8 ms·
India's Plan to Bring Digital Banking to 1.2B People
- hackuser 11y agoExciting, but I'm wary of journalism that presents no critical voices. This was interesting: Srikanth Nadhamuni, chief executive officer of Khosla Labs, said the best way to think of the project is by comparing it to how shampoo was introduced in India. Decades ago, most people couldn't afford to buy an entire bottle of shampoo, so Unilever, Procter & Gamble and other companies sold them in small sachets that people could afford to buy, paving the way for marketing everything from detergent to toothpaste in rural areas. Nadhamuni is betting that the new digital payments system will be be low-cost, high-volume, like a "shampoo-sachet revolution in the financial sector." Perhaps this tech could help with micropayments elsewhere.
- x5n1 11y agoFunny reading that, multinationals introduced relatively useless products to the masses using small quantities they could afford. The first hit is free. This is more about control then actually improving anything. India still has problems with terror that could be better tracked if all finances could be scrutinized. Corruption too. If we can only get Pakistan to do the same.
- hackuser 11y agoWhy are toothpaste and shampoo "relatively useless"? I believe there are many health benefits to using them. I don't know for sure, however, because I've never tried going without them for long ... let me know how that goes.
- x5n1 11y agoFor toothpaste they were already using other things. And shampoo does not have health benefits. Maybe it makes you smell a bit better, but rural Indians don't care too much about BO even now. ex for toothpaste: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3545237/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3545237/
- jeremyt 11y agoI can't even begin to describe how condescending your comment comes across as.
- jakub_h 11y agoSetting aside the fact that condescending comments aren't mutually exclusive with true ones, I wonder if those packagings weren't "relatively useless" simply for the fact that small packagings ususally tend to be more expensive in the long run. It's more or less the same problem as with poor people in developed countries not being able to save money on batch buys, especially in case of supermarket discounts.
- jeremyt 11y agoThat's not what he said. You're putting words in his mouth.
- loeg 11y agoShampoo is maybe useful. Some sort of soap + scalp action, occasionally, is beneficial. Plenty of people in the west don't use shampoo or use it rarely. You don't really need toothpaste. It's the brushing part that's good for removing detritus from your teeth. Edit: Downvote with no comment? How is this comment non-constructive, so I can avoid doing it in the future?
- hackuser 11y agoI didn't downvote you, but perhaps somewhat extraordinary claims require a little evidence.
- loeg 11y agoThey aren't especially extraordinary claims. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shampoo#No_Poo_Movement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shampoo#No_Poo_Movement https://www.quora.com/How-much-less-effective-is-brushing-your-teeth-without-toothpaste https://www.quora.com/How-much-less-effective-is-brushing-yo...
- coolsank 11y agoI'll disagree with the fact that multinationals like Unilever and P&G start producing and marketing sachets in India. This was pioneered by an Indian entrepreneur Chinni Krishnan[1]. These firms just ended up copying their business model. [1] http://www.rediff.com/money/2007/mar/22bspec.htm http://www.rediff.com/money/2007/mar/22bspec.htm
- manifestdissent 11y agoIn a country where genocide and sectarian violence are a regular occurrence†, I am sure that a detailed database of religious affiliation, biometrics, photographs, and addresses won't be misused. Much like the Dutch census, history will look back at this registry of citizens with horror. † http://time.com/3545867/india-1984-sikh-genocide-anniversary/ http://time.com/3545867/india-1984-sikh-genocide-anniversary... http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/apr/07/narendra-modi-massacre-next-prime-minister-india http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/apr/07/narendr... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graham_Staines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graham_Staines http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-30288169 http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-30288169 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Christian_violence_in_India https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Christian_violence_in_Ind... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Violence_against_Muslims_in_India https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Violence_against_Muslims_in_In...
