4 ms·
Have Comment Sections on News Media Websites Failed?
- tim333 11y agoThey seem to be doing ok on the whole. Being able to vote comments up and down helps loose the bad stuff.
- dandare 11y agoI keep wondering for years now why nobody copied the reddit comment system? It is simply the best comment system invented so far and I don't see a single reason why ALL newspapers should not implement a variant of it.
- jack9 11y agoThe reddit comment system is not that good and has been duplicated many times. Almost every comment system is comprised of multiple recognizable elements. 1. The presentation (this is probably what you meant). Reddit's comment threading and hiding is excellent. /. does something very similar, but with more decoration. 2. The voting system. Reddit's comment system is for rewarding comments that contribute to the discussion for some value of "contribute". Instead it's used as a popularity score, which has resulted in the same problems you see in Stack Overflow where accuracy falls prey to enthusiasm (for good or ill). The systems that do not have a "downvote", instead starting at an anonymous (or some incremental) threshold. I thought maybe a floating filter based on the average or some group-specific setting or a manual setting (e.g. /.) would be optimal, but there are some readability problems that can only be solved with good presentation. I have not seen many that have good presentation AND technical sophistication because the last item is a deal-breaker. 3. Automation/tooling. Manual and/or automated moderation + bot mitigation is a fairly complex issue. Thread locking, deletion, account banning, anti-spam measures are not things that traditional media are prepared to deal with. You find they sometimes just abandon or delete articles that have been bot-slimed. Reddit's tools are a combination of watchful (time-investment) community leaders, automation, and network level blocking. 4... there's probably more, but those are what comes to mind.
- stirner 11y agoI sympathize with the desire to avoid racism, sexism, and the other forms of abuse the writers mentioned, but people with nasty opinions should be discouraged with voting systems, not with complete silence. By all means, go ahead and remove comment sections from your site. But I imagine there are people beside me who will move on to other sites when they see discussion being shut down.
- jrnichols 11y agoI used to think the same way, but re/code has done just fine without comments. On most regular news sites, they always seem to devolve into mud flinging anyway. The signal to noise ratio went way off the chart. Disqus has a rating system but that hasn't helped much either as well written opinions are voted down simply because they disagree with the hivemind that has way too much free time.
- mozumder 11y agoVoting systems are probably the worst option, since it just encourages negative group behavior. The entirety of Reddit is a good example. The best thing is to just shut down the comments, and encourage trolls to move elsewhere. Remember that advertisers don't want all audiences - they want quality audiences. No advertiser is interested in placing their ads on a train wreck, even though a lot of people are looking at it. It just doesn't help their branding.
- stirner 11y agoWell, I agree that Reddit's voting system encourages groupthink, but I'd rather that unpopular opinions were silenced by other commenters rather than all opinions being silenced. Do you think that comments belong anywhere on the web (on aggregator sites, for example)?
- mozumder 11y agoUnmoderated commenting doesn't belong anywhere that relies on advertising as a business model. At the very least, have a human editor filter out comments, based on editorial guidelines.