4 ms·
It's rather interesting to me, that every time one of these studies or articles is published, people crawl out of the woodwork shouting denials and rejection.
by Alupis 11y ago
It's rather interesting to me, that every time one of these studies or articles is published, people crawl out of the woodwork shouting denials and rejection.
People, for some reason, want to cling to this naive idea that cannabis consumption has zero negative effects.
Can't we all just accept that it is indeed harmful to your body and brain, especially if used habitually? Continue to use it as you wish, but understand it very well is causing long term harm, just as any other sin-of-choice! Is that really so rejectionable?
- takno 11y agoThere exists a political climate where any negative effects are seized upon as evidence that cannabis should remain banned, however inapplicable (for example because they are a small study of chronic users after a week's withdrawal). In such circumstances it is often couterproductive to hold nuanced views.
- DanBC 11y ago> In such circumstances it is often couterproductive to hold nuanced views. That's what parent poster is asking for. Any time I post about cannabis on HN i have to include the line "I am strongly in favour of drug legalisation" or tediously predictable replies accusing me of shilling for the government appear. And my position - that for some people smoking large amounts of cannabis is probably a bad idea (especially if they've young; have a history of psychosis; or have a family history of psychosis) - doesn't feel particularly un-nuanced.
- pc86 11y agoI'd be more interested in your nuanced opinions if you weren't a government shill.
- DanBC 11y agoI'm not a government shill, which makes it even more frustrating.
- dang 11y ago> I'd be more interested in your nuanced opinions if you weren't a government shill. Personal attacks are not allowed on HN, and neither are accusations of shilling or astroturfing without evidence. (An opposing opinion is emphatically not evidence.) We ban users that do this, so I'm dismayed that such an established user as you would set this kind of example for others. We'll put it down as the kind of lapse that happens to all of us on the internet, but please don't do it again.
- bcook 11y agoI guess you missed the articles that say marijuana has positive effects? There are positive and negative aspects. You ask why people are biased towards the positive and, similarly, I ask why are you focused on the negative? There is much research to be done. Let's wait and see how it turns out. :)
- Alupis 11y ago> I ask why are you focused on the negative? Well, I'm not. Of course there can be, and there are positive medical effects. The issue is, most users aren't using for real bona fide medical purposes. These are the same users who reject any notion that their favorite pastime may indeed be causing them long term harm. I ask, why reject it? Alcohol can have good effects in moderation, but when abused it causes long term harm as well. Why treat it any different? > There is much research to be done. Let's wait and see how it turns out. Indeed there is. Most of the claims of harmlessness are based on bad science conducted decades ago! Unfortunately, no matter how many studies are published since then, people cling to the old invalidated data which furthers the narrative they desire most.
- oldmanjay 11y agoThe claims of harmlessness are based on decades of widespread use without even silly overblown anecdotal stories of people being harmed (he took a giant hit and jumped out the window!)
- bcook 11y agoYou are being too absolutist. Nothing is "harmless". I agree with you... as with any choice, an individual should try to compare the pros & cons of any decision. My argument would be, if a group happens to be "self-medicating" or simply "getting high", is marijuana not one of the better drugs for that purpose? Yes, drugs (the kind that make you feel good) are probably not something we should encourage, but if it must happen, marijuana is perhaps the best choice. Let's assume abstinence is impossible.
- DanBC 11y ago
- CuriouslyC 11y agoI don't think it is really that "harmful" if you eat/vaporize it. That being said, it certainly does reduce motivation/focus when used to excess.
- Alupis 11y ago> I don't think it is really that "harmful" if you eat/vaporize it. This is exactly the responses I was talking about. The study clearly says THC causes the harmful cognition effects. You're still getting THC by eating/vaporizing it! (otherwise it'd be a pointless activity). Consumption method is pretty irrelevant, other than less carcinogens when not smoking it (the only appreciable difference between consumption methods).
- squeaky-clean 11y ago> The study clearly says THC causes the harmful cognition effects. This is also just a single study with some questionable methods. It's just as ignorant to blindly dismiss this study as it is to blindly accept it.
- Alupis 11y ago> This is also just a single study with some questionable methods How many studies need to come out before folks start to accept that maybe their favorite pastime isn't so harmless after all? It's fairly obvious introducing chemicals to your body long term will have undesirable side effects. In the end, it doesn't matter how harmful or harmless this substance is. People will continue to use and abuse it regardless. But we should not reject modern studies simply because we want to believe old data.
- mbrock 11y agoNo, that's not fairly obvious! "Chemical" in this context is meaningless... so you're basically claiming that eating anything is harmful to the pristine state of the body uncontaminated by "chemicals" (aka molecules).
- mikearagua 11y agoIt's almost as if the government had been lying about it for decades and people became suspect of any claims being made. But you're right, I'm really interested in learning the actual science around it so I'm happy that work is being done. I suppose that perspective doesn't lead to the need to comment. And it's not only the "sins-of-choice" that cause long term harm. Life itself has quite a few negative effects and is the leading cause of death, after all.
- mbrock 11y ago"Can't we all just accept"—why? Because it's a "sin"?
- Alupis 11y ago> "Can't we all just accept"—why? Because it's a "sin"? You willingly cause harm to your body and brain daily. I choose to drink too many energy drinks, knowing full well all the chemicals and additives are not good for me. The point is, I don't go around claiming energy drinks are totally harmless simply because I enjoy them. Of course they're not good for me. Accept cannabis causes harm, and then make an educated choice to continue using or not. I just ask that we be realistic about this - it's a foreign chemical being introduced to your body.
- mbrock 11y agoBut you can't base an argument on "please accept my claim as fact," is what I mean. I'm not aware of a clear scientific consensus that cannabis is harmful.
- jlarocco 11y agoI don't think anybody is shouting "denials and rejection." Usually what I see is people pointing out that whatever new negative result is no worse than other substances and activities that are legal.
- askldfhjkasfhd 11y agoI think the evidence that's out there shows cannabis consumption has negative effects for developing minds. And there is some evidence to indicate that burning plant material inhalation is bad (although this is far from as factual as with cigarettes, for example). Generally, the studies that indicate long term negative effects use a limited population or confounders (such as amphetamines in this case). Those studies indicate one method/combination is harmful, but (AFAICT) are not generalizable to most users. I am happy to be shown wrong, but have yet to come across a generalizable study that shows long term negative health effects of cannabis consumption.
- mc808 11y agoI've noticed similar crawling out of the woodwork when the harmful effects of coffee, sugar, and other sinful addictive drugs are discussed.