2 ms·
I rather think there is a decent point in there, but on closer inspection this argument that the ownership of property should give you unfettered ability to do
by chris_wot 11y ago
I rather think there is a decent point in there, but on closer inspection this argument that the ownership of property should give you unfettered ability to do whatever you want falls apart.
If the person next door wants to run a private, non-commercial meat processing plant (abattoir) then I think it's fair to object. If they wanted to setup a rifle range that ran throughout the day and night, this would also be a valid objection.
Or more likely, if they were hoarders who cause a health hazard to neighbouring properties, then they eventually don't have the right to unfettered freedom at the expense of everyone else in the community.
Case in point: in Bondi, Sydney there was a case where a family of hoarders caused such problems that there was a massive health risk to the entire suburb. They were forced to allow the council to cleanup their home.[1] That is fair enough.
In any society, individual rights are important. However, there is a limit, even to holding property. There must be some controls over what you can do on your private property to ensure that the greater community is not adversely affected.
1. http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/newslocal/city-east/bobolas-family-member-arrested-at-her-bondi-hoarder-house-before-latest-courtordered-clean-up/news-story/25e31be8159464bcbd9ab01e94f9aeba http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/newslocal/city-east/bobolas...
- ancap 11y agoThe problems you raise are all solved by the theory of homesteading. No additional regulations or zoning laws necessary.
- chris_wot 11y agoHow does it solve the problem? I had to look up the theory on Wikipedia and I don't follow how it resolves the issues I raise.
- ancap 11y agoRegarding the meat packing plant, I'm not really sure what the objection is so I'll have to let you explain why someone might object to it. Do they put off some smell? Make a lot of noise? In both of those cases the smell or the noise would be seen as a trespass onto the neighbors' properties. The rifle range is the same story. The new noise would be considered a trespass on existing neighbor's properties. Regarding the hoarders, whatever the thing threatening neighboring properties (rodents, smells, diseases) would be considered a trespass. Once someone has legitimate claim upon a property, they have the right to enjoy that property in the manner in which they obtained it. A lot of the protections of enjoyment of property that people seek through additional legislation would be built in if the laws held greater respect for property rights to begin with.