legally enforceable in Europe, I'm not sure about the situation in the US.
- kidmenot 11y agoIANAL but, as far as I know, e.g. here in Italy things work like this: assuming you decide to leave your day job to found your own company meant to compete with the company you were working for, your former employer could theoretically sue you if you found your new company within 5 years of you leaving (at least this is what I remember). To work around this, you could pick a partner and make them the head of the company. This could also work in spite of non-compete clauses, which I think many companies consider as overkill anyway. As far as laws preventing your from moving from a company to a competing one go, I really don't think we have anything like that. Same goes with taking old employees with you if you move to another company. Which is a Good Thing, if you ask me, because if people decide to walk away it's probably because they are sick of it or found something better/better paying/more interesting, and law preventing you from moving someplace better would be preposterous, IMHO. Of course, this "lack of regulation" might have to do with the fact that the vast majority of contracts are of the collective type and not tailored to your particular company, meaning that you work under the same conditions as most of the other people doing your job. According to my limited experience, a company drafting up its own contracts is a rare occurrence.
- mosselman 11y agoNot only are these clauses bad for employees, but the economy suffers as well. Preventing someone from moving within the same industry (assuming it would hold up in court) just means that knowledge and experience is thrown away. I can't imagine any industry benefitting from this, let alone our economy.
- codeulike 11y agoThe way the traditional car makes are offering electric vehicles as a niche side product makes no sense. There's no conviction to it. Electric shouldn't be offered as an option, like a sunroof or convertible. Its the future. The i3 is marketed like 'here's a quirky car for weird people who dont like dinosaur juice'. No wonder staff would rather work for a startup. Go to a dealership and ask them about the electric range - the dealers dont give a shit.
- mtgx 11y agoIndeed. That's exactly why Tesla will win over any other car manufacturer. They treat it as "just another segment in the market", when they should be remaking all of their products as EVs.
- Cookingboy 11y agoAs a long time BMW fan who has a M3 on order, it really is kind of sad to see that the company is becoming less and less inspired and more and more focused on short term shareholder happiness. One one hand, the company is completely ditching its enthusiast root, at least within its main non-M lineups. The current generation 3 series is one of the worst offenders at this. In order to pursue mass market profitability, the 3 series has been watered down, its steering became heavily assisted electric systems, its suspension is tuned for comfort for a more "floaty" feel, its interior looks good in photos but are filled with cheap plastic everywhere to save cost. Its brakes no longer bite as hard because BMW doesn't want to replace too many rotors under their maintenance plane. The old king of sports sedans now drives like an overpriced and under-equipped Accord with worse reliability but faster acceleration. On the other hand their lineups are exploding like Samsung's cellphone lines 5 years ago. Just in the U.S. market there is the 2, 3, 3GT, 3 ActiveHybrid, 4, 4GC, 5, 5GT, 5 ActiveHybrid, 6, 6GC, 7 series, then there is the X1, X3, X4, X5, X6, Z4, and then there is the M2, M3, M4, M5, M6, M5 GC, and X5 M, X6 M. Then there is the i3 and i8. They are really trying to go for market share, but are losing leadership positions in many market sectors that they used to completely dominate (ATS-V now drives better than a M3, C class now is just as sporty and way more luxurious than a 3 series). And now they are barely dangling their feet in the EV front, while Tesla is charging ahead full speed (pun intended). M division is still doing good work technically, but even them are lost in the "spec game" and their new cars are all faster but less fun to drive than their predecessors. My advice to BMW: Kill the i division, don't make EV a freaking hobby, do a serious EV within your main line-up and heavily push it. Don't be afraid to give it a sports tuned suspension with heavy and precise steering, add some of that old BMW magic back. Even if it doesn't become profitable in the short term it will create a halo effect for the whole company. Otherwise it's only a matter of time that the old school enthusiasts completely abandon you and the newer generations go chase after Teslas. /rant
- dingaling 11y agoThere was an inflection point with the E46 3er when sales passed those of the Ford Mondeo. The formerly boring-brand Ford is now seen as the niche interest for the manager-with-family who likes a little driving excitement and the BMW is a standard rep mobile!
- chinathrow 11y agoI think "defection" is a strong word here. They simply left.
- edent 11y agoI've a BMW i3. I think the manufacturer said that the majority of people buying the i3 had never been BMW drivers before. Certainly true in my case. It's a perfect city car, and good for my 70 mile commute. The REx makes it practical for long distances (by EU standards). That said, I doubt I'd buy another BMW. Over-priced, poor apps, crappy in-car computer, every halfway decent option comes at a ridiculous price, maddening missing options (no heated steering wheel!), and a UI that's basically junk. I don't know if that's reflective of the general BMW "way" - reading online it seems to be - but it's like dealing with a company from the dark ages. BMW have proven that they can build and design electric vehicles. They now need to concentrate on why people don't want to buy into their brand. Maybe they can make it as an Apple - ultra-expensive luxury for people willing to turn a blind eye to imperfections - or maybe they need to concentrate on a superior user-experience from purchase to drive. The tech is there and evolving - it is just the company which is stagnating. (My review of the car, if you're interested - https://shkspr.mobi/blog/2015/09/i3-electric-car-review/ https://shkspr.mobi/blog/2015/09/i3-electric-car-review/ ) Edit: "How many i3 buyers are new to BMW? About 80 percent" Source http://europe.autonews.com/article/20140606/ANE/140609922/bmw-sales-boss-robertson-says-born-electric-range-will-help-boost http://europe.autonews.com/article/20140606/ANE/140609922/bm...
