3 ms·
Welcome to 'the worst job in the world' – my life as a Guardian moderator
- im3w1l 11y agoTrolling is a word. It means something: "make a deliberately offensive or provocative online posting with the aim of upsetting someone or eliciting an angry response from them." I can't help but wonder why the author attempts to describe anything he doesn't like, in his moderator role, as trolling. This seems to be a general trend in newspaper people describing their comment sections.
- _yosefk 11y agoTo elaborate on your point - from the article: "They are comment-thread poison – men’s rights activists who act as if articles about women’s issues are their gender’s single biggest problem, climate change deniers who will drag any conversation about energy policy into murky pseudo-science, and borderline racists for whom there is no issue that cannot be pinned on immigration (UK) or black people (US)." ...incidentally these are all people strongly opposing (perhaps to an extreme) some political positions of The Guardian. Not a single example of people strongly supporting (perhaps to an extreme) some political positions of The Guardian - these could never become "comment-thread poison."
- fredley 11y agoThose people are probably off being "comment-thread poison" trolls on right-wing websites.
- _yosefk 11y agoProbably "yes" in the sense that it's those websites where they're being labeled "comment-thread poison", probably "no" in the sense that they certainly do comment on left-wing websites, they just don't ever "derail the discussion" in the eyes of this moderator.
- im3w1l 11y agoLet's take this example > climate change deniers who will drag any conversation about energy policy into murky pseudo-science, That is activism using derailment and off-topic tactics. Not saying that that shouldn't be deleted. Just that it isn't trolling.
- tinco 11y agoNot a single example out of two examples chosen to be familiar to his target audience, it must mean he moderates with a strong bias. Great to have you in this discussion, did you realize you were drawing an exaggerated conclusion from weak evidence when you wrote your comment? Do you realize it now? Would you consider your comment to be one with an agenda as the author theorized or do you have a different motivation?
- _yosefk 11y agoActually it's 3 examples, which I think is enough to show a bias towards one of two sides (c'mon, nobody chooses one side out of two 3 times in a row accidentally, and if he chose a side with equal probability for each example - yeah right - the result we got is a 1 in 8 event, so not a great support for that hypothesis), and as to "familiar to his target audience" - again, come on, his target audience will be familiar with their fellow extremists' arguments just as much as it will be familiar with the other side's extremists. As to what I think of my comment - I think it shouldn't be removed by a forum moderator, nor should your (IMO tremendously biased) comment be removed by a moderator, and neither comment constitutes "trolling" or "comment thread poison." A moderator removing either and doing similar things consistently is creating a forum I would not like to participate in either as a reader or a commenter.
- tinco 11y ago> Actually it's 3 examples, which I think is enough to show a bias towards one of two sides (c'mon, nobody chooses one side out of two 3 times in a row accidentally, and if he chose a side with equal probability for each example - yeah right - the result we got is a 1 in 8 event, so not a great support for that hypothesis), That is a straw man argument, as you can see nowhere I claim that he chose his examples randomly. Quite the opposite as you quote directly, I think he chose his example to speak to his target audience. > again, come on, his target audience will be familiar with their fellow extremists' arguments just as much as it will be familiar with the other side's extremists. Perhaps, but this is a writing style issue. Anyway sure, it's a valid point you could ask of the writer to always perfectly balance his examples between minority and majority viewpoints of his readership. I don't think the "come on" is warranted though, do you really feel it's that obvious that the author should consider this instead of considering for example the sting the nice black/white examples that he uses give? As to what you think of your comment, I didn't ask what you thought about your comment. I asked whether you realized your argument was exaggerated. I didn't downvote your reply nor do I think a moderator should remove it. I was just curious as to why you would be artificially polarizing this discussion.
- m0nty 11y ago> a general trend in newspaper people It's a trend with the majority of people. There was a case recently where a UK police force (Cambridge) decided to post pictures of poorly-parked bicycles on Twitter. Many people responded by posting images of poorly-parked cars. They were branded "trolls" by the police. Apparently, peacefully, relevantly and sensibly responding to something is now called "trolling". By the police, of all people. http://www.cambridge-news.co.uk/Twitter-spat-erupts-Cambridge-police-branded/story-28348364-detail/story.html http://www.cambridge-news.co.uk/Twitter-spat-erupts-Cambridg...
- digi_owl 11y agoYeah it seems to fall afoul Poe's law from the other end, by failing to distingush bertween a honest believer and someone apeing the same to produce an emotional response.