- urmish 11y agoSince you conveniently decided to not show violent acts against Indian Hindus, here are some links on Anti-Hindu violence for sake of completeness. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christian_terrorism#India https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christian_terrorism#India https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Islamic_terrorism_in_India https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Islamic_terrorism_in_... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religious_violence_in_India#Religious_violence_against_Hindus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religious_violence_in_India#Re... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethnic_cleansing_of_Kashmiri_Hindus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethnic_cleansing_of_Kashmiri_H... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persecution_of_Hindus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persecution_of_Hindus Mostly Islamic terrorism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terrorism_in_India https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terrorism_in_India https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Violence_against_Hindus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Violence_against_Hind... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Hinduism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Hinduism
- dominotw 11y agoI think GP was pointing out the fact that people in power are infact hindu nationalists who can misuse power. Islamic terrorists are not in power, hindu nationalists are.
- MikeNomad 11y agoAudacious plan? That would be getting their 1.2 Billion people reasonable access to fresh water and indoor plumbing.
- urmish 11y agoSo any other plans should be put on hold while doing this? Access to sanitary facilities has been one of the prime agendas of Modi's elections and he is delivering on it too. http://qz.com/505276/narendra-modis-most-popular-move-so-far-sending-millions-of-indians-to-the-toilet/ http://qz.com/505276/narendra-modis-most-popular-move-so-far...
- MikeNomad 11y agoSigh. No, I did not suggest that all other initiatives should be put on hold. The pivot, fulcrum, etc. for my comment was the use of the word "audacious" in the article title. Since the use of brevity has... muddied the waters: I don't think the deployment of yet another digital payment method that allows for the highly centralized storage of personal information, in a country that does not yet have enough toilets (yes, there is an initiative under way) or reasonable access to fresh water, qualifies as audacious. I suppose I may have pulled up short on the Audacity Scale by copping low with sewage and water, instead of mentioning crime and air pollution. Of course, YMMV.
- woodandsteel 11y agoSeems like India is leap-frogging way past where the U.S. financial system is. On the other hand, I worry if all this personal ID data got hacked.
- Veratyr 11y agoThey seem to be starting from scratch and the U.S. financial system is probably the worst system available in first world countries so it makes sense that they'd skip it. It'd be fantastic if the U.S. would follow their example and take more than baby steps out of the 20th century.
- rahulr 11y agoHacking is definitely a worry. A bigger problem might be communicating and teaching people not to part with this information easily.
- catchmrbharath 11y agoIndia is way ahead of the US financial system. I am a student here in US and I can't really fathom how bad the US financial system is. - Intra bank wires / transfers are free and happen within 10s - Cheques are free - You don't have a system where you can lose all your money if you give your handwritten cheques to somebody (who came up with echeques anyway?) - You don't get charged to have a checking account. They pay you interest for your account. - Get a message about every transaction, every withdrawal that you do immediately.
- _jgdh 11y agoInter bank transfers are also instantaneous and cost $0.08 per transaction
- aptwebapps 11y agoI'm not going to argue against the general thesis that the US banking system is antiquated, but I gotta pick these nits: - Checks are usually free in the US. - You don't usually get charged to have a checking account in the US. - The lack of interest on most US checking accounts is due to the very low inflation rate and nearly zero federal rate. Adjusted for inflation, what is the interest rate of your Indian checking account? Back in the 70s when inflation was high in the US checking account that carried interest were not uncommon. I do seem to remember that they were called something else, but I can't remember right now.
- apo 11y agoThe plan is based on a national identity system with 80% penetration: > So far, India's attempt to assign every citizen a unique 12-digit number associated with a person's unique iris, fingerprint or facial features, is succeeding—just last week, Aadhaar reached its milestone of registering 1 billion people. With more than 80 percent of Indians enrolled, it gives the payments system a solid base to build on. This reminds me of an article I read awhile back talking about the things that technology has made disappear. Farms. Factories. Horses. Many diseases. And so on. It ended with the question: what fixtures of current life are likely to disappear in the future? A commenter responded with one word: "privacy."
