4 ms·
There is definitely an Uber presence on HN doing damage control.
by colordrops 11y ago
There is definitely an Uber presence on HN doing damage control.
- dang 11y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11512701 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11512701 and marked it off-topic.
- SquareWheel 11y agoPeople sure love to throw out the shill card without providing any proof.
- chris_wot 11y agoPerhaps, but the comments are a bit silly given what the parent poster says: 60% of Android users are affected by this. Why do Uber need that permission in the first place? What exactly are they doing with the permissions that are granted?
- mirimir 11y agoThey want to black-box your mind, of course ;)
- Johnny555 11y agoIt would make a pretty poor shill if it were easy to prove it.
- vehementi 11y agoThe fact is there are shills everywhere. It's hard to prove them in all cases. But it is a "big" and important industry for companies to anonymously and without accountability do damage control. There have been articles and AMA's etc. from people who had worked for these firms and it's really disgusting. So it's not people with tin foil hats speculating that shills might exist - we know shills exist and are pervasive. Given that, we should have a certain non zero belief that any given poster is a shill. Not sure what is the best way to proceed when you know for sure that there are spies around you all the time. That's a bigger discussion. But jumping on people as if we should have to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that there's a shill is really counter productive and helping "them" win.
- SquareWheel 11y agoThe existence of past conspiracies does not offer proof of new ones. Likewise, the fact that shills have existed in the past does not mean they exist here and now. The burden of proof is still on the one making the claim. It's not only irresponsible but dangerous to take a guilty until proven innocent approach. You should expect somebody to prove it if they're making a claim. That's not letting anyone "win". Look at profiles. Look for unusual voting patterns. Is it more likely that Uber is secretly watching and manipulating a forum for hackers, or could it be that a lot of people here actually quite like Uber as a company? Occam's razor suggests the latter. Or maybe - like me - this story just seems shaky as hell with people not understanding that Android permissions (like license agreements) often over-extend themselves. That a permission requiring X doesn't mean X is being used. All the time we see things like "App requires contacts list" where it's only grabbing the owner's info. Honestly, playing the shill card is lazy and irrelevant. If you have proof, show it -- otherwise you're just spreading FUD.
- fullshark 11y agoOr some people on HN work for Uber, a near certainty given the company's size.
- lorenzhs 11y agoIn that case, the established, respected and ethical way is to state that affiliation in the comment.
- LeoNatan25 11y agoI don't get why people working there would defend their company's shady tactics. But then again, I never understand why people blindly defend their countries, sport teams, etc. If the tactics are not shady, come out and plainly state it. No such statement has been made that I can see.
- sangnoir 11y agoUber are mold-breakers who are well known for 'disrupting' "the established, respected and ethical way" of doing X. They are simply revolutionizing the old-fashioned and corrupt HN commenting industry.
- AnkhMorporkian 11y agoOr, alternatively, people (like me) who don't like a witch hunt. I have no affiliation with Uber, no affiliation with ride-sharing or taxis, have never used them, but I think the entire situation is being blown way out of proportion. Uber certainly doesn't need me jumping to their defense, but it annoys me when people read malicious intentions into something that has a perfectly reasonable non-malicious explanation. Sure, malice does sometimes exist on these things, but most instances of this stuff in major apps turn out to be entirely benign. Ill-planned perhaps, but not malicious.
- jetcata 11y agoOn HN, who is able to delete comments?