3 ms·
Exactly. Geoblocking is xenophobic. And the issue is not limited to EU. Better analogy would be a book store. Imagine, you want to buy a book that's not availa
by shmerl 11y ago
Exactly. Geoblocking is xenophobic. And the issue is not limited to EU.
Better analogy would be a book store. Imagine, you want to buy a book that's not available in your country. You can travel to the country where it's available and buy the book there.
In the digital space, the analogy of travel would be using a VPN to bypass geoblocking. That's why using the VPN for that purpose should be perfectly legal, and those who try to forbid it (Netflix and Co.) are xenophobes (it would be like refusing to sell a book to a foreigner which comes to a store in another country).
The problem of course is that as usual, some try to translate realities of the physical space (with regional market segmentation) to the digital ones, where they don't make any sense. But they are eager to do it when is suites their interests (geoblocking). But when people use the same invalid translation, and virtually travel to bypass geoblocking (VPN), geoblocking proponents whine and want to declare it illegal. Hypocrites.
- maxerickson 11y agoNetflix blocks stuff because the content owners have managed to negotiate different terms in different countries. They are blocking people because the place where they live requires it. Respecting local laws is not xenophobic. The messy implementation of distribution rights does not make sense, but companies trying implement new distribution models are not the ones to blame for it.
- shmerl 11y ago> Respecting local laws is not xenophobic. If local laws forbid selling merchandise to foreigners - the laws are xenophobic themselves. > Netflix blocks stuff because the content owners have managed to negotiate different terms in different countries. They can't use an excuse of content owners' xenophobia for their own execution of xenophobic policy.
- maxerickson 11y agoThe local laws forbid distributing unlicensed content to locals. It isn't US copyright that (hypothetically) prevents Netflix from distributing content in France.
- shmerl 11y agoThen it's Netflix who are xenophobes, since using that law they refuse to serve foreigners. Anyway, this whole mess stems from completely inadequate attempt of translating physical realities into digital space, and hypocritical approach of forbidding others (i.e. customers) to do the same. No amount of demagogical justification will whitewash such xenophobic practice.
- maxerickson 11y agoWhy should companies fight the stupid laws that foreign countries have put in place? Why is it up to the American company Netflix to fix the laws in France? I get that you've chosen your rhetoric here, but you've drawn the lines in the wrong places.
- shmerl 11y ago> Why is it up to the American company Netflix to fix the laws in France? What law in France requires Netflix to ban users who access it through VPN? There is no such law. Same as there is no law in France which says that you should forbid selling a book that's not available in another country, to a customer from that country who comes to a store in France to buy it. So don't shift the blame here. Netflix run ahead and performed xenophobic ban because they decided to, not because they are required by any laws.
- kyberias 11y agoYou know words have specific meanings. Like xenophobia: "fear and hatred of strangers or foreigners or of anything that is strange or foreign" I'm pretty sure these companies don't hate the foreigners or fear them. Please find more suitable words to express your opinions.
- shmerl 11y ago> I'm pretty sure these companies don't hate the foreigners or fear them. Forbidding selling merchandise to foreigners who come to your store based on the fact that they are foreigners is xenophobic. But if you have a better term for it, please describe it another way.
- vinceguidry 11y agoA phobia is an irrational fear of a particular thing. Xenophobia is fear of outsiders. Refusing to sell to them is not fear of them, it's fear of the consequences of not following the law. Which is a rational fear rather than an irrational one. So the charge of xenophobia is wrong on both aspects of the definition that matter. But by all means, reiterate your loaded terminology.
- shmerl 11y ago> Refusing to sell to them is not fear of them, it's fear of the consequences of not following the law. Except there is no such law (unless we are talking about some xenophobic country, Third Reich style). Rather than any laws, they fear that their crazy partners will pull a plug on them. And they are being xenophobic to oblige their insane content overlords. Their exact intentions don't matter however for the end user who is being discriminated. What matters are their actions.
- vinceguidry 11y ago> Rather than any laws, they fear that their crazy partners will pull a plug on them. And they are being xenophobic to oblige their insane content overlords. Neither of which is an irrational fear of outsiders. I agree it's a shitty situation, but you're not going to get anywhere by demonizing merchants. We need to change the system they exist in.