4 ms·
There's a simple solution: Don't use real names online. That eliminates meatspace threats, if done properly. And then compartmentalize. For risky stuff, create
by mirimir 11y ago
There's a simple solution: Don't use real names online. That eliminates meatspace threats, if done properly. And then compartmentalize. For risky stuff, create new personas. In worst case, just burn them down.
- pmiller2 11y ago> There's a simple solution: Don't use real names online. Tell that to Facebook.
- jholman 11y agoThere's a simple solution: don't use Facebook.
- pmiller2 11y agoThat's my current and likely future solution.
- mirimir 11y agoThere are work-arounds. Not easy, mind you, but doable. Mostly only scammers will bother.
- tomjen3 11y agoNot much of a problem, just let your name be Mustafa Jones. It's a never going to fall for their real name policy.
- tajen 11y agoWhen you have a company, your name and contact is on every commerce registry document.
- mirimir 11y agoDPR had a company, with none of that stuff. If he hadn't been so careless, he still would.
- skybrian 11y agoThat's good advice. But it's not a sure thing because most people will make mistakes. Or maybe their friends will.
- mirimir 11y agoYour sets of online friends and meatspace friends must not overlap.
- thaumasiotes 11y agoSure they can overlap. They can't knowingly overlap.
- mirimir 11y agoMaybe. One never knows. But areas of interest shouldn't overlap either, so friend overlap is less likely. The bizarre possibility is knowing people online via multiple pairs of pseudonyms ;)
- tlrobinson 11y agoMost people are terrible at OPSEC. If your online persona is used long enough and garners enough attention your real identity will almost certainly become known (extreme example: Ross Ubricht). This is compounded by the fact that people tend to say things they wouldn't otherwise say if they knew they weren't anonymous. The other issue is it's harder to capitalize on the reputation of online personas in the real world, if you care about that sort of thing. If you don't care about reputation online or offline then just generating new identities on a regular basis could work well.
- mirimir 11y ago> Ross Ubricht He initially used his real name for a StackExchange account, which was later linked to DPR and SR. But you're right about downsides. If you want online personas and real world identity to be unlinked, you can't capitalize in ways that link them. But you can still capitalize in parallel. In the real world, I have no interest in privacy etc. Here, I don't draw on my real world reputation. It is sad, though, that I don't get to meet online friends, attend meetings, etc. So it goes.
- tlrobinson 11y ago> He initially used his real name for a StackExchange account, which was later linked to DPR and SR. Like I said, terrible at OPSEC :)
- UVB-76 11y ago> The other issue is it's harder to capitalize on the reputation of online personas in the real world, if you care about that sort of thing. That's the trade-off, and it's why I don't sympathize too much with people who go online to get publicity, then complain about the negative attention that comes along with it.
- grey413 11y agoThat's not how public figures work. Influential public figures are influential largely because they are credible. Credibility requires history. Anonymity precludes history. Take Jeff for example. Jeff has a history. Jeff is a credible game developer with an impressive development history. He's a known factor in the creative community. He's got credibility out the wazoo. As such, we give his words extra weight because of that. In an alternate universe where this article was written by internet-man-of-mystery Bleff Blogel, we probably wouldn't be having this discussion, because he would have no history to back up his points. It just wouldn't have the same impact.
- thaumasiotes 11y agoAnonymity precludes history. Pseudonymity doesn't.
- Odin78 11y agoA prominent example is the mastermind behind DotA, Icefrog. The public has no idea who he is despite the fact that he has been quite famous for several years.
- lsc 11y agoPersonally? meatspace threats aren't the problem for me. Which is important, because I think that in a lot of contexts, your "real name" conveys a lot of credibility. I mean, sure, _why could write a technical book and have it be accepted without a real name, but I'm not nearly that good. I also, uh, I really like bragging about the technical book in real life, so compartmentalization would remove some of the reward I get. It would probably make me a less irritating person, too, but hey, I'm talking about me here. The part of the article that really struck home for me: > They all have something in common. It never fails to amaze me, but a single mean email or bad review can send them into a spiral. Like, they'll still be obsessing over it days later. I think, "Wow. After all these years, they still won't let this stuff roll off of them?" And then it happens to me. It's largely an emotional issue... but when I create, and I think when most people create, it is for largely emotional reasons, too. Of course, it's also, uh, well, I feel kind of embarrassed for admitting that anonymous words can make me feel anything. And it's not like I want to silence thoughtful criticism, even if it's hurtful. (I think there's a line in there somewhere; part of that line is content... how well thought-out is the meanness, and part of it is repetition.) >Suppose someone gets angry at me for what I write. He gets a bunch of friends together and they give my games bad reviews on Steam and iTunes. >This is really mean and genuinely harmful, and there is not a damn thing I can do about it. They will cost me earnings, and I have no recourse. They walked up, punched me in the nose, and strolled away, and I could do nothing. which isn't something I've personally experienced, but is something I feel some fear of. Probably not as much as a real creator would feel, just because creating, for me, is almost entirely social; my living expenses come from elsewhere. I mean, yes, I think that there is a place for a nom de plume, especially if you are working in two different areas with two different or conflicting generally accepted social mores, That helps, I think, mostly by setting expectations with your readers; It's not so much that your pen name is especially secret, but that it gives the reader an idea what to expect, and if they don't like the sort of thing you do under one particular name, well, there's a convenient way to avoid it. Ian Banks and Ian M Banks are a particularly not-secret example of this; choose the former if you like literary fiction, the later if you like science fiction, and it's pretty obvious that if you just enjoy the man's writing more than you care about genre, you can pick both. More commonly, you see writers penning erotica under an assumed name, and then later, after they have made it with regular novels, their real name is revealed, like Anne Rice/ Anne Rampling But... the point here is that if I'm creating for public consumption, and a big part of the return is the public reputation, then compartmentalizing, sure, can make the loss of one persona less catastrophic, but it's still a pretty big deal, and for a lot of people, changes the equation to the point where it doesn't make sense to have a public persona at all.
- CM30 11y agoYeah, this is how we told to use the internet in the olden days. Don't give out personal information online, don't tell every random person your name or what you look like, realise that no one is who they seem on the internet. Unfortunately, this means that: Your credibility might take a hit, since people tend to be suspicious of anonymous or pseudononymous sources. You might become less famous/popular in general.