2 ms·
It breaks my heart every time I see yet another VR Roller Coaster Demo, which seem to be all the rage with self-defeating VR evangelists trying to excite and ed
by DonHopkins 11y ago
It breaks my heart every time I see yet another VR Roller Coaster Demo, which seem to be all the rage with self-defeating VR evangelists trying to excite and educate ordinary people about its possibilities.
VR Roller Coaster Demos are the epitome of what VR is NOT about. It's the equivalent of setting a movie camera up in front of a stage to film a play. It's the antithesis of interactive simulation: No sidepaths. No exploration. No freedom. [1] It's literally railroading. [2] The worst thing that often happens after a VR roller coaster ride is that you take off the VR headset and say "thank God that's over!"
VR experiences with sidepaths, exploration, freedom, simulation, social interaction, and artistic content creation, gives you a much better impression and understanding of VR's capabilities.
You don't need to explore every place in GTA or Minecraft to realize that it's an open world. It's good VR if you walk away with the feeling that you haven't already been everywhere, done everything, there's more to see, things you still haven't tried, ways to create things, express yourself, interact with other people, and affect the outside world, so you want to come back later to see more.
It's not just about throwing in a bunch of navigable locations that are interconnected in a more interesting graph than a linear hallway. It's about simulation, where objects and characters in those places have rich interesting behaviors that interact with each other and the players, as opposed to a museum you can wander around but not touch or move anything or interact with anyone else.
The other sadly common VR demo that's the epitome of what VR is NOT about is literally the equivalent of setting a movie camera up in front of a stage to film a play, only worse: VR home movie theater simulations, like the Netflix app.
Sure, in some minor ways, watching a movie in VR might be better than watching it on a flat screen, but it's much worse in many other ways. How can you possibly win when you're using a VR headset to SIMULATE watching a movie on a flat screen? You can't see where your popcorn and soda are, you dip your chips in the ash tray, and you knock over your bong when reaching for your peppermint paddies!
[1] http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/NoSidepathsNoExplorationNoFreedom http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/NoSidepathsNoExpl...
[2] http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/Railroading http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/Railroading