4 ms·
Burdensome taxes to support underutilized rail infrastructure cause misery too. We can call names at public policy, but that's not a good way to manage public p
by JoeAltmaier 11y ago
Burdensome taxes to support underutilized rail infrastructure cause misery too. We can call names at public policy, but that's not a good way to manage public policy. Efficiency has to matter too.
And, strangely, this article insists there's no central decision-making group for managing rail stations and lines. Then, how did Mr. Beeching manage to close all those lines?
- makomk 11y agoA few decades after Beeching's cuts, British Rail was privatized in a rather half-baked fashion.
- Jaruzel 11y agoAnd interestingly enough, it now seems to be slowly creeping back the other way: http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/tfls-london-overground-is-being-handed-control-over-londons-entire-suburban-rail-network-a6824761.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/tfls-london-o... Normally I'd be against nationalisation, but having been a 'SouthEastern' commuter for over 20 years, I can only hope this will result in an improved service.
- agent008t 11y agoI wish the UK had a high-speed rail network like the Shinkansen in Japan.
- MLR 11y agoWe're in the middle of trying to establish a high speed corridor at the moment, I'm all for it personally but honestly it's been a ludicrously expensive project so far and the opposition to it is huge and mounting. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_Speed_2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_Speed_2
- gsnedders 11y agoTfL doesn't actually run the TfL Rail services—the big difference is their operator receives a fixed sum for operating them, compared with the other operators where they pay a fixed amount to the DfT and pocket any profit they get beyond that. Arguably, the big difference is that it means TfL Rail will only get investment if TfL decides, because there's no motivation for the operator to do so. At the same time, TfL Rail isn't in competition with the Underground, etc. so better inter-modal connectivity becomes more worth investment.
- njs12345 11y agoThe operator also has no control over fares and branding, I'd argue that's a big difference too.
- makomk 11y agoIn practice, other British rail companies only seem to make improvements if the government pays for them most of the time too. There's very little actual private-sector investment in the railways; it basically just seems to be a license to print money.
- twic 11y agoMostly, yes. One honourable exception is Chiltern's Project Evergreen: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chiltern_Railways#Project_Evergreen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chiltern_Railways#Project_Ever... But then, Chiltern wasn't run by a bus company, but by a group of British Rail managers who knew exactly what they were doing: http://www.oxfordtimes.co.uk/business/profiles/8227427.History_of_Chiltern_Railways/ http://www.oxfordtimes.co.uk/business/profiles/8227427.Histo... I suppose it also helped that it was a line with potential to steal traffic from already overloaded intercity services to Oxford and Birmingham.
- lmm 11y agoChiltern are owned by Deutsche Bahn are they not? A state operator running a better railway, who'd've thought it. (And aren't the improvements all funded by the back door by central government anyway?)
- codeulike 11y agohow did Mr. Beeching manage to close all those lines? In the 60s, it was all centralised.
- thrownaway2424 11y agoDoes efficiency also matter for roads? Has anyone ever produced a list of all the unprofitable roads in the country?
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoSure. I'm in the US. Iowa's DOT has constantly reevaluated the use of roads as land-use and rural residences change. Bridges de-commissioned; road maintenance turned to 'class B' which means no maintenance. In fact they recently re-committed their budget 100% to maintenance and 0% to new roads. Mostly because global weather instability has been really rough on our huge, vulnerable road network. Agriculture is important to us; every field has to have access to roads and markets.
- thrownaway2424 11y agoThat's great, but it puts Iowa in a tiny class of rational D's of T. Most governments find roads, streets, and parking to be obviously desirable.
- a_humean 11y agoWhen Beeching wrote the report the stations, carriages, services, and rail were publicly owned and centralised under one public company: British Rail. In the mid-90s the services, carriages, and the stations were sold off as 14-year franchises to the private firms (most of which are actually public rail companies from other countries such as Germany and France), but the rail itself kept in a weird thing called National Rail that has an odd public/private structure that I don't understand. Ownership and responsibility for the network is somewhat unclear in many cases. I think at this point there is a political consensus that its been a complete mess and a botched privatisation that either need to be redone or just be re-nationalised, though Conservatives try to not talk about it if they can (they implemented it). There was an awkward period in recent years in which one of the private companies abandoned a major line as unprofitable and it was temporarily nationalised - it ended up becoming the most popular and profitable line while under public management. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/East_Coast_(train_operating_company) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/East_Coast_(train_operating_co...
- gsnedders 11y ago> the rail itself kept in a weird thing called National Rail that has an odd public/private structure that I don't understand No, it wasn't. The rail itself was sold off as Railtrack. Following on from the Hatfield crash, after which it spent £580 million on repairing similar track faults as which caused the Hatfield crash, and a few hundred million more on compensation, which led to the failure of the company and it entered "railway administration" (essentially a special form of administration created along with the privatisation of the railways to avoid the railway ceasing operating when in administration). Network Rail then bought Railtrack in 2002, bringing the railway infrastructure back into public hands. Railtrack was then subsequently liquidated.
- a_humean 11y agoOh sorry, I forgot that part of the history. I was a little young at the time so the Hatfield crash is not something I remember in much detail.
- takno 11y ago
- tome 11y agoPoint of information: it was Dr Beeching (PhD).