5 ms·
It's disturbing to think that the pilots spent precious time trying to reboot the flight computers, rather than trying to stabilize the plane using the basic th
by barrkel 17y ago
It's disturbing to think that the pilots spent precious time trying to reboot the flight computers, rather than trying to stabilize the plane using the basic thrust, pitch, roll and yaw controls, maintaining level flight and an open throttle.
All automated controls like this should be tested with each input in turn (a) disabled and (b) actively malicious, followed by two inputs disabled / malicious, and perhaps three inputs disabled / malicious - with special attention paid to likely cascading failures. Anything the automated system can't deal with should (a) be detectable through sanity checks and (b) have a reliable human response that pilots are trained in.
My experience in flight is limited to some skydiving and flight simulators. What I know about stalling from lack of thrust in level flight is that the plane seems to pitch downwards and becomes relatively unresponsive to the small adjustments in the elevators that ought to correct this pitch. A stupidly simple feedback system that doesn't know about the impending stall would simply try to counteract the stall by pitching up further and further, until it ends up in a flat stall / spin. The problem being that stall warnings are based on wind speed, which in turn requires an instrument.
- epochwolf 17y agoThe problem with the Airbus series of aircraft is that the flight computer has the ultimate authority with flight controls. The flight computer can actually override the pilot if it senses the pilot was attempting to fly outside of programmed limits. Now I would hope that it would release control when it detected a problem, especially when three airspeed sensors are reporting erroneous data. I wonder if this leaves the pilots too dependent on the computer and therefore didn't know how to fix the problems or if the computer itself caused the crash. I could be completely wrong about this. I don't have any experience with flying, I'm just putting out ideas.
- rickmode 17y agoThis sounds a heck of a lot like the drive by wire issues Toyota is having. As technologist we should have a healthy distrust of any software. It's simply too complex to predict. Is it corporation group-think that causes them to ignore this? Or hubris? I can't imagine they are that stupid.
- idlewords 17y ago"The problem with the Airbus series of aircraft is that the flight computer has the ultimate authority with flight controls." Where do you have any evidence for this? As the article points out, once the speed indicators diverged, the flight computer on AF447 put itself into an alternate mode where almost all of the overrides you refer to were turned off. At that point you're basically flying the plane directly, except that hydraulics are moving the flight surfaces for you.
- ovi256 17y ago"Where do you have any evidence for this?" This is a design feature of modern FBW systems. It will not let the plane exit the safety envelope. Simply put, the pilot can put the plane through more acceleration than the frame can handle (the control surfaces are big enough), thus the plane could break apart at high speed without the FBW. You are right for the rest, the flight computer passed control to the pilots after the loss of the pitot tubes.
- idlewords 17y agoNo, I meant where do you have evidence for it ever being a problem. There was a lot of FUD around fly by wire in the early days of Airbus, none of which ever panned out. So I'm asking you to justify your similar statements.
- epochwolf 17y agoHere's one article about it. http://www.seattlepi.com/business/boe202.shtml http://www.seattlepi.com/business/boe202.shtml
- jac_no_k 17y agoThis shows the difference in failure management style between Airbus and Boeing. From the article, it seems that Airbus made assumption that the computers will not fail, and if it does fail, it won't be a survivable event. It does deal with sensor errors but no real way of completely ignoring the bad input. Hopefully Airbus issues an update that allows the computer to fail gracefully. And make it free so there will be high adoption.