- bonaldi 11y agoThis is as tedious a fight as the old "hacker doesn't mean cracker!1!" one was. Words (and phrases such as "begging the question") mean what they're understood to mean by the majority, much though those of us who understand their "proper" definitions might like to fight those tides. Sure, you can still use the lesser-known or overtaken meanings in particular scenarios when you know your audience has a shared understanding, but that's true of all jargon or less-common definitions
- pessimizer 11y agoAre you saying that "troll" now means "people who disagree with our established positions"? That's far less a new usage then an intentional relabeling to imply that censorship is justified against any group - like redefining "terrorist" to mean "critic of government policy."
- bonaldi 11y agoNo, and I don't know where you got that from. "Troll" is rapidly coming to mean "person who behaves offensively, abusively or objectionably online". Of course the Guardian will have a different definition of what those behaviours are to, say, the Daily Mail. Or to HN!
- mahranch 11y ago> Are you saying that "troll" now means I think the overall meaning of his comment is basically "Languages evolve." And I agree with him. It's as inevitable as death and taxes.
- iorrus 11y agoOne man's troll is another man's freedom fighter. Depends on the agenda of the website. Guardian is the premier left of centre newspaper in the UK as a result, it will be targeted by those who disagree with their views. Are these people trolls? Depends on your personal ideology.
- mahranch 11y agoOnly 70k comments a day? As a someone who has been a reddit default moderator for 6+ years (I help out in more than 1 default subreddit), I'd say they're still small time. It's so bad over on reddit that even with a fully active staff, we have to utilize bots to automate much of the work. Without those bots, it would be impossible to have a community at the sizes we're talking. We simply wouldn't exist. He overstates how bad the job is because they've never experienced "true" bad... The author should see if he could intern for a month on one of reddit's busier subreddits. If he asks, I'd be more than willing to give him an inside peek into one of our subreddits. Weekly 4chan raids, intra-subreddit brigades, people (spammers, SEO types, marketers, etc) trying to game us to reach the front page for profit, and then to add on top of that, we have all the same trolls and racists and psychopaths theguardian has to deal with. That's actually not true, they're not the same, there are more of them on reddit. Many, many more. I know this isn't a competition, but I look at the average comment there and I can get a feel for what moderating there must be like. And I have to say, it looks like paradise compared to reddit. It would be a vacation and even that would probably be an understatement. Though, TheGuardian is the 128th largest website in the world while reddit is 28th (9th largest in the U.S). That's quite the discrepancy.
- elaus 11y ago> […] I look at the average comment there and I can get a feel for what moderating there must be like. And I have to say, it looks like paradise compared to reddit. Correct me if I'm wrong, but what you're seeing in the comment section of the Guardian is AFTER moderation has taken place – both longterm (blocking trolls) and short term (removing/blocking comments). So obviously it doesn't look as bad as what you're seeing WHILE moderating reddit comments and you can't really compare that. It's like I'm saying "moderating reddit is easy, I barely see any spammers or trolls there" (as a user).
- lucozade 11y agoThe Guardian has just done an analysis on comments and they get approx 2% that are blocked or deleted. So it doesn't look like they're fighting back the hordes and you just can't see it. And in the article, the chap says that removing the spammers and swivel-eyes is easy. What's hard is curating the discussion. If you read the comments on this article and on similar articles recently, this is the area that attracts the main criticism of the Guardian moderation. My guess wrt Reddit is that it's a much more difficult job to remove the spammers and front-page optimisers. The curation of a sub-reddit, if it happens at all, is probably easier as there'll likely be little or no real need to be subtle about it.
- gadders 11y agoIronically, the last Guardian editor's daughter got in trouble on comments she was supposed to be moderating: http://www.thejc.com/news/uk-news/21934/guardian-editors-daughter-melanie-phillips-row http://www.thejc.com/news/uk-news/21934/guardian-editors-dau...
- cbeach 11y agoThe Guardian seems to be doing well on HN recently. For such a one-sided political publication, with no technical merit, that seems odd.
- m0nty 11y ago> one-sided political publication They certainly are left-aligned: they are famous (and notorious) for it. The "Guardian-reading lentil-munching sandal-wearing lefty" is a popular caricature, I've even seen people criticised during debates for being a "good Guardian-reader" (i.e. a part-time socialist). But they do publish articles on relevant topics, and are prepared to stick their collective neck out for important stories like the Snowden case. They are probably a few notches above the open sewer which characterises much of the rest of the UK press, and it's clear that many people on HN find them relevant, if not always correct.
