5 ms·
it blows my mind that South Korea was a military dictatorship Why? China, Japan, Vietnam, and Taiwan all derive their political cultures primarily from Confuci
by contingencies 11y ago
it blows my mind that South Korea was a military dictatorship
Why? China, Japan, Vietnam, and Taiwan all derive their political cultures primarily from Confucianism, a strongly hierarchical system that modern commentators would probably, if it could be seen undoctored today, describe as a dictatorship. North Korea, a personality cult with similar structure, persists.
At the same time, in the 1980s, nearby Taiwan was also a dictatorship of the Nationalist Chinese army and was also supported if not set up by the US. They stopped off in Burma to grow heroin and prop up a military dictatorship there along the way. In the last few years, the US has basically let the dictators out of prosecution to counter growing regional Chinese influence which was formerly set to dominate the country. Singapore is widely accused of setting up its stock market explicitly to launder the drug revenues, and still has - and indeed probably only exists today - because of major US support.
Vietnam is the only really strong story of the lot, repulsing an attack from China after kicking out the French and Americans and re-asserting its independence, then removing another dictatorship (Pol Pot's Khmer Rouge) from Cambodia in 1978.
- walrus01 11y agoDon't forget US support for the Greek military junta: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greek_military_junta_of_1967%E2%80%9374 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greek_military_junta_of_1967%E... And the US military LOVED Saddam Hussein. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_support_for_Iraq_during_the_Iran%E2%80%93Iraq_war https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_support_for_Iraq...
- harperlee 11y agoUS also loved Franco in Spain, and a bunch of undemocratic latin-american governments.
- tmp23423 11y agoAnd more recently, Egypt http://www.news24.com/Africa/News/kerry-expresses-support-for-egypt-in-brief-visit-20160420-3 http://www.news24.com/Africa/News/kerry-expresses-support-fo...
- walrus01 11y agoNot even recent, the US supported Mubarak since he took power after the Sadat assassination.
- refurb 11y agoVietnam is the only really strong story of the lot You say that as if Vietnam did it on their own. They were as supported by China and Russia as Taiwan was by the US. And now that China is encroaching on Vietnam's sovereignty, who do they cozy up to? The US. It's all politics.
- contingencies 11y agoIt's all politics. Of course. Actually they have had many invasions and multiple occupations from China over the course of the last 10-20 centuries. They are, long-term historically speaking, essentially a China breakaway, but similarly southward-expansionist state.
- hackuser 11y ago> Actually they have had many invasions and multiple occupations from China over the course of the last 10-20 centuries. Right now there is conflict with China over their Vietnam's territorial waters and the South China Sea. China invaded Vietnam via land as recently as 1979. > They are, long-term historically speaking, essentially a China breakaway Hmmm ... China hasn't controlled Vietnam in a very long time, AFAIK; maybe never. Vietnam has a different culture and language. > similarly southward-expansionist state South of Vietnam is ocean; what does this comment mean?
- contingencies 11y agoHmmm ... China hasn't controlled Vietnam in a very long time, AFAIK; maybe never. China has occupied Vietnam many times. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Vietnam http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Vietnam Vietnam has a different culture and language. The language is very much a dialect of ancient southern Chinese. In fact, it is used by linguists to reconstruct (along with other languages) ancient Chinese pronunciation. Culturally, Vietnam has Chinese holidays like Chinese New Year, plus Chinese characters (though they are forgetting how to read them after the installation of Romanized script), Confucianism, Taoism, etc. South of Vietnam is ocean; what does this comment mean? Sinified Vietnam (ie. the first beginnings of modern Vietnam proper) expanded southward overrunning completely culturally distinct countries such as Champa, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Champa https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Champa
- nickpsecurity 11y agoCambodia had help from U.S. on Khmer Rouge, too. Marcinko, SEAL 6 founder, covers his time training them to fight Khmer Rouge in his book Rogue Warrior. Far as Vietnam, I agree that their resolve was impressive. I just don't recall it going the way you described with instead them splitting up with one side backing communist imperialists and the other capitalist imperialists. They fell for the games plenty enough but resisted a lot, too. The one with most potential is probably Singapore given what they've accomplished in a short time. They just need a cultural shift to get them out of this conformist, nationalist, factory-worker mentality. They could become a hub of not only trustworthy business in Asia but innovation or quality-focused business too. The reactionaries are doing everything they can to prevent that, though, as it will threaten their power.
- contingencies 11y agoCambodia had help from U.S. on Khmer Rouge, too. Never heard of this but it no doubt pales in comparison to Vietnam's "remove them with a land army" commitment. I just don't recall it going the way you described with instead them splitting up with one side backing communist imperialists and the other capitalist imperialists. They fell for the games plenty enough but resisted a lot, too. Any way you look at it Ho Chi Minh was brilliant military tactician and strategist who drew from both ancient Chinese and modern western military philosophy to lead his people to independence. I'd argue that the use of socialism was probably not as significant (versus other options of wartime economies) as commonly thought. It was useful, however, to get diplomatic support and military hardware from allies such as Russia and China. I don't think it greatly shaped Vietnam, which is now very capitalist, just like China and Singapore, two other nominally 'communist' party-led modern Asian nations.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoNot as strong on the history part to know about remove them with land army. However, I agree Ho Chi Minh was brilliant at strategy. Far as our opponents go, I particularly was impressed with whoever realized that Americans would likely pull out if they saw enough messed up stuff on TV. That's one of reasons they started doing stuff near places like churches. It was a brutal strategy but it worked quite to their advantage. They proved America didn't have the guts to keep up a war against Vietnamese. Many couldn't even watch one.
- ekianjo 11y ago> China, Japan, Vietnam, and Taiwan You forgot Thailand. With the cult of the president and full cooperation of the army, it's pretty much a dictatorship as well.
- coupdejarnac 11y ago...Cult of the King. Living in Thailand was a real eye-opener for me. Having to stand up for the King before movies, to stop in public places to honor the King when the loudspeaker played, and to watch what I said with regards to the King was a very jarring experience.
- Cyph0n 11y agoHoly damn and I thought it was bad in the Gulf!
- chengiz 11y agoOf all the countries I have visited as a tourist, I felt Thailand was the most overrated because of all this. It's surreal to see busy people in train stations at rush hour stop for the anthem, which as I saw later in the cinema is basically a dystopian hail to the king deal (I was continually reminded of Borat's anthem, especially the last line). Add to that the people prostrating themselves at monks' feet on busy streets, the schoolboys with all identical shortcropped hair, and then the old white men with young girls draped around them. Everything just had an evil vibe and I couldnt wait to leave (and they even made me pay an exit fee at the airport!).
- mc32 11y agoAhum, I think you forgot the Philippine islands... Marischal Ferdinand Marcos doesn't seem to have been the most democratic guy in the neighborhood.
- tamana 11y agoWhy is that Confucianism, and not plain old military coup like the rest of the world?