- simula67 11y agoI held off for a very long time. I realized finally that if it is OK for me to give these details to foreign governments ( for visa ) atleast I should not be so uneasy about giving it to the Indian government which ( at least theoretically ) have the responsibility to defend my interests.
- r0h1n 11y ago>> ...giving it to the Indian government which ( at least theoretically ) have the responsibility to defend my interests. That's an assumption not borne out by facts. The Indian govt. has denied that citizens even have a right to privacy [1]. And there is no recourse (or even disclosure requirements) if a citizen's data is lost, stolen or misused under the Aadhaar ID system [2]. This is not say Aadhaar or the Indian govt. are bad, but I'm just contesting your point Indians "should not be so uneasy" about giving up their biometrics and other data to the govt. There are massive, valid concerns. [1] - http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/No-fundamental-right-to-privacy-to-citizens-Centre-tells-SC/articleshow/48171323.cms http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/No-fundamental-righ... [2] - http://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/aadhaar-bill-the-basis-of-privacy/ http://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/aadhaar-bil...
- mtgx 11y agoBanks can't arrest you for violating bogus immoral crimes. Your government can. You should be much more afraid of the government violating your privacy than your banks.
- prebrov 11y agoHere's an anecdote about India. They started requiring customer authorisation on all card transaction recently (signature doesn't cut it and no Paywave for you). There were reports on how that that forced Uber to use local payment gateway. Anyway, couple months ago I was in Chennai, went to a restaurant with a customer and when the bill came which customer didn't give me a chance to pick up, they handed over a card AND a PIN number for the card. I was shocked, naturally. The customer explained to me this is standard practice and "a requirement" now for locally issues cards. It isn't really, but since most terminals are wired and installed at the checkout counter, Customers aren't invited to enter the PIN over at the other end of the venue and aren't keen to, frankly. It is upper class who uses cards for payments and psychologically and culturally they're expecting a full service. Walking to the terminal to enter a PIN is a bit of a "walk of shame". So, that's how best government intentions turn into known, en-masse and country-wide security hole and a direct breach of banking service contract, that requires customer to keep PIN private and waives any responsibility if PIN is shared. I would not at all be surprised if this 12-digit personal API ID will be shared just as easily as a card PIN.
- supergreg 11y agoI was under the assumption that the 12-digit ID is public data, the bank account number, not the password to access it. Unless they can scan your iris and derive the number themselves to identify you, which makes it similar to a bitcoin address, while the private key for that address is your biometric data.
- prebrov 11y agoI very much doubt they plan to equip POS's with biometric readers, not to mentioned I doubt there's a reliable enough tech to deploy at such scale.
- blackoil 11y agoNow a lot of establishments are getting wireless terminals, which they bring to your seat.
- tushar-r 11y ago
- Snargorf 11y agoI take it this plan is going to be executed by the 2% of Indian programming graduates who are employable.
- known 11y agohttp://financialaccessatbirth.org/ http://financialaccessatbirth.org/
- Nano2rad 11y agoPeople were forced to get UID by misinformation. The people were led to believe it was compulsory. Only by intervention of the supreme court, the govt was forced to admit it was optional. This was introduced undemocratically without legislative back up with an executive order. An example of corporate insensitivity to democracy. BJP pretended to be against UID before election. Now they have conveniently forgotten their stand. Now there is legislation for UID, but this was introduced by deception. It was introduced as money bill in parliament, so that rajyasabha could not discuss it(BJP has majority in loksabha). Money bill can only deal with govt finances but it is now used to give approval for data collection, which needs constitutional amendment in a real democracy. This is again undemocratic and fascist. The stated aim of biometrics was to avoid duplication. but by insisting on 10 fingerprints and iris, the real aim is data collection itself. But they are really not sure UID biometrics is enough to avoid duplication, there is condition like you can only apply for it once. UID is successful by deception, ignorance, and undemocratic methods.