- jseliger 11y agoI've a BMW i3. I think the manufacturer said that the majority of people buying the i3 had never been BMW drivers before. . . . Over-priced It mostly seems to be overpriced, though perhaps tax incentives and gas costs make it more competitive in Europe. In the U.S., it's hard to imagine buying one over a Nissan Leaf or Chevy Volt (especially because the 2016 Volts are getting stellar reviews).
- tempestn 11y agoWhen I see an article about the i series, I can't help saying: if they had just made a line of full electrics that look like other BMWs, they would sell far more of them. I'm sure these things appeal to some, but I can't be the only person who finds them hideous. Just because it's an electric car doesn't mean it needs to look like something out of Tron.
- arethuza 11y agoI find the i3 and particularly the i8 rather nice looking - certainly better than most other current BMWs. Then again I do like Tron!
- Htsthbjig 11y agoI am owner of different electric cars. I have an IT company so for us electric cars are more than a battery on wheels. It is a car you could put sensors on and do lots of stuff easily, like automatically drive and so on. I don't consider BMW sales low. Quite the contrary. Read "The Innovation dilemma" to see what is happening here. Sales of electric are low compared to normal cars but they are extremely high for electric growing at an exponential rate. So high that right now with the Tesla batteries alone in the next two years the price of lithium alone will double or triple, because the Gigafactory alone will produce in a year more batteries that are currently manufactured in the entire world today. What is probably going to happen is that electric batteries need for cars will advance the development of new batteries that do not depend on lithium, like grapheme, because lithium availability is limited.
- _s 11y agoThere was a video (http://youtu.be/uDr4L6BzpP8 http://youtu.be/uDr4L6BzpP8) posted recently discussing the manufacturing tech within the i3; absolutely fascinating - the general gist being how this car is the Model T of our time. Perhaps it is a big loss or not that great; eitherway I believe the company will do just fine - they've set themselves up very well for the future unlike many of the other manufacturers in terms of brand, mobility, innovating / delivering on new tech / processes etc.
- justsaysmthng 11y agoHere's a video of the i3 production line: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pa5_tudyAF8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pa5_tudyAF8 As can be seen, they are not joking around. To me it looks like technology brought by aliens from the future.
- noahmbarr 11y agoHeard the entire "i" program is a huge money losing offset so BMW can make the volumes they want of their highly profitable, yet gas-guzzling "M" versions. CAFE is no joke (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_Average_Fuel_Economy https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_Average_Fuel_Econo...)
- jonah 11y agoThis is a really interesting discussion about the production tech in the i3. "Cutting Edge" and "Revolutionary" are used. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uDr4L6BzpP8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uDr4L6BzpP8 You can buy the report for $500k: http://leandesign.com/bmw/ http://leandesign.com/bmw/
- nulims 11y agoThey ain't a set of car keys, are they? It's not as if they're incon-freaking-spicuous, now is it?
- sickbeard 11y agoAfter designing a car like that, I can see how they run away. Why can't anyone design normal electric cars?
- halotrope 11y agoIt might look weird at first. But it is a very capable and fun car for city driving. Some things like the doors might not be 'normal' but you will appreciate when using. The whole thing is very compact without being cramped inside. Super tight turning circle. Nice materials. If I was responsible for this car I would be very proud.
- sickbeard 11y agoyou didn't answer the question tho. why can't they take a normal looking bmw, like an m3 and make it electric?
- andiwand 11y agoVery interesting, that German carmakers don't take e- mobility seriously. They have outdated concepts, lack of visions and deal with exhaust-emissions-tuning and irrelevant micro-improvements rather than out of the box thinking into the future. A paradigm shift is imminent. Goodbye Germaneering. Hello concepts that help making the world a better place. Thank God for guys like Elon Musk!
- andiwand 11y agoVery interesting, that German carmakers don't take e- mobility seriously. They have outdated concepts, lack of visions and deal with exhaust-emissions-tuning and irrelevant micro-improvements rather than out of the box thinking into the future. A paradigm shift is imminent. Goodbye Germaneering. Hello concepts that help making the world a better place. Thank God for guys like Elon Musk!
- kabdib 11y agoCall me jaded, but losing executives could be a good thing for BMW, and a bad thing for Future.
- jordache 11y agoI'm sure the other company provided them with significant compensation premiums over what BMW offered...