3 ms·
This is semantics. The whole point of forming a union is that these organizations are legally protected. Libertarians are opposed to the relevant protections.
by foldr 17y ago
This is semantics. The whole point of forming a union is that these organizations are legally protected. Libertarians are opposed to the relevant protections.
The trouble with libertarian opinions is that they're always the same boilerplate whatever issue is being discussed. I've heard the views you're expressing literally hundreds of times previously on this and similar forums, and it inevitably becomes tedious and frustrating to read them over and over again. You seem to be insinuating that this is because I want to be insulated from opposing views -- but why would I be here, or be making this comment, if it were so? Surely you can understand that reading the same boilerplate hundreds of times over is potentially frustrating.
Also, Libertarians tend to address people who hold opposing views as if they were idiots. See e.g your assumption that I am completely uninformed about libertarian views on unionization, which derives from a refusal to adopt minimal standards of charity in interpretation. Do you really suppose I'm unaware that libertarians are not opposed per se to voluntary organization? This is a libtertarian talking point; I have seen the libertarian position on this issue exposited countless times. The bottom line is that you made a comment saying that public sector workers should not be allowed to unionize, but are now complaining that you are characterized as "opposed to unionization". I'm perfectly aware that those three words don't capture every nuance of your position, but I think it should be fairly clear what they mean in this context.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoThis is semantics. The whole point of forming a union is that these organizations are legally protected. Libertarians are opposed to the relevant protections. No, it isn't semantics. Libertarians believe in the right to free association, but they don't believe that free associations get to use the threat of violence to prevent competition. It's also an important distinction as it relates to your point, that forming a union is better than buying litigation insurance. Litigation insurance doesn't violate anyone's rights, but a union does. Libertarians also tend to address people who hold opposing views as if they were complete idiots. See e.g your assumption that I am completely unintormed about libertarian views on unionization, I didn't assume you were uninformed. I became convinced of that after reading your post: "Yeah, and if you want to be that simple-minded about it, banning unions violates the right of individuals to associate to protect their collective interests...Obviously if you are a libertarian, you will be opposed to unionization in general;..." I guess I should have been charitable. I should have assumed you knew this was false, but were saying it anyway in order to cast your political opponents in a bad light? My apologies. In the future, I'll assume you are deliberately lying rather than simply making uninformed statements. You make a comment saying that public sector workers should not be allowed to unionize... You have me confused with someone else.
- foldr 17y agoThe thing is, you say that "forming a union violates [people's] rights", but also that you are not opposed to unionization. I think you're perfectly illustrating the semantic issue here. Being opposed to unionization can either mean that you are opposed to voluntary organization in the workplace of any sort, or that you are opposed to the formation of organizations with the legal protections that unions currently have. If you say that unions violate rights, a sensible reader will naturally infer that you are opposed to "unionization" in some relevant sense of the word (given the reasonable assumption that you are opposed to rights violations). I am not so easily confused by ambiguous words as you think, and I understand the libertarian position on this issue: unionization in the sense of voluntary organization is fine, unionization in the normal sense of the word is not. As for your somewhat confused and bitter comments on my uninformedness, I think they illustrate my point. It is simply impossible to have a sensible discussion with someone who holds other people in such contempt. I think I've already explained what I was saying. Why are you trying to rake over the semantic issues yet another time?