3 ms·
FBI admits that no useful information found on San Bernadino iPhone
- chris_wot 11y agoYes, I'm well aware that my post doesn't reflect the headline, because basically the FBI are spinning like crazy here! Here is their evidence: "The phone didn't contain evidence of contacts with other ISIS supporters or the use of encrypted communications during the period the FBI was concerned about."
- bigiain 11y agoThe reductio ad absurdum argument here is scary: "We need access to your safe deposit box, to confirm it doesn't contain evidence of tax evasion…"
- fabulist 11y agoCNN is a consistent mouthpiece for the United States Government. Shame on them for regurgitating such garbage.
- DiabloD3 11y agoThey aren't even that. They're a consistent mouthpiece for their own agenda, which is an imperfect copy, and sometimes conflicting, of the agenda of their majority shareholders. The government, however, has a Facebook relationship status with said majority shareholders of "it's complicated". CNN just wants eyeballs to read their headlines, they make it as clickbaity as possible. What they don't realize is they have to be on the level of Buzzfeed to make that work, and they aren't even close.
- ooooo00000 11y agoIt's also that intentionally leaked information and special access tend to be given to journalists who share the views of the organization or individual at hand, and will be more likely to put a favorable spin on the story. Of course it's natural that people gravitate toward like-minded others and mutually beneficial relationships arise, but depending on the circumstances it should be illegal. Take a look at the emails where Hillary Clinton more or less dictates to Marc Ambinder of The Atlantic (a news source that is still IMO far less seedy than the most popular media organizations).
- dang 11y ago> I'm well aware that my post doesn't reflect the headline If a headline is misleading, you're correct to change it (this is in the HN guidelines), but you need to change it to one that's accurate and neutral. Yours certainly is not neutral, and it doesn't seem to be accurate either (since the absence of something can obviously still be 'useful information'). So what you've done here is out of line. Submitting a story doesn't give you license to spin it.
- chris_wot 11y agoLots of folks disagree with you. How can the absence of anything in this case be at all useful? Not obvious to me I'm afraid. I don't feel I was out of line at all.
- dang 11y agoViolations of HN's rules aren't affected by what "lots of people" agree with (lots of people agree with every such violation) nor by how you feel. You broke the rules by replacing what you saw as political spin in the original headline with an opposing political spin that you happened to prefer. That's so obviously against the rules that if you do it again, we'll take away your right to submit stories here. Instead, either use the original title or (if it is misleading or linkbait) replace it with one that is accurate and neutral. That means as spin-free as you can make it, preferably using representative language from the article itself. It's pretty easy in most cases if you try. Doing this is a valuable service to the community: it presents the story in a way that allows people to receive it as information, not agitation.
- chris_wot 11y agoNo need to threaten me. Fair comment on neutrality, but your comments on accuracy is what lots of people disagree with. No less than Mike Godwin has commented on that anomaly, off HN. I'll be more careful on neutrality in future. What would you have used as the title? Edit: love to know the reasoning of the person following this thread. If you could step out of the shadows and comment, I'd appreciate it.
- orionblastar 11y agoIt was his work phone they found, he destroyed his personal phone. Any intel would have been on his personal phone. If he used his work phone for terrorist communication he'd destroy it as well.
- mirimir 11y agoPeople do make mistakes. But yes, this is the obvious expectation. Still, the FBI wouldn't be doing its job if it didn't review the evidence. I'm not, however, claiming that Apple should have done what the FBI wanted. I'm just saying that the FBI should have wanted it.
- orionblastar 11y agoThe FBI wants access to any smart phone. Even if Apple did what the FBI wanted they would have made a way to bypass any iPhone and it could be used without a warrant on anyone's iPhone. It is like opening Pandora's box and anyone with access to that code/iOS could access anyone's iPhone.
- mirimir 11y agoI agree with you about the risks of the FBI's request. I'm just saying that the FBI would have been remiss to ignore the phone.
- orionblastar 11y agoSure they have to check everything just in case it has any evidence on it. In this case the work phone didn't have any evidence on it, and breaking into the phone cause an ethical debate over the right to privacy and encryption. It is important to know that the FBI has tools made by hackers to break into an iPhone, and Apple stood by their corporate ethics to not create any OS or tools to break into an iPhone. I think this is because Apple cares about their customers and their right to privacy.
- 11y ago