3 ms·
>The need for "baseload", "storage", or "the sun doesn't always shine and the wind doesn't always blow" are red herrings. They are not relevant. They aren't re
by dogma1138 11y ago
>The need for "baseload", "storage", or "the sun doesn't always shine and the wind doesn't always blow" are red herrings. They are not relevant.
They aren't red herrings they are poor excuses when used as a reason to not to expand renewable but they aren't without their merit.
We need to improve energy storage considerably to be able to push renewables to be actually a major part of the electric grid.
A a major part is a very important definition here because they need to be dependable, it's nice when you have a headlines that Denmark has reached 90% of it's energy production with wind for period X but we also need to put it into perspective that it was only a few hours in a single day on a specific year.
Solar and wind are being constantly improved it's true but we also need massive improvements in energy storage as well as to renew our interests in better and safer nuclear reactors to actually drive out Fossil Fuel completely and have an abundance of energy that could be used to improve everything around it.
Our energy goals shouldn't be aimed at something comparable to fossil fuel we should find ways to produce 10 times what we produce now in a cheap, reliable and environmentally sound fashion.
If we have an abundance of electricity many other things can improve, we can stop sucking out out underground water and make desalination cheap for everyone, we can grow more crops faster reducing the amount of food, we can produce more at lower costs.
Energy is a much larger bottleneck than people assume, especially to developing countries, better energy production, better grids mean that everyone in Africa can get a water purified, an AC and a fridge, it also means that we can start treating the sewage which is a problem now in many parts of Africa where NGO's gave them a water pump and forgot that they also need plumbing and septic treatment facilities.
So while you might claim that solar and wind are here in a massive way, we haven't even touched the tip of the iceberg as far as energy production goes and where we should be. And sadly too many people in the environmental lobbies want to cut down on energy production rather than to increase it 10 fold.
- Osiris30 11y agoMisinformed. Please see my comment at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11524691 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11524691 and these links would be helpful http://www.nrel.gov/analysis/re_futures/ http://www.nrel.gov/analysis/re_futures/ http://cleantechnica.com/2016/03/02/base-load-power-is-a-myth-used-for-defending-the-fossil-fuel-industry/ http://cleantechnica.com/2016/03/02/base-load-power-is-a-myt... http://cleantechnica.com/2014/08/08/rmi-blows-lid-baseload-power-myth-video/ http://cleantechnica.com/2014/08/08/rmi-blows-lid-baseload-p... http://rameznaam.com/2016/01/31/how-far-can-renewables-go-pretty-darn-far/ http://rameznaam.com/2016/01/31/how-far-can-renewables-go-pr...
- ageofwant 11y agoSolar power is great, but it will not flood the Sahara and the Simpson Desert, nor pump gigatons of C02 from the oceans or melt the oort asteroids into giant glass ball habitats for the billions of earth creatures that will live there one day. For that we need something a bit more energy dense. When the first commercial fusion reactor is sold, the vast majority of "renewable" installations will immediately become redundant.
- pjc50 11y agoThe first commercial fusion reactor is (a) a long way off and (b) going to be tremendously expensive. Whereas solar and wind can be deployed today for reasonable prices, reducing our CO2 output. I wouldn't be surprised if the first commercial fusion plant in the UK is built only after the 30 year design lifetime of my solar panels has passed.
- Retric 11y agoSolar can do all of those things. The most useful thing to do with ort cloud objects is to get them closer to a star for cheap energy. Once you get the ball rolling it's easy to beam power out to the ort cloud. PS: Remember there is no night in space. So that's 4 * (149,597,870,700) ^2 * 1.3kw for billions of years. After the stars die, then we can start using all that saved up hydrogen.
- ageofwant 11y agoSure, but you have to concede that it is much more convenient having a small sun in your basement than having to deal with concentrating the energy from the giant ball in the sky. Especially if your halfway to Alpha Centauri. In which case the giant ball is little more than a bright star. But, I'll be happy with your scenario too.
- dogma1138 11y agoI'm not misinformed, you are looking for solutions for the current global energy production, I think we should increase it ten fold and that's only the beginning.
- stevejones 11y agoOne advantage of solar is the requirement for an electrical grid is lessened, when photovoltaics get cheap enough the requirement for a grid is eliminated.
- kumarski 11y agoWhere do we go after lithium iron phophate batteries as far as a galvanic chemical source for batteries? Please help me the understand evidence that suggests we have somewhere on the periodic table to move to after Lithium batteries? (Lead Acid ----> NiCd ----> Lithium....now where do we go?) How do we improve energy storage? Be very explicit about what data/evidence are driving your statements. Bold claims about energy storage increases are unusual given the energy realities of today. How much natural gas peaking can solar/wind displace?
- dogma1138 11y agoEnergy storage doesn't mean only batteries, we can store energy as heat, as kinetic energy for example by pumping air into under water tanks, and by quite a few other means. As far as batteries go, the chemistry doesn't necessarily has to change that drastically the internal structure of batteries is always evolving and we are finding more ways to increase their efficiency. And with advancements in nano technology new flow batteries are becoming more and more viable for long term energy storage Hydrogen–lithium batteries could offer 8-13 times the energy density of regular LiOn rechargeable batteries and modern flow batteries are just in their infancy. Flow batteries are also very appealing to the automotive market because cars with batteries that run on nanoelectrofuels could be refueled just like petrol so once your battery runs out of charge you simply pump out the depleted solution and pump new one in.