38 ms·
- asking someone out on dates repeatedly, even if they've already said "no" There's some kind of weird disconnect in our society here. I've been in the positio
by stcredzero 11y ago
- asking someone out on dates repeatedly, even if they've already said "no"
There's some kind of weird disconnect in our society here. I've been in the position where I've asked a colleague out to a movie, but she gave a plausible sounding excuse each time. I stopped asking when she finally definitely said "no," but she did so with language that made me feel like she thought me a rapist. No means no, but white lies should not be held equivalent to "no."
- vkou 11y agoIf she really wanted to see the movie with you, but she actually had to take her dog to the dentist, she would have counter-offered a time and date. She was trying to brush you off, hoping you'd take the hint, without appearing confrontational. It obviously didn't work. You continued with the unwanted advances, and it made her uncomfortable.
- ElComradio 11y agoThis is the unintended consequence of a lifetime of hearing that men are dangerous and might kill you. Threats are everywhere, says the media, constantly.
- vkou 11y ago... And so do individual women. In this thread, even. Are they all lying?
- ElComradio 11y agoAre our only choices: 1) Violence against women never occurs, and 2) Most men are barely contained threats?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- stcredzero 11y agoI actually ended up asking her what was going on, specifically, "Am I bad at taking hints?" At that point, I should think a simple yes would have done fine. Making someone feel like a rapist for believing what is said or failing to correctly second guess is just weird and oppressive in itself.
- tome 11y ago> Making someone feel like a rapist for believing what is said or failing to correctly second guess is just weird and oppressive in itself. It is unfortunate and I sympathise with your hurt feelings, but I think this is just something you should take on the chin.
- stcredzero 11y agoDouble standards and requiring second guessing based on gender is as harmful now as it was in the 50's.
- vkou 11y agoFor you, the wrong response to your question causes harm to your feelings. For a woman, giving the wrong response to an obsessed creeper can cause harm to her career, her body, or her life. (Yes, I am quite aware that women can be creepy and violent. No, it is not a frequent power dynamic in the office.) It would certainly be nice if we could be honest all the time, but you are demanding far too much in this bargain.
- ownagefool 11y agoThink about it another way, if a girl asked you out and you didn't want to go out with her, what would you do? Sure, some of us, like some woman, don't really care and will just shut it down, but many of us would just make an excuse so we're not outright rude. Either way, learn by being told, or learn by using empathy, if she doesn't counter offer it was a no. Once you've had your 3rd no, you're that creepy guy fyi.
- 11y ago
- jbmorgado 11y agoYou are making it sound like it's actually his fault that he kept asking until she actually gave a definite answer. Worst than that, some people would call that harassment and chastise me and others for victim blaming, just stating a simple fact: She should have said no. I wonder how many of these cases get into the statistics about harassment when it should just be considered simple human interaction up to the point she gave a definite answer: "No". It's quite simple, you can even make it nicer with: "Sorry but I'm not interested". If after that he keeps pushing, then yes, it should be considered harassment.
- devilsavocado 11y agoI don't necessarily think that it's his fault... But try asking 100 random people on the street what it means when you ask a girl out and she responds that she is busy, and she does not suggest another date. I'd bet that at least 98 of them would say that is means she is not interested, and she is letting you down nicely. I'm kind of surprised some men don't understand that.
- rokhayakebe 11y agoGuys do. Some people (men and women) are just very clear cut and they do not try to understand the subtext. They say what they mean and they expect the same. They are usually thought of as arrogant.
- ghostcat 11y agoUsing a straight-up "no" can turn it into an outright confrontation, which can be pretty dangerous if the guy isn't the type that will take "no" for an answer. Once I gave a guy a simple-but-polite "no" in college, and he responded with harassing emails/repeated phone calls/stalking/etc for months. Once during an internship, a superior cornered me in my office after-hours, blocking my exit and declaring his love for me. I could've said "no", but I was alone and cornered and in a very vulnerable situation, so I stammered over excuses about being really busy with work right then and thanked God that my internship was ending in a few days. I wish I could just say "no", because most men would be civil and bow out and appreciate the straightforwardness. But I have no way to know in advance which kind of person any given guy is going to be.
