3 ms·
I think this article boils down to two statements, "Mr. Mahaney said stock-based compensation could “distort the quality” of a company’s earnings and “make the
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
I think this article boils down to two statements,
"Mr. Mahaney said stock-based compensation could “distort the quality” of a company’s earnings and “make them look stronger than they are.” -- this has been a refrain from analysts for years, and the whole reason companies now report options as an expense. The argument goes, if it doesn't "cost" anything to give someone an option, then for a salary budget of X and a revenue of Y you mis-report the cost of revenue so the revenue "looks better" than it really is. In my experience, anyone who has worked at a job where part of their compensation was stock options has never considered options "pay" like the dollars that show up in your paycheck twice a week. They are always lottery tickets, and given the trading restrictions at public companies, usually a pain to exercise or cash out. Further distancing them in one's mind from the notion of compensation. The second statement is this one;
"Ms. Hindlian says that while it can be reasonable for companies to pay workers a lot in stock, the practice can become scary when the stock starts to fall. “Particularly with software companies, you run the risk of losing your leading salespeople, engineers and developers when the stock falls, because employees feel like they’re getting a pay cut,” -- For the folks that I know, they don't consider it pay so if the options which they haven't exercised are underwater they don't consider them a "pay cut."
It is closer to the truth to say that options with value (so called "in the money") do have a retention power on employees but only if they continue to be worth something. And sometimes even that isn't enough.
But it is true to say that employees with options don't behave like little autonomous drone actors moving in collective self interest, and that makes it a lot harder to evaluate the enterprise value of a company. That difficulty arises from the understanding that it is the people that make the company what it is, and not being able to predict if those people will stay or leave adds uncertainty.
The desire for mathematical evaluation is strong in the analyst community and they continue to argue against anything that seems to affect that.
- d4rkph1b3r 11y agoThe vast majority of people making money from stock compensation are at big companies that give generous RSU grants, so I'm not really sure how much of what you say is applicable. I think people absolutely consider RSUs as a factor in compensation, albeit a slightly more complicated, less predictable amount of pay. But given that it can be over 100% of your total cash compensation... it seems crazy to say people don't 'count' it.
- readams 11y agoThis is nonsense. Remember that they're talking about public companies here, and the stock grants aren't options but typically come in the form of restricted stock units. Of course people treat RSU grants as pay. It's taxed like pay and otherwise acts exactly like pay except that it's tied to the stock price. For many people it's the majority of the pay or an otherwise substantial component of the compensation structure.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoIf we're talking RSU's sure, if we're talking ISO's not so much. I would certainly agree with you on the RSU front, although there is the other twist that some companies, like Google, don't equate RSU's 1:1 with actual shares, they can go up or down depending on other factors. So you can have 100 RSU's that convert to 1 share or 200 shares depending on how much your manager likes you. In that case it really doesn't matter if the stock price goes up or down.
- eitally 11y agoWat? An RSU grant of 100 shares won't actually result ownership of 100 shares?
- ChuckMcM 11y agoNot at Google, in California. When I was working there, one of the things they really liked was a dynamic compensation system. Basically everyone got a calibration score and that score dynamically adjusted your compensation, up or down. To be fair it is a very creative way to avoiding the trap of over paying people. The bottom line is that all grants are legal contracts, generally very long and dense legal contracts, and it is useful to spend time to understand them. California is an "at will" state, if either you or the employer doesn't like the situation, either one of you can end it and be done.
- logical42 11y agoI'm not sure what you are saying corresponds with reality..
- st3v3r 11y ago"For the folks that I know, they don't consider it pay so if the options which they haven't exercised are underwater they don't consider them a "pay cut."" Umm, if I had options that were in the money, that suddenly ceased to be, I absolutely would consider that a pay cut.
- thaumasiotes 11y agoThat's not a pay cut -- it's a loss. You already had those options. When the compensation you receive going forward falls, that's a pay cut.
- st3v3r 11y agoDoesn't matter. It's still going to feel like a pay cut, and be treated as such by most people.