- UncleSlacky 11y agoLately, though, they seem to have developed a bias (or maybe it's just become more evident?) against what you might call the "non-establishment" left, people like Jeremy Corbyn and Bernie Sanders get unexpectedly short shrift from most of their writers, whereas their (often female) competition, like Yvette Cooper and Hillary Clinton, get glowing coverage. This has been pointed out extensively in the comment sections, to no avail...
- takno 11y agoI think a lot of people over 40ish view Jeremy Corbyn as very much establishment left, with impeccable roots in the years when the establishment left were in the business of losing and losing hard. The guardian certainly give that view a good deal of prominence, but also feature writers who take a much more positive line on the left. The overall quality has dropped a bit with more clickbait and cif nonsense, but it's still the best place to get news, and the fact that they publicly sweat policy like this is a positive sign
- digi_owl 11y ago
- pieter1976 11y agoSeems vastly overblown to call this "the worst job in the world". There are far, far worse things people do to get paid. Sure jumping out of your tree-hugging everybody-love-everybody mindset is probably a shock, but there's plenty of hatred in the real world.
- takno 11y agoThe article finishes by saying it's the best job in the world. Did you read it?
- rawTruthHurts 11y agoAnd if you read it to the very end, it leaves some doors opened (to the tree-hugging argument I mean): "It’s the best one I’ve ever had."
- pluma 11y agoI thought YouTube moderators had the worst job? http://www.buzzfeed.com/reyhan/tech-confessional-the-googler-who-looks-at-the-wo http://www.buzzfeed.com/reyhan/tech-confessional-the-googler...
- isxek 11y agoAll this talk about worst jobs reminded me of that old show "Dirty Jobs"[0] from a decade ago. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dirty_Jobs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dirty_Jobs
- junko 11y agoSometimes reading the Guardian's comment sections is like reading the Daily Mail's with extra pompous tosh.
- thesehands 11y agoIf online publications wanted genuine discourse under articles then I'm sure the die-hard commentators would pay a fee to engage in such, especially if the author were around to offer response. Seems this would provide enough of a barrier to stop _most_ "trolling", and self fund the moderation. If newspapers would stop using clickbait titles I'm sure they'd move the needle somewhat too. They are however in the 'eyeball' game and the content quality reflects this lowest common denominator ethos.
- grey-area 11y agoI think the problem with sites like the guardian is that they still haven't adjusted to the inversion of power between writer and reader that the Internet brought (the article hints at this but doesn't fully address it). When they still see the article (which is often rushed insignificant fluff) as primary, and comments as secondary, optional and in need of gardening by qualified moderators, they get the commenters they deserve. Contrasting this with moderation and comments on HN and well run subreddits is instructive. Those sites aren't perfect but at least they recognise the value of comments, and that some commenters will know more about the story than anyone, they might even be involved in it as witnesses or protagonists, as opposed to journalists who typically know very little about a subject. In addition your readers can be the best moderators if you empower them and keep steering them with a light hand. The guardian lets readers vote up only and then does nothing with it. Maybe it's time for a new kind of journalism without journalists or ads, with a focus on primary sources, and empowering interested communities to report and verify for other readers. It's unlikely to emerge from old media though.
- lucozade 11y agoI agree with you. My anecdotal opinion is that commentary works well where the article is intended to impart information. A lot of HN submissions are of this type because they're posted precisely because someone learnt something from them and often lead to extra information being imparted in the comments. It's true, to a lesser extent in Guardian articles that are simply reporting. Where it doesn't work well, on HN or news sites, is where the article is intended to influence debate. Whether it's a monad swinging contest on HN or an analysis of the lighter side of Jeremy Corbyn, comments rarely seem to reduce the polarity. I think this is more of an issue for news sites simply because there is less reporting and more influencing done, somewhat ironically.
- grey-area 11y agoYes agreed, on opinion pieces, everyone has their own opinion, and wants to shout about it. I'm not even sure they are useful on a news site, but they drive traffic and due to the perverse incentives which drive places like the guardian (ads and clicks above all, the competition for traffic on google), they will start to dominate over didactic pieces which take more effort and drive less traffic. Our journalism is turning into Buzzfeed because of the quest for traffic at all costs.