4 ms·
Discerning motivations and monday morning quarterbacking whether they were justified or not is a quagmire of futility. Really, the victim just needs to be made
by mindslight 11y ago
Discerning motivations and monday morning quarterbacking whether they were justified or not is a quagmire of futility. Really, the victim just needs to be made whole - force these organizations to stop creating externalities out of their self-created costs. To me, it sounds like the victim in this case is owed an automatic payment of at least several thousand dollars for the lost day, emotional distress, etc. The civil damages in a general kidnapping/wrongful imprisonment case are also a good reference point. He really should sue - free apologies don't reform bad incentives.
Southwest should have also removed the reporting woman from the plane so the victim could face his accuser, and also to reduce frivolous complaints. If she really thinks he was a t'rist, she should be wanting to get off that plane regardless.
- yazaddaruvala 11y agoI think this is reasonable deterrence. The accuser should be asked to get off the plane, and remain with the authorities, till such a time as the accused is allowed to leave or is taken into custody.
- im3w1l 11y agoYou are responding as if the reporting woman could have, should have, expected this outcome. For all she knew, the report could have just resulted in an extra-thorough search.
- mindslight 11y agoThey had already boarded the plane. The only possible outcomes were nothing, or his removal from that flight. It seems reasonable, and incentive-aligning, for both of them to be removed from the plane.
- im3w1l 11y agoSo take him off the plane, search, and let back on? Delay the departure 15 min. Maybe the policies don't work like that though.
- mindslight 11y agoYeah - policies, logistics, police, pilots, and economics don't work like that.