2 ms·
The thing is, you say that "forming a union violates [people's] rights", but also that you are not opposed to unionization. I think you're perfectly illustratin
by foldr 17y ago
The thing is, you say that "forming a union violates [people's] rights", but also that you are not opposed to unionization. I think you're perfectly illustrating the semantic issue here. Being opposed to unionization can either mean that you are opposed to voluntary organization in the workplace of any sort, or that you are opposed to the formation of organizations with the legal protections that unions currently have.
If you say that unions violate rights, a sensible reader will naturally infer that you are opposed to "unionization" in some relevant sense of the word (given the reasonable assumption that you are opposed to rights violations).
I am not so easily confused by ambiguous words as you think, and I understand the libertarian position on this issue: unionization in the sense of voluntary organization is fine, unionization in the normal sense of the word is not.
As for your somewhat confused and bitter comments on my uninformedness, I think they illustrate my point. It is simply impossible to have a sensible discussion with someone who holds other people in such contempt. I think I've already explained what I was saying. Why are you trying to rake over the semantic issues yet another time?