3 ms·
I think the key takeaway is this: And even if we had been successful in changing people’s behaviour, the lack of threading made it very difficult to have meani
by EGreg 11y ago
I think the key takeaway is this:
And even if we had been successful in changing people’s behaviour, the lack of threading made it very difficult to have meaningful, deep conversations about complex subjects anyway. Before you could even fully understand the problem being discussed (let alone find a solution), someone would invariably start a new conversation or reply to a previous discussion that happened earlier in the channel.
Threaded, asynchronous discussions with notifications when someone actually replied to your message are much more useful.
And they can also be freaking decentralized and end-to-end encrypted! Woot!
I am building something like this. Anything like that exist?
- greggman 11y agoWasn't that Google Wave?
- EGreg 11y agoHow so?
- mgpc 11y agoWhat you're describing is called email. Seriously - it is exactly this, right?
- dingo_bat 11y agoI've always wondered about the viability of an email client that behaves like a chat client. Instant send with the enter key, messages in bubbles, etc. You get all the fun of IM without additional infrastructure or services, and in a standard way too. No walled gardens of different apps.
- Strom 11y agoCould be a pretty cool UI solution to have a chat client that uses PGP encrypted e-mail in the background, but Gmail SMTP has a send limit of 100 e-mails per day. You would run into that rather quickly with a chat UI. I guess the chat client could do all the e-mail sending from some of their maintainer e-mail servers and not from under the chat participant e-mail. Then we would start losing comaptibility with other e-mail clients though. Although not completely, as we could set Reply-To headers and when another e-mail client replies to user1234@chat-client.com, we could just forward it to the correct e-mail. An interesting concept indeed.
- EGreg 11y agoKind of. Imagine more like Google Groups or HN but with notifications when someone replied. I guess if you use mailing lists for topics you can subscribe to, and cc'ing people for @mentions inviting them to reply, then yeah! Email can do it all. So why is email considered such a time sink? Because people don't filter conversations coming from the outside. But if they just set up a filter, then literally email is a Slack killer, no?
- chasb 11y agoSlack plans on introducing threads this year, according to their marketing folks.