- snowwrestler 11y agoI think this is true, but it's important to understand that there is more to harassment than just missing a few hints. I'm sure she was annoyed, but that doesn't, by itself, make the situation harassment. He can easily recover now by simply acting polite, pleasant, and professional with her--essentially, acting like it never happened. That's hard, but the right thing to do. If he retaliated--by treating her badly, talking shit about her to other people, trying to harm her career, etc.--that would be a clear step into harassment land. Yeah, it feels unfair, but that's life. People get annoyed at each other all the time in a typical workplace, often for reasons that seem unfair. Everyone is still expected to act maturely and professionally.
- clevernickname 11y agoIf the socially awkward male stereotype is to be oblivious to hints and the way your actions are interpreted, then the socially awkward female stereotype is to be misinterpret and overanalyze everything people do and think you're being very clear with your intentions when you really aren't. This is something I've seen repeatedly in many women, in their interactions with everybody in all kinds of situations, yet people rarely comment on it the way they do the bumbling male nerd. My theory on why tech seems to be an outlier in terms of gender-related disputes (other than that stories about it generate lots of clicks) is that rather than being an environment of "evil misogynistic geeks wreaking havoc on well adjusted females," it's really an environment of developmentally stunted socially awkward people all around, a perpetual comedy of errors of oversensitive idiots overreacting to bumbling fools.
- NoGravitas 11y agoOr maybe even not a particular time and date, but "maybe sometime next week?" or "I'd love to, but I'll have to take a rain check". Those are both "yes in principle"; anything less than those is "no".
- scott_s 11y agoI would not call it a "weird disconnect". It's just very awkward to give a flat-out "No" when asked out, even when the two people are not coworkers. When it comes to asking someone out, there are three answers: Yes; Yes in principle, but I'm not available then, how about next Tuesday?; all other answers are No. She was probably frustrated that you weren't picking up on this, and probably did feel uncomfortable that she had to keep rejecting you.
- stcredzero 11y agoIf sounding like "yes in principle" is the goal of your speech, then how can one reasonably expect to feel violated when that speech is taken as "yes in principle?" I like "no means no" as a principle. I wish everyone stood up boldly for the right to say "no." Do this by boldly saying no. The right to say yes but really mean no is something else entirely, and is corrosive to the right to say no.
- scott_s 11y agoThe answer is only "yes in principle" if they counter-offer with a specific date. Otherwise it's no. These are standard social-norms, not specific to work. Asking someone out is stressful, but being asked out is also stressful. I think it's unreasonable to assume that people who are being asked out should automatically have to assume the awkward social burden of providing unequivocal rejections. Once you learn these social-norms, it's not hard to navigate with them.
- stcredzero 11y agoThe fact that trying to sound like "yes in principle" while not satisfying that in a detail is just weird on the face of it. If it's a social norm, it's an illogical and out of whack social norm. Grown women are just as rational and emotionally tough as men. If you claim the task of saying no is too much for them, I don't buy it. I think it's telling that in contexts where consensuality is even more immediately critical, the social norm is for direct and clear communication. awkward social burden of providing unequivocal rejections It's unreasonable for people to assume the awkward social burden of subtle second-guessing, with the consequence of being labeled as a deviant if you don't. How is that any less unpleasant and corrosive than women having to second guess how they dress, or be thought of as a sexual target? Both of these situations needlessly eschew clear communications for illogical reasons, and hold starkly severe consequences for not adhering to them -- way out of whack with the cost/benefit analysis of avoiding a little "awkwardness."
- Mz 11y agoYou know, you sometimes say really brilliant and insightful things, like this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11520762 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11520762 And then you say something like the above and I shake my head and wonder how both sentiments can be expressed by the exact same person. Do you not see how your other comment applies to the situation that you find personally frustrating? Do you not see how unreasonable it is to expect all women to just give a straight up "no" instead of a polite excuse? I am pretty forthright and I find that just straight up telling men "no" is all kinds of problematic. If just saying "no" worked and solved my problems, wow, that would be heaven.