8 ms·
The New Man of 4chan
- sotrueee 11y agoA news article about r9k...
- Aelinsaar 11y agoThat was... surreal.
- sevenless 11y agoWhat was this article really about? Was it more than "I'd like 3000 words on 4chan and toxic masculinity by Friday, please"? There are some baffling omissions. The MRA movement/MGTOW? Gamergate? It just reads as though the writer hasn't much familiarity with the subculture.
- scandox 11y agoMGTOW is referenced briefly
- asdasdmnqwjn 11y agoAre you seriously relating r9k and 4chan's culture to MRAs and MGTOW? Really?
- ZoF 11y agoDo you go on the /chon/ much? It's an extremely common topic across boards
- Chris2048 11y agoThose omissions would confound things. While some MRAs talk about 'betas', not so many advocate explicit violence or 'uprisings'. And Gamer-Gate is another thing entirely - mentioning it would be explicit stereotyping.
- CM30 11y agoYeah, GamerGate is... well to be honest, I don't think anyone supporting or opposing it really knows what it is nowadays, since it's become a catch all term for: Anyone a journalist or media figure or opposer doesn't like/thinks is being a jerk on the internet. Those who oppose corruption in gaming journalism. Those who don't like 'SJW' types trying to censor things or complaining about privilege. Certain groups of trolls who want to dox people they find stupid or strange, and need a justification for it. People who oppose various changes made to localised video games. Conservatives who think gaming and the media has become too liberal. People who want to become internet celebrities off the controversy. Many, many gaming websites and Youtube channels that support some parts but not others. Basically, it's more divided and semi diverse than the rebel groups in Monty Python's Life of Brian. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kHHitXxH-us https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kHHitXxH-us Either way, it's split across so many websites and seemingly encompasses so many radom groups that it's really all that associated with chan culture any more.
- neutronicus 11y agoI dunno, the author seems to have a pretty good handle on both the circa-oughts 4chan and '12-'13 Tumblr feminism I remember.
- CM30 11y ago4chan doesn't allow GamerGate discussion. So anyone wanting to discuss it goes to 8chan instead, which is somehow less moderated than 4chan.
- bitshiftthis 11y agoA review of this article: Get out normies, REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
- jszymborski 11y ago> The details that emerged about Harper-Mercer’s online life made it difficult not to resort to stereotyping. On a dating site, he had listed pop-culture obsessions typical of “beta” shut-ins, including “internet, killing zombies, movies, music, reading,” and added that he lived “with parents.” Movies, music and reading as hobbies? Yup, that's a killer alright. /s Man, the media hasn't really progressed since 1991 has it...
- lake99 11y agoIt has. Doom was released in 1993. Video games have been the leading cause of murders ever since. /s
- zethraeus 11y agoI'm impressed. This is possibly the only article I've seen about 4chan whose author actually understands enough about the discussed subcultures to make interesting analyses.
- justabystander 11y ago> only article ... whose author actually understands enough about the discussed subcultures I was thinking that at first, too, until I noticed that the author completely missed the fact that calling someone a "beta" male is not a positive thing. I mean, she alludes to it, but then takes it all literally. Referring to one's self as beta is generally a self-deprecating statement or a mark of self-resignation. Betas just take whatever they're given. Calling someone "beta" is actually a common insult to many of the sub-cultures that she sweeps together. It's the recognition that someone else is in control. You have to actually look at it from their perspective to get it. These are outcasts. They want to be at the top, but they don't want to be like the people who mistreat them because they despise them and their behavior. Instead, many of them idolize the sigma and omega types - the types who stand outside (or hide within) the hierarchy and still remain confident and powerful. The chans idolize the rebels and the masterminds, not the jocks and the bootlickers. The fact that she can't catch the mockery in all the beta commentary speaks to the fact that she really doesn't understand this culture at all. She may have done some research, but apparently the black humor that pervades the dark corners of the internet escapes her.
- sevenless 11y agoI agree. I thought this article did a better job of discussing these weird net subcultures from an outsider perspective, and capturing the ironic/serious tone of all the atrocious crap they say: https://newrepublic.com/article/132039/tay-exposes-fairy-tales-tell-racists https://newrepublic.com/article/132039/tay-exposes-fairy-tal...
- pron 11y ago> the author completely missed the fact that calling someone a "beta" male is not a positive thing. I mean, she alludes to it, but then takes it all literally. Referring to one's self as beta is generally a self-deprecating statement or a mark of self-resignation. Except she says exactly that: The term “beta” ... is an ironic inversion of the fabled swagger of the alpha male. “beta male” is a common term of identification, one of both belonging and self-mockery. > These are outcasts. They want to be at the top, but they don't want to be like the people who mistreat them because they despise them and their behavior. Instead, many of them idolize the sigma and omega types - the types who stand outside (or hide within) the hierarchy and still remain confident and powerful. The chans idolize the rebels and the masterminds, not the jocks and the bootlickers. She says exactly that, too: Whereas alphas tend to be macho, sporty, and mainstream in their tastes, betas see themselves as less dominant males, withdrawn, obsessional, and curatorial in their cultural habits. But how, exactly, does “hegemonic masculinity” accurately sum up a scene explicitly identifying as beta male? And can “traditional ideas about gender” really be bursting forth from an Internet culture that also features gender-bending pornography, discussions about bisexual curiosity, and a male My Little Pony fandom? In fact, a great deal about the beta-male rebellion runs counter to theories of masculinity advanced by scholars like R. W. Connell and Michael Kimmel. In her 2005 book Masculinities, Connell lists the words “nerd” and “geek” among the terms that stigmatize marginal masculinities. The beta style draws from a countercultural genealogy and identifies itself against feminism but also against social conservatism, political correctness, mainstream consumer culture, and most important, against hegemonic masculinity itself. As one patiently surveys the varieties of online expression favored by beta males, it becomes apparent that, in addition to their all too palpable sense of self-loathing, they’re further actuated by a pronounced sort of class contempt. One key source of their rage—against both the sexual pecking order and society at large—is that their own sense of superiority over the masses, the unspecial “normies,” is not reflected back to them by others in real life. > The fact that she can't catch the mockery in all the beta commentary speaks to the fact that she really doesn't understand this culture at all. She may have done some research, but apparently the black humor that pervades the dark corners of the internet escapes her. Except that it does not escape her, as she says: The casual racism embedded in this geeky beta world comes wrapped in several layers of self-protective irony Commentators like Coleman have lent a certain credibility to the beta uprising’s contention that its motives are misinterpreted by a public that fails to grasp its unique brand of postmodern wit. Some people, they say, simply “don’t get” that the betas are in it strictly “for the lulz.”
- Archio 11y agoThere are two important points I think the author of this article doesn't really understand. 1. "4chan" is not a person, a club, a worldview, or even a reputation-based comment aggregator. 4chan is website with a constant, ephemeral stream of anonymous comments, and the "culture" between different boards varies quite significantly. This system makes it especially prone to misrepresentation by a media that does not understand it. One could easily write an article entitled "The New Man of Reddit" about disturbing subreddits that exist with deep misogynistic hatred, but people understand that one subreddit does not represent the views of everyone that visits the site as a whole. It is even easier to portray 20-30 4chan users as representative of hundreds of thousands because they all post under the same name, "Anonymous". I know several friends who frequent /g/ (the technology board on 4chan), and the discussion is on technical topics virtually all of the time. 2. There are obviously pockets on certain boards (e.g. /r9k/) with groups of anonymous users that have disturbing thoughts and views. That being said, I think it is a mistake to frame the problem as a website being "like Uber, but for violent misogyny", or making a broad analysis that includes references to decades-long gender dynamics theories. I am NOT defending or endorsing the actions whatsoever of these users. However, if the author were to engage in conversation with some of the more extreme users, she might realize that what many of these people need is help. If she were to read personal stories threads on /r9k/ she might find that a large portion of those people are there because they are not "doing well" in life, at all, and have not "fit in" to society for a very long time. They are often clinically depressed, or have any number of debilitating mental illnesses. There are people there that are in poverty, have crippling anxiety disorders that prevent them from leaving the house, who are addicted to substances and cannot hold a job, and who have never done so much as held hands with a romantic interest even decades into adulthood. There are a disturbing number of people on /r9k/ that were physically and sexually abused as children, and those stories are excruciatingly sad. I don't exaggerate about the prevalence or severity of these problems, I have seen regular popular threads about child abuse and significant social impairment on boards. Misogyny is often not a calculated tactical hatred on the part of these people, but an unhealthy and abhorrent outlet for their desperation. Again, I am not defending their actions and I don't think that those 4chan boards are positive places for people to seek refuge. But I think it is important to recognize why many of them are there, and proceed from a point of compassion for another human being, no matter hard that may be. It is easy and tempting to demonize a group of individuals that engage in repulsive misogynistic commentary all day, but that won't solve any of their problems or those of society.
- NaliSauce 11y agoWait - there are people who take stuff posted on tumblr and 4chan seriously? I purely visit those two places for entertainment. Sure it's a bit repetitive, but the sheer absurdity makes me laugh and that's good enough for me.
- nickthemagicman 11y agoThis was my reaction. It was like someone writing a 3000 word article on "Sociocultural analysis of Gender models relating to HOW the chicken ACTUALLY crossed the road."
- pron 11y agoIf a chicken were to go on a murderous rampage (or even orchestrate a campaign that intimidates -- with threats of death, rape and mutilation -- women into withdrawing from online presence) I think such an article might be justified.
- nickthemagicman 11y agoHilarious that you blame 4chan. There's hundreds of millions of pageviews every month. Might as well blame AMERICA for school shooters or Islam for terrorists. Your gut based fear response is uneducated. If you educate yourself your fear will diminish. I promise.
- pron 11y agoI don't blame 4chan at all, and neither does the author (who, BTW, doesn't talk about "4chan" but about one specific board). Hilarious that you read it this way. But when writing a piece of cultural criticism, it's important to categorize social groups based on cultural narratives (or currents), and the narratives on that 4chan board overlap with those found in the murderers' manifestos and intimidation campaigns. That within every narrative-group some people take things much, much further than others goes without saying. It also goes without saying that discussion groups -- online or off -- are better indicators of the "mainstream" of the groups they represent rather than the most extreme (people who end up behaving violently often eschew gatherings), and most certainly cannot be blamed for violent action. Nevertheless, all sorts of ideological violence are associated with some non-violent ideological groups in some way, and it is disingenuous to claim that there is no cultural association whatsoever between those anti-women rampages and certain online communities.
- nickthemagicman 11y agoIt's very small minded of the author implying these role model philosophies originate and are used in 4chan only. Reddit has /r/theredpill, there's numerous mens activists, and dating groups that all use the model of male gender roles and distinctions that the author has described here. To me this article is just another subtly disguised insincere 4chan hit piece. I knew by the opening paragraph when the article implied that 4chan aids and abets school shooters. Also, the joke is kind of on people who actually take 4chan seriously.
- ghyttttgg 11y agoAlmost didn't touch on /pol/, what a missed opportunity
- brobinson 11y ago/pol/ is